10 ms·
Building a field hospital for a pandemic and not needing it is literally dead last in my list of wasteful government expenditures to be angry about. The rationa
by ashtonkem 7y ago
Building a field hospital for a pandemic and not needing it is literally dead last in my list of wasteful government expenditures to be angry about. The rationale that lead to making the hospital was incredibly clear, and that we didn’t need said hospital is a source of relief more than anything else.
- jliptzin 7y agoYea it’s like buying a fire extinguisher and then being mad that you never had to use it
- calvinmorrison 7y agoI think people are more upset with the fact that they are unemployed and their states are locked down. The initial request from my governor was "2 weeks to flatten the curve". After two months, and hearing we never reached near capacity, and our local emergency hospital is also winding down, why are we still closed? Now we're told it could until June
- ashtonkem 7y agoBecause the metrics for “we don’t need this emergency hospital” and “the epidemic is beginning to burn out” are different.
- jaywalk 7y agoBut the whole point of the lockdowns was to "flatten the curve" meaning to prevent the hospitals from becoming overwhelmed. That's been done.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThe risk of a second wave is still known, and cases are still rising in quite a few states.
- calvinmorrison 7y agoAnd the risk seems fairly small if you look at the numbers. But then you're some sort of conspiracy nut. In Philadelphia, half of the cases are in nursing homes, and more than half are of people older than 60 years of age. There is risk to opening the country, but telling old people to stay home seems more sane than keeping people from being able to make ends meet
- ashtonkem 7y agoAt least 0.16% of NYC is dead from COVID-19, and that number will rise as both the disease continues and we go back and discover cases we missed. If those numbers hold nationwide, you’re talking about half a million people dying or more. I personally wouldn’t want to argue for putting half a million in an early grave for the sake of opening up.
- taurath 7y agoI don't think you're a conspiracy nut, and you're right that the risk is fairly small right now in places where there have been few confirmed cases. But an exponential growth rate means the risk not small for very long. Covid-19 is the leading cause of death in the US right now. That we don't have the ability to test people before they go back to work is a huge problem. We can't even catch when someone has a fever. > In Philadelphia, half of the cases are in nursing homes, and more than half are of people older than 60 years of age That has little to do with the infection rate and a lot to do with who gets tested. In nursing homes people are getting monitored all day. There are many countries that are far more dense than the US that are currently open, because they test everywhere and prevent people effected from being out.
- vkou 7y agoThey are still rising in a few states that have locked down. I have to wonder, what do the people pushing to re-open expect will happen in those states?
- greedo 7y ago"It'll disappear, just like a miracle."
- gizmo385 7y ago"The epidemic is beginning to burn out" is also very different from "everything can go back to normal now". We saw how quickly this can get out of hand if left unchecked last month. If people rush to get back to normal and pretend that things are fine, it's just going to happen again.
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt’s depressing that people have already forgotten the lessons from last month.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoAnxiety over an inability to procure resources due to economic uncertainty for the future and lack of income is also an epidemic.
- leesalminen 7y agoIt's depressing that people think 25% of the workforce can be out of work for an indeterminate period of time without massive, potentially society-ending effects.
- carapace 7y agoNo one thinks that.
- mdemare 7y agoI think that. Specifically, I think that first world societies can afford to give 25% of the workforce a paid sabbatical without ceasing to exist. And I find it depressing that there are people who think this is a shock that rich societies cannot absorb. Sure, it'll be painful. Taxes will have to go up afterwards, the retirement age might have to rise. But it's possible.
- bigbob2 7y agoI can only assume you mean without drastic changes to our current economic system, because otherwise in this modern age of automation that seems entirely possible.
- malandrew 7y agoIt's not an epidemic any longer and hasn't been for a while. It's a full blown global pandemic headed towards being endemic long term. All three are very different scenarios that require different strategies and where we should have very different expectations for what is and is not achievable. People are praising countries like New Zealand, but what's their endgame? Be in a situation where their citizens can't even safely travel from their country until global herd immunity is achieved because every vacation or business trip is a chance to end up being sick far from home? This isn't going away just like the seasonal flu and common cold are not ever going to go away.
- lostlogin 7y ago> People are praising countries like New Zealand, but what's their endgame? Be in a situation where their citizens can't even safely travel from their country until global herd immunity is achieved because every vacation or business trip is a chance to end up being sick far from home? Yes. And I’ll have this over every alternative I’ve seen so far. I’m in New Zealand.
- jsight 7y ago"Flatten the curve" != "wait until the epidemic burns out" The fact that the rhetoric started with one and ended with the other makes the whole process feel dishonest.
- evultrole 7y agoWe literally have to talk about goals as they come up. It's not that complicated. It makes no sense to keep saying "flatten the curve" as a goal once we achieve that goal, and it makes no sense to say "wait for it to burn out" during a period of skyrocketing growth. Once we get over the exponential growth, we then have to wait for it to drop. Otherwise we'd just go right back to exponential growth. All you people acting like "oh, the curve flattened, now we can go back to normal" are the kind of people that caused three massive spikes in the 1918 flu. We're very likely to have a second spike that is way worse than the first because of this attitude.
- jsight 7y agoLiterally noone is saying "go back to normal". If the goal was to get it to burn out, the initial statement should have been "we need to isolate until it burns out". That was not the initial sell to the public.
