6 ms·
With the biggest incarceration rate, greatest executions in all the west, and biggest number of cops who kill people, it's amazing how ideas like being the "lan
by coldtea 7y ago
With the biggest incarceration rate, greatest executions in all the west, and biggest number of cops who kill people, it's amazing how ideas like being the "land of the free" stick to the populace...
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoThe police seem free enough, perhaps it's their land. A state of their own, even.
- stronglikedan 7y ago> "land of the free" That just means we're legally afforded more individual liberties than most (if not all) other countries.
- mywittyname 7y agoMost "western" nations provide roughly the same legal rights to their citizens. There's some variance, but there's also a large amount of variance in laws between states within the USA.
- bhupy 7y agoThere's no country in the world that provides, to the same degree as the USA, extraordinarily broad freedom of speech (and association) and the right to keep and bear arms. And, to the extent that citizens of other "western" nations enjoy legal rights typical of republican democracies, it's because the US set the trend in the 18th century. At that time, the concept of a creedal nation obtaining its legitimacy from a governing document, in it providing checks & balances to limit the power of government, along with a bill of rights that guarantee broad protection of rights pertaining to speech, bearing arms, impartial trial, privacy (searches and seizures) — was truly unique to the US. That it is now commonplace in the West is a testament to one of America's many lasting contributions to the world.
- kennywinker 7y agoJust because you did it first, doesn’t mean you did it best. There are so many things in the US that have previously or currently systematically denied liberty to large subsets of americans - but I guess you can publicly advocate for violence against specific groups of people, which you can’t do in many other countries, so you win there! :P Since I know that someone is going to reply “like what?!?” here’s an example I recently learned about: it wasn’t until 1963 that public defenders were widely available as a result of a supreme court ruling. So equal protection under the law was clearly not available before 1963. We all know the rich Can afford better defense to this day, but can you call it justice if you don’t even get a lawyer? Contemporary example: drive west from el paso for an hour or so, today. Well, not today, but when it’s safe to travel. The border patrol checkpoint along i-10 will check your papers if you’re visibly latinx. Freedom!
- bhupy 7y agoYes, it is entirely possible for multiple things to be true at the same time. 1) the US has unique protections of individual liberties (free speech, associations, arms) 2) the US has systematic repression of certain minorities, especially among the police (the vast majority of which is illegal and just inadequately prosecuted) > Since I know that someone is going to reply “like what?!?” here’s an example I recently learned about: it wasn’t until 1963 that public defenders were widely available as a result of a supreme court ruling. So equal protection under the law was clearly not available before 1963. We all know the rich Can afford better defense to this day, but can you call it justice if you don’t even get a lawyer? Right, at the risk of diving into a rabbit-hole of negative vs positive freedoms — the US was never ever the land of positive freedom. It has always been the land of negative freedom, and uniquely so. You can dislike the implications of that all you want, but it doesn't change the fact that the US truly is the land of negative freedom — and that's not a normative statement.
- mindslight 7y agoBeing attacked by a court runs directly contrary to negative freedom though. And with a single systematic infringement of negative freedom, the overarching ideal has been lost due to the contradiction of needing to respond by engaging with a system that requires you to jump through arbitrary "voluntary" hoops.
- coldtea 7y agoWhich other countries? Most other western European countries are free-er and even have better press, and much less (to almost none) religiously motivated BS and puritanism... Heck, for a while people weren't even allowed to ...drink alcohol...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- qqssccfftt 7y agoYou're mistaken; the "free" means "economic freedom", not anything to do with personal liberties.
- sitkack 7y agoI think the Puritans deem freedom to be economic freedom and that your expression should be done through business. Be the change (coins) you see in the world.
- deathgrips 7y agoEven if the US only incarcerated rapists and murderers, we would still incarcerate more than Germany. It's not so simple as you're implying.
- 411111111111111 7y ago> As of 2016, 2.3 million people were incarcerated in the United States, at a rate of 698 people per 100,000. Germany is around 70 per 100000. You were saying?
- deathgrips 7y agoI was saying "Even if the US only incarcerated rapists and murderers"
- function_seven 7y agoI went looking for data to refute this, because it didn't seem right to me. But, looks like you're correct here. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics [0], among all state-level prisoners, 14.3% of them are in for murder, and 13.1% are in for rape. That's 27.4% for the combination, or about 350,000 inmates. 106 per 100,000. If you add in Federal prisoners, the inmate count goes to ~370,000, or about 112/100k [0] https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/p18.pdf https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/p18.pdf (PDF, see table 13, page 21.)
- edmundsauto 7y agoCan people be counted in both categories?
- function_seven 7y agoNo. Those stats are exclusive counts. For the most serious offense only. So inmates who raped and murdered their victim are tallied under the “murder” column.
- 7y ago
- steve76 7y agoHere's an idea. For once in our existence, leave us alone. Don't bomb Pearl Harbor. Don't steal our nuclear weapons and sell mass murder to the highest bidder. Don't lure us into Korea and Vietnam after Pearl Harbor, and then commit a century long mass murder suicide. Don't addict millions of people including children to tons of smuggled drugs. Don't blow up the twin towers. Don't cross use HIV to cross SARS with the common cold and unleash it on the world.
- jariel 7y agoActually it's not contradictory at all, it makes sense. Whenever I visit America I'm astonished at how outrageous and uncivil some people behave. They really do want to press their freedom against the rights of others. Carrying guns is the best example - it's an obvious 'freedom' that massively complicated policing and everything else. Police in the US are rightly very afraid when pulling over someone for something petty like speeding because that person could be upset and have a gun. Where I'm from cops are not afraid because nobody has guns. The woman who defied 'stay at home orders' - how do you deal with that as a cop? She just wants to cut hair to make money to stay alive, but you have to arrest her, which could lead to a confrontation with her and her 'supporters with guns'. An ideology of 'land of the free' will necessarily have excessive conflict at the margins where said freedoms interdict with the ostensible freedoms of others and you have law enforcement in the middle trying to sort it out in sometimes ambiguous situations.
- mywittyname 7y ago> Police in the US are rightly very afraid when pulling over someone for something petty like speeding because that person could be upset and have a gun. Where I'm from cops are not afraid because nobody has guns. They aren't actually scared. Publicly, they might talk about how stressful their jobs are etc. etc., but speak privately with one who is comfortable with you and you'll discover they are not scared in the slightest. They know everyone has their back and that they aren't really in any danger.
- leetcrew 7y ago> Police in the US are rightly very afraid when pulling over someone for something petty like speeding because that person could be upset and have a gun. Where I'm from cops are not afraid because nobody has guns. this sort of begs the question of why direct, in-person confrontation is even necessary for petty offenses. there's always a risk that such an interaction could go south, whether or not guns are involved. to write a ticket, all the cop has to do is record the measured speed and identify the vehicle and driver. with the tools available in 2020, they should be able to do this without stopping the person to ask for their license and registration. save the confrontations and arrests for when the person clearly poses an imminent threat to those around them.
- deepspace 7y agoWell, the justice department decided to let Michael Flynn go free, so the US is still the land of the free for certain definitions of free.
- nerdponx 7y agoBecause ultimately people in the USA who aren't oppressed don't even notice or have to care that other people are being oppressed. Then they are given various -isms and -phobias to not only make sure that they continue to not care, but that in some cases they actively cheer on said oppression.
- UI_at_80x24 7y agoPropaganda is one hell of a drug.
- pinkfoot 7y ago… and to those at the borders clamouring to get in.
- bmurphy1976 7y agoLand of the free, but not for you and me. It's reserved only for those who pay an entrance fee.
- svth 7y ago"Land of the free? Whoever told you that is your enemy."