3 ms·
...as far as we know, because it's difficult to prove otherwise and would take months. Why the impulse to round off uncertainty to certainty? Ed Yong explained
by skybrian 7y ago
...as far as we know, because it's difficult to prove otherwise and would take months.
Why the impulse to round off uncertainty to certainty? Ed Yong explained it better:
https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/05/coronavirus-strains-transmissible/611239/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/05/coronavir...
- ilitirit 7y agoSo a more more accurate description seems to be "there is no evidence that thinking of the viruses in terms of multiple strains is scientifically helpful".
- AmericanChopper 7y agoThinking of things that aren’t proven to exist is scientifically unhelpful?...
- jraph 7y agoYou, you are going to be crucified by scientists. :-) More seriously, I get your point but many discoveries are done by finally observing something which existence has been anticipated, hypothesized but still unproven. A planet that had an effect on nearby objects because of its gravity for instance. Or the Higgs boson. So, yes, thinking of things that are not proven to exist (yet) is often scientifically helpful. You still want to apply Occam's razor of course.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoYou've cut the context, was that on purpose? The context is a discussion of improving medical interventions during the current pandemic, in that context, at present the argument is that 'considering Covid19 to be separate "strains" (isolates) will not help to treat patients'. Is that clearer?
- AmericanChopper 7y agoIt’s not clearer, it’s a completely different statement. The idea of the answer to a question being “medically unhelpful” doesn’t seem at all related to “scientifically unhelpful”.
- inopinatus 7y agoI’d refine that further to clinically relevant
- colmvp 7y agoI feel like that's an important distinction. In Canada, our officials said in January that asymptomatic individuals were not main drivers of epidemics. And while that may have been true with something like influenza, a more accurate statement would've been we don't have evidence _yet_ that suggests asymptomatic individuals could effectively spread the virus. We proceeded to operate on that assumption by not forcing incoming travelers from infected regions to isolate, unless they contacted health officials with symptoms associated to the virus. We didn't change this stance until late March, well after the virus had infected thousands of people across the country. In contrast, Taiwan implemented mandatory 14-day self-isolations for incoming travelers from specific regions as early as late January. In Ontario, we've had cases of airport taxi drivers pass away from Covid-19. Whereas Taiwan recognized that there'd likely be a large number of people coming home with the virus, so they created special airport quarantine taxis equipped with mandatory masks for passengers and isopropyl alcohol for the driver.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoWorth noting how some people, including mainstream press, have vilified WHO for saying there was "no evidence yet of human-human transmission" (at the point there was no evidence yet), and for saying (paraphrasing) "it's not a pandemic yet, not until there's community spread across global regions" when it wasn't yet a pandemic. So, yes, I'd agree with your 3rd para, but press can spin such statements to create reputational damage which is really underserved.