- zzleeper 7y agoWell look at Wuhan, Europe, etc. Had people in the US taken the lockdown seriously, we would have ended with an Rt below 1.0 (ideally WAY below 1) so we would be more than ready to reopen now. Instead, people keep doing crap and getting infected, and here we are stuck at home for two months.
- xienze 7y agoIt’s more like experts telling you that models predict you’ll need 50 fire extinguishers to put out a kitchen fire, you express skepticism, and you’re branded a science-denying lunatic.
- Loughla 7y agoThe problem is much media, and especially social media, is using things like these unused field hospitals to justify that the problem was never that bad to begin with. Which is exactly what people said would happen if stay-home orders managed to flatten the curve. I hate this all so much. I am honestly super depressed about how short-sighted many people I know are proving to be.
- Grimm1 7y agoI'm with you on how depressing it is, my biggest take away from this entire thing so far is that people's ability to link cause and effect is much lower than I had previously estimated.
- jtbayly 7y agoHave you seen any attempts to actually put cause and effect together for stay-at-home orders and number of deaths? The only attempt I've seen to quantify it found no statistical connection between the two, but high connection between population density and deaths.
- ashtonkem 7y agoAny attempt to blame fatalities solely on population density is going to run into problems the moment they look at Southeast Asia.
- jtbayly 7y agoPlease. That's not what I said. I said that there was a measurable connection between them. Any epidemiologist will acknowledge this. The point is that it could be seen and measured in this case. But when they attempted to find a connection between shutting down early or late (in the USA), no effect was found. The point being, the shocked horror that people already "forgot" the lessons learned last month is silly if that lesson wasn't learned and wasn't even true. The claim could do with some actual evidence. And I'm not even saying it's not true. I'm just saying this is the only attempt I've seen to actually analyze it, and it came up the opposite way. Can you point me to anything that shows the claim is true? https://www.wsj.com/articles/do-lockdowns-save-many-lives-is-most-places-the-data-say-no-11587930911 https://www.wsj.com/articles/do-lockdowns-save-many-lives-is...
- DiffEq 7y agoThis building of field hospitals is just another stupid thing we did in response to the models. None of the models have been accurate and truth be told this whole thing is a debacle because we made myopic decisions based upon models that are never right and can not ever be right. These models are the modern version of a crystal ball; they remain attractive because they promise to predict the future; but these have been a false promise. Whether it be the models that predict who will be president, which stock to buy or how a pandemic will play out, the models will be wrong. By now - these models should be considered a pseudoscience as real life events have thoroughly discredited them over the decades. What to do then? Well instead of listening to experts - whose vision is that of their narrow field - we need wise leaders that can detach, see the whole picture and use wisdom. But alas...shall we ever have a wise person to lead us again? I don't know but it seems after a casual look over our modern history the entire living generation has not seen one of these kinds of men. It doesn't seem if there was a wise man among us all that we would recognize him.
- dnautics 7y agoOr at the very least have leaders who are brave to disclaim dramatic actions like constructing field hospitals as precautionary and say that the models may not come true in from the start. Instead we have leaders that use the worst "scientific" projections as received truth to get public support, then cargo-cult their policy without being frank about it (china did X, south korea did Y, so we must). That is what I think causes backlash.
- paul7986 7y agoMore stupid media trying to cause outrage when a month prior the outrage was there's not enough medical resources.
- wernercd 7y ago"The rationale was incredibly clear" If you trust the same kind of "Scientific Modeling" that create Hurricane Path Predictions. Notorious for being hysterically wrong. Then sure... that's wonderfully "clear"... If, instead, you look at "models" and "projections" as junk science that's easy to prove wrong by simply looking at any model and how horribly wrong it's been in the past? Like... the COVID models have been horribly wrong so far... Then no... it's not "incredibly clear"
- taurath 7y agoWhich models on COVID are you referring to that are horribly wrong? Also curious why you think the US was so badly effected compared to say south korea or thailand? Do you think it would be safe for everyone to go back to relative normal? What would your prediction of the effect be? What data would you trust to validate that prediction? I'm asking out of genuine curiosity how someone who I'm assuming is well meaning can get to this position. I'm happy enough to be convinced if your prediction turns out correct as there will be plenty of different states that are going to do a variety of strategies.
- wernercd 7y ago"Which models" the ones projecting 2.2 million deaths... the ones based on 4% fatality rates. "do you think it would be safe" With the data thats coming out? Yes. Absolutely. COVID is turning out to only be a little more dangerous than the Flu and "lockdowns" are not slowing or stopping the spread of the virus. "How can someone get to this position" Honestly... January WHO was saying COVID didn't pass person to person and models were predicting 2.2 million dead in the US alone. I'm not making a prediction... I'm casting aspersions on the "predictions" that have been used to feed opinions like "do you think it would be safe?" as if we are all going to die - 99.5% of those who get it survive. Worse than the flu but not worth shutting everything down (which hasn't stopped it at all - look at New York). Personally I know we can protect those who need extra protections (Old, ill, etc) without unproven shutdowns based on faulty models fed with bad data. Why do I feel this way? Because I know that hurricane predictions are "Scientific models" and are wrong just like "market predictions" and all other forms of prediction based models based on past data.