5 ms·
Yes, the ban may not be perfect, but as a Canadian, I can say unequivocally: I don't need perfect to be the enemy of good. There's no reason to possess these we
by arcticbull 7y ago
Yes, the ban may not be perfect, but as a Canadian, I can say unequivocally: I don't need perfect to be the enemy of good. There's no reason to possess these weapons any more than there's a reason to possess nuclear warheads.
The next bill can ban more, fix the bugs, etc, but the flag has been planted: there's no room for those weapons in Canada.
A huge number of people have wanted to ban weapons like these since Ecole Polytechnique [1] -- and probably much further back. We've been lucky to have few enough such mass murders to remember many by name, and it also makes them horrifying enough that we're not going to sit back and pray the crime away. The Liberal Party (currently in power) ran on banning these weapons. Then they banned the weapons. They did the job they were elected to do.
I don't think that's a good example tbh.
[edit] Let's be super clear when you say "pushed through by a minority government during a pandemic" -- you're seeming to imply that the minority is somehow strong-arming the majority. That's the exact opposite of how that works in the Canadian parliamentary democratic system. A minority government is in a very weak position and can be removed at any time. If this was at all controversial the next confidence motion would be swiftly defeated and the government would fall. A minority government wouldn't do something like this without absolute confidence.
Unlike a majority government a minority government must rule by consensus or face immediate removal. I think they normally don’t even make it past the 3 year mark.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/École_Polytechnique_massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/École_Polytechnique_massacre
- cmdshiftf4 7y agoPAL/RPAL holders, or weapons stolen from them, account for virtually no gun crimes in Canada. Essentially all are carried out with illegal weapons smuggled in from the US. Therefore, the ban is ineffective in serving its mandate, punishes law abiding, statistically harmless individuals needlessly and saddles the taxpayer, of which only 60% of households in Canada are, with yet more debt for nothing. It has also set a very dangerous precedent in Canada as to how "unpopular" rights, not explicitly in the Charter, can be stripped by the pen stroke of a populist. But HN, and this topic in particular, is not the place for this discussion. Good luck to you when the political pendulum swings.
- arcticbull 7y ago> It has also set a very dangerous precedent in Canada as to how "unpopular" rights, not explicitly in the Charter, can be stripped by the pen stroke of a populist. To be fair, if it's not in the charter, it's not a right. You are of course correct re the pendulum and unpopular privileges.
- throwawayosiu1 7y agoI’m a Canadian and I find that absolutely the opposite. 1. > I don't need perfect to be the enemy of good. There's no reason to possess these weapons any more than there's a reason to possess nuclear warheads Slipper slope don’t you say? Quite a lot of guns on that list were not even available in Canada or would be available. Furthermore, we have some of the strictest gun laws around. What you said above to me sounds like we also need to just ban McDonalds and others from Canada too - considering obesity kills more Canadians than gun deaths no? 2. > The next bill can ban more, fix the bugs, etc, but the flag has been planted: there's no room for those weapons in Canada. Have you by chance gone throw the process of getting a PAL? Our issue is not responsible gun owners - it’s the access to illegal guns coming from south of the border and this bill did absolutely nothing to stop it. It was political theater at the end of which a minority of citizens were affected (and they probably didn’t even vote in for the Libs anyways) > it also makes them horrifying enough that we're not going to sit back and pray the crime away By not dealing with the influx of guns from the south - we are literally doing JUST that further more at the cost of law abiding gun owners too.
- arcticbull 7y agoRe 1: If McDonalds were handing out firearms I'd agree with ya ;) The difference is of course that the burger only kills the person ingesting it where a gun kills someone other than the owner. This makes the former a personal responsibility issue and the latter a public safety issue. And of course, you can eat McDonalds safely in moderation without developing obesity, but you can't really get shot safely or in moderation without developing death. Re 2: I have not tried to get a PAL, though I do understand it to be quite an arduous process. Re 3: Indeed more should be done to keep weapons on the US side, however I don't think there's any reason we can't do both things at the same time.
- Talanes 7y agoI agree with you on almost all points, but regarding: > but you can't really get shot safely or in moderation without developing death. I think 50 Cent offers a counterpoint.
- 7y ago
- Reelin 7y agoI'd suggest that you ought to be more concerned about rights and privileges that you don't necessarily value personally (or even see as causing a problem). If you extrapolate what's been happening in China regarding the internet to electronics in general and the rest of the world, the logical extreme is total surveillance, internet censorship, and eventually loss of direct control over the devices that you own. (Only a terrorist or dissident would want to install their own OS!) (Sideloading? What's wrong with the app store?) (Who needs admin anyway?) (Tor? Isn't that the network run by all the sexual predators?) Only a cultural norm of protecting all possible personal rights at nearly any cost, even those you don't personally value or agree with, is likely to successfully stand against such an outcome. The reason is that any particular person isn't likely to make use of (or even feel strongly about) most of the rights and privileges available to them. Put another way, it's your job to protect your neighbor's rights and your neighbor's job to protect yours.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>There's no reason to possess these weapons any more than there's a reason to possess nuclear warheads. I've yet to see any valid reasons to possess drugs or alcohol. With guns, there is at least the justification of self defense. >and pray the crime away. Is that not what is being done with all crimes (drunk driving, but also many assaults) associated with alcohol? There are two ways government can work. You can either have it where you have to justify to the government why you should have something, or you can have it where the government can justify why you should not have something. The former is far worse. The latter only works if the logic used is consistent, else it is really the former in disguise. People always seem to want the former when it comes to guns, but the latter when it comes to things they personally like which have been associated with government restrictions. Why is the double standard held so openly?
- goatlover 7y ago> I've yet to see any valid reasons to possess drugs or alcohol. For recreation, therapy, socialization, experimentation, mysticism, or just because it's my own damn body. > With guns, there is at least the justification of self defense. That would be fine if gun violence wasn't a thing.
- brandonmenc 7y agoAlcohol use sends a person with impaired judgement and often times a short fuse into the public space to wreak havoc. By the millions. How many fist fights, rapes, harassment, spouse and child beatings, car crashes, on the job accidents, chronic illness, and early deaths must society be forced to accept just so people with disposable income can enjoy a nice red wine with their meal? Seems pretty selfish.
- goatlover 7y agoSociety already has been down the road of banning alcohol, and it went over just as poorly as the war on drugs, with tons of social and economic costs.