5 ms·
> lockdown does not always result in a low enough rate of transmission to avoid a crisis. On that topic, Cuomo just declared that among the last batch of infec
by ekianjo 7y ago
> lockdown does not always result in a low enough rate of transmission to avoid a crisis.
On that topic, Cuomo just declared that among the last batch of infected people in NY, more than 80% were apparently respecting the lockdown and staying at home and we have no idea how they were even contaminated. Puzzling.
- usaar333 7y agoThat's a bit of a stretch of what he said (https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/06/ny-gov-cuomo-says-its-shocking-most-new-coronavirus-hospitalizations-are-people-staying-home.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/06/ny-gov-cuomo-says-its-shocki...). * Hospitalizations, not cases and not infections. That skews old/out of the workforce. * The stat is that 66% live at home and 84% not working. * That doesn't mean they are 100% to the letter respecting social distancing. Nor does it mean they don't have housemates that aren't working. (That could be the case, but there's no data).
- aeyes 7y agoDo you have a link? With incubation periods of up to two weeks and cases without symptoms everything is possible.
- rb808 7y agoThat makes sense to me. The lockdown has reduced people getting infected from being out. There are still people getting infected and that is people in institutions (care homes, prisons, hospitals) and people in houses. Ie if one person in a house of 4 gets the virus and passes it on to the rest of the family 75% of people infected were staying at home.
- gpapilion 7y agoGenerally lockdown in the US has been pretty loose. Many people have left their homes, and had the opportunity to be exposed. I also think there is a likelihood that between presymptomatic/asymptomatic transmission, and the possibility of 2 week incubation this seems like a nightmare to track transmission. A friend who had SARS-cov2 was sick for 30+ days. So it’s not clear to me that a mild infection would be over in 14 days.
- stronglikedan 7y ago> Generally lockdown in the US has been pretty loose. I'd like to see the same study done outside of NY, because the NY lockdown was one of the most stringent in the country, from what I've read.
- usaar333 7y agoWas it? It reads about the same as the Bay Area's, possibly even a bit looser.
- kl4m 7y agoIf it's a mild infection, by definition, the immune system has squashed it. If it didn't, the virus would take hold; it's not a latent viral infection like herpes. Edit: okay, okay, I didn't specify "a mild infection that stays mild and goes away". We know complications can arise and the infection can progress into severe symptoms. Plenty of examples.
- smaddox 7y agoThe evidence does not support this viewpoint. Also, things are complicated by the evidence that the worst symptoms are caused by cytokine storm, i.e. an auto-immune response.
- kl4m 7y agoWhich evidence? Are you referring to the "lag" in immune response in the initial stage of infection?
- smaddox 7y agoPerhaps I should have said there is no evidence that I am aware of that supports that viewpoint. Instead, there is evidence that asymptomatic people can transmit the virus. No symptoms does not mean no virus.
- ebiester 7y agoI've worried about apartments for that reason. If air circulation is shared, wouldn't it be possible to transmit from apartment to apartment? I think it would be worth a test, at least.
- Vysero 7y agoNo, the virus doesn't just float around in the air, at least, not for any appreciable amount of time. It's much more likely that people in these apartments are touching the same elevator buttons and then wiping their eyes and contracting the virus.
- tgflynn 7y ago> No, the virus doesn't just float around in the air I'd be interested in any references you can point to that explain why that doesn't happen. A priori I would expect virus particles to be able to remain airborne indefinitely. Viruses are very small, much smaller than pollen grains that I believe are well known to remain airborne over long distances so I would think Brownian motion from collisions with air molecules would suffice to keep them aloft.
- markbnj 7y ago> No, the virus doesn't just float around in the air, at least, not for any appreciable amount of time. Here is a pretty approachable summary of how transmission happens that contains a review of some specific cases where airflow was critical to transmitting the infection: https://erinbromage.wixsite.com/covid19/post/the-risks-know-them-avoid-them https://erinbromage.wixsite.com/covid19/post/the-risks-know-.... None of these occurred in isolated spaces connected by shared ventilation but I would be cautious about saying flatly that it can't happen.
- Vysero 7y agoI didn't say flatly that it can't happen. I said it can't happen at any appreciable distance. Obviously, if someone sneezes in your mouth your going to get sick.
- anoraca 7y agoReference: "Preliminary data submitted by 113 hospitals over the last three days show most new admissions have mostly been staying home; they're predominantly from the downstate area (57 percent NYC, 18 percent Long Island) and people of color. Most of them are older and non-essential employees; 66 percent were admitted from their own residences. Of the new New York City hospitalizations, 90 percent have not been traveling by car service, personal automobile, mass transit or even walking around. If they've been working, they've been doing it from home and apparently weren't going out much, the governor said." https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/coronavirus/subway-shutdown-begins-infection-rates-spike-outside-new-york-amid-devastating-toll-at-home/2404295/ https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/coronavirus/subway-shutdown-...
- fpoling 7y agoIn Wuhan the infection rate went down only when they started to place any person who required quarantine to separated buildings. This points out that perhaps transmission across apartment building is significant.
- abrowne 7y agoI wonder about other people in their households, who may be going outside more or even working.
- dragontamer 7y agoNews alert: Americans lie and/or are misinformed on surveys.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoThere's a strong incentive, if you're going in to hospital with Covid19, to lie. They ask "were you sheltering in place?" and you'd think "if I answer no, will I be denied care?". That's going to make survey almost useless, a secondary survey (eg speak to neighbors) might be better but would still be relatively poor.
- umanwizard 7y agoThat's not what the numbers meant. The majority were admitted from home to the hospital, i.e., they were not institutionalized or homeless.
- dehrmann 7y agoThat data is poorly framed. I have no idea why he's surprised. This is the one I've seen people cite: https://i.imgur.com/b9RAr8g.jpg https://i.imgur.com/b9RAr8g.jpg Cuomo: > 66% of the people were at home, which is shocking to us...This is a surprise: Overwhelmingly, the people were at home...We thought maybe they were taking public transportation, and we’ve taken special precautions on public transportation, but actually no, because these people were literally at home. That chart is titled "Source of Admission," not "Was supposed to be staying home." Someone providing critical services who woke up with a fever and got tested would fall under "home." There's also nothing to compare it to. What percent of people are in those circumstances? To what I think he misread and was surprised by, the idea that most people getting hospitalized were sheltering in-place (a stat I haven't seen), with how many New Yorkers who have been exposed to SARS-CoV2, you'd expect essential workers who are going out every day to be more likely to be immune at this point, those sheltering in place aren't. More people are sheltering in-place than out working, they're less likely to have been exposed, so I wouldn't be surprised to see more of them infected. But again, that's not the data Cuomo was talking about with "66%."
- tedmcory77 7y agoVentilation systems like what happened in South Korea?