4 ms·
I like the EFF's mission, but I find many of the EFF's posts like this to be awful and quite propaganda-like in style. They present an issue and spend time talk
by ineedasername 7y ago
I like the EFF's mission, but I find many of the EFF's posts like this to be awful and quite propaganda-like in style. They present an issue and spend time talking about how it's bad, provoking an emotional response of anger or righteous indignation, and leave out the most important details.
In this case, the USPTO released new guidance on how reviewers should consider the Supereme Court's Alice decision. EFF thinks this guidance is bad. They have metrics and talking points. But the EFF fail's to deliver the single most important information:
What did the new guidance say! -- EFF is silent on this.
WHY? I think in this case it's because the EFF doesn't like software patents at all. They know much of their audience feels the same way. So they don't care about actually explaining what the new guidance says-- All they care about is presenting metrics about increased software patent grants that show how bad the new policy must be, because it's doing what the EFF hates: granting more software patents. I find it emotionally manipulative, and the more time goes on the more I avoid their articles.
They used to be better than this.
- jedberg 7y ago> They used to be better than this. Did they? I've been a member for 20 years and I don't remember it ever being different. They've always been a pro-technology anti-patent lobbying machine. All of their materials are biased this way. I don't agree with everything they lobby for, and I tell them that when I renew each year. I know a few of the folks there, and from what I hear, they take that into consideration when they discuss budgeting. But I'm pretty sure they've always been like this.
- pnw_hazor 7y agoCritiquing the USPTO is fine and welcome. But going to bat for Alice is a fools game. Alice is an incoherent and disjointed holding (well several holdings). Which is no surprise because trying to craft a stable informative legal standard that limits or improves so-called software patents based on 35 USC 101 (subject matter/patentabilty) is inherently unworkable. Besides, patent attorneys are usually smart enough to draft around Alice-type subject matter issues. There were so many early Alice rejections at the USPTO and patents invalidated in courts because they usually involved applications or patents that were drafted before Alice was decided. Alice changed the standard out from under them after they were filed or granted. Patent attorneys familiar with software technology could/can easily draft around Alice limitations now that they know what they are.
- Natsu 7y agoWhat I wish they'd said in Alice was that you can't meet the patentability standards piecemeal. That is, I wish they'd said that you can't have an invention where the novel part isn't patentable subject matter and the patentable part isn't novel, like software + a formulaic definition of an ordinary computer. I think that's more or less the state of affairs they wanted to get to, but they never quite worked out any comprehensible way to get to that and just kinda punted.
- pnw_hazor 7y agoI liked the older subject matter standard (I can't remember the case In Re Alappat, maybe?) where the combination of software and hardware is considered the machine under consideration. Thus, novel software running on conventional hardware is viewed in combination as a novel machine. This makes sense to me for some reason. I wish this remained the 35 USC 101 standard for software patents, I think it cleanly resolves subject matter problems. Then the courts and Congress could focus on developing better law using 35 USC 102, 103, and 112 rather than trying to use subject matter, which is by design the broadest patent law on the books.
- Natsu 7y agoYes, this creates a very bright line that's easy for lawyers to follow, but in return it allows every trivial act performed on an ordinary computer that someone has not yet submitted to the USPTO to be an "invention." Given that inventions are not rivalrous and actual practitioners of the art don't generally go around reading patents in the first place (other than, perhaps, those newsworthy due to litigation or sheer idiocy), this makes an area ripe for trivial lawsuits from people taxing the work done by others while providing no actual benefit from the patents themselves. This leaves the two arms of the scale badly unequal. Supposedly, we derive the benefit of knowledge in exchange for patents. Instead, we're getting "do X on a computer" we already know how to do and make for any given X in exchange for a huge number of lawsuits from patents filed by lawyers who have never actually built a thing, who have at best a vague idea as to how something might be done. The real work is the implementation. Maybe you could convince me if they actually had to build the software and release it to all alongside the patent so that society benefited from that when it expired, but the patent terms are too long for such software to be useful at the end and the various patent lawyers I've interacted with are adamantly against that idea.
- slaymaker1907 7y agohttps://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/101_examples_1to36.pdf https://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/101_exam... has some helpful examples that are part of the new guidance. Seems pretty readable surprisingly.
- hcknwscommenter 7y agoExactly. And once the inventor can see these examples and understand how to describe their invention in a way that mirrors these examples, abracadabra eligibility problems disappear. THis is the intended and beneficial effect. In nearly all (all?) cases, the claimed subject matter is narrower and specific to an actual novel and non obvious practical implementation of an "idea." That is the way it should be. The EFF is blowing smoke.
- vikramkr 7y agoWhat does the new guidance say then? I'm curious to hear a counterpoint on the substance of the guidance from someone that might have the expertise to go into it. I agree with you on the EFFs article being substance-free and manipulative, and I'd like to know what the substantive counterpoint is from someone who can interpret the guidance.
- paul7986 7y agoWelcome to every media outlet out there ... from CNN to MSNBC to Fox News ... spewing out their slanted reality to rile up their base who are clueless to what's happening and keep coming back for more outrage. Tune the media out.. watch the press conferences, interviews and dig a little deeper yourself to get the real story. BBC America is pretty decent .. they just tell the news without reality tv outrage drama.
- Hnrobert42 7y agoThe EFF is not the news. That you chose to conflate the two in order push an agenda against journalism is why I downvoted your comment.
- paul7986 7y agoJust like news outlets they are pushing their agenda via media.
- paul7986 7y agoUmmm push agenda .. journalism of today is confusing ... many people are like wth do I believe when many times one side says this (right or left) then that ... Not that JOe ROgan is expert, but he is expressing the same thing I am and im sure the millions of his listeners are thinking the same thing .. see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJYEk1pTLIU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJYEk1pTLIU Anyway, a lot of things I say here on Hacker News are unpopular at the time of writing, but ultimately what Im saying is ahead of the curve like hating the iPHone XS due to size three years ago and that getting downvoted fiercely like i am here .. as of this April I now own the iPhone SE cause Apple saw the data that customers thought same thing ... another is me for years complaining about my meeting Google experience and how horrible they treat fledgling innovators (invite them out.. use their influence ..put their stars in their eyes) then stomp all over them ... a few years later a MIT student shared her same story with email evidence backing up my horrid experience which following Google had all types of PR problems (her story helped light a small flame as Google did no evil in the eyes of all HNewsers which is an influential crowd)... im also ahead of the curve here too ... people are tuning out media, especially political media ..its a joke... all sides. Another, thing I was on a inventor reality TV show in 2015 and pitched share battery power between phones to Intel and Shark Tank/Apprentice producer, Mark Burnett.. in 2019 Samsung built this feature in their phones.. lol ... look at me im great .. not.. just have thoughts/ideas that are unpopular at the time and get downvoted a lot. Anyway im gonna keep sharing my thoughts/etc and continue to get downvoted lol but what im saying most of the time is worth sharing and then some!!!
- nikitaga 7y agoThis EFF release isn't about what technicalities or creative interpretations USPTO used to avoid the complying with Alice because that guidance isn't new, what's new is a report that shows the dramatic effect of their avoidance, and that's what the article is about. If you really wanted to know what the guidance was, literally the first link in TFA leads to an EFF backgrounder that explains it, including linking to the actual source. EFF's mission is to effect positive change in technology. If you disagree with their views on software patents, you should expect to not like what or how they have to say. Their mission is not to convert you, it's to drive support and engagement for their ideals among their supporters and undecideds. I personally do agree with them on software patents, and so I approve of their methods because I can see that they optimize for effectiveness of their campaign, as they should.
- ineedasername 7y agoThe entire article is about how new guidance had a negative impact. I don't think it's a responsible presentation of the topic if the only way you can find out exactly what they're objecting to is by finding another article, which you don't know whether or not it will have that very relevant information, read it, and then link to a third piece of writing to actually get anywhere. The EFF clearly knows what the guidance says, it would have taken little effort to give an abstract of it. But more and more they seem to have little interest in generating reasoned agreement with their cause, only reflexive support induced by anger and indignation. The cynic in me says it's because they realized it works better, gets more donations. But regardless if their intentions, it comes off as a bit scummy.
- madaxe_again 7y ago> it comes off as a bit scummy. And patent trolls? They’re hardworking American businesspeople? Last I checked, their tactics were vexatious litigation, bullying, browbeating, and buying support. In short, if you’re going to fight a pig, you’re going to have to get in the mud with it. If you just stand there making reasoned arguments as to why the pig should lie down, the pig will just look at you, shit on the floor, and continue doing what it was doing.
- baryphonic 7y agoAfter reading the post, I had the same thoughts as you, so I decided to do a cursory review of the _Alice_ case history. The question was whether three patents describing a software system that merely automated a preexisting process using generic hardware was patentable. In the decision, the Supreme Court issued a unanimous decision affirming the court of appeals judgment that the subject matter was not patentable, which itself affirmed the district court judgment (with a caveat I'll get to below). That itself stood out to me as odd, since most cases reaching the Supreme Court involve some sort of difficult question of law, some inconsistency in application of the law between different appeals courts or justiciable constitutional questions. Based on the case history, that wasn't clear. Furthermore, the court of appeals was (as in all patent cases) the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, widely understood to be "captured" by and a tool of the "patent bar." The judges are typically former patent attorneys, and most notably, the Supreme Court often overturns Federal Circuit judgments unanimously. I don't follow this stuff religiously, but I'm not sure I've ever seen the Federal Circuit unanimously affirmed. I decided to dig in more. The case history was a bit more interesting, and crystallized why this thing went up the chain. The case history actually did involve a small amount of disagreement. Initially, a panel of Federal Circuit judges sided with the petitioner _Alice_, who sought to have the parents reinstated. However, the Federal Circuit subsequently performed _en banc_ review where the entire court (save those judges recusing themselves or otherwise absent) sat to hear the case. The outcome of that _en banc_ review was a seven-judge majority (out of ten) throwing out two of the three claimed patents. In addition, a plurality but not a majority of five judges wanted to throw out all of the patent claims. In the world of legal appeals, tie votes affirm the decision of the lower court, but such decisions are not considered persuasive or "controlling." Indeed, the opinion of the seven judge _en banc_ majority was a single paragraph. It's hard for anyone to figure out exactly what a plurality opinion means without resorting to reading tea leaves or other forms of divination. Into this ambiguity stepped the Supreme Court in order to provide clarity to both the appeals court and the rest of the judiciary. The only controversial aspect of this case was whether only two patents were bad or whether they all were. To summarize, every court involved in the case concluded that the three claimed patents covered non-patentable subject matter. The court of appeals explicitly established to serve the interests of patent litigators affirmed this, and the Supreme Court only reviewed the case in order to more definitively demonstrate that the subject matter was not patentable (and it did this in the strongest possible way). All of this leads me to strongly concur with your reading of this EFF post. The _Alice_ case involved a particularly egregious case of nonsense patents/patent trolling, such that not even the Federal Circuit would save it. Far from being some sort of landmark case, the Supreme Court's opinion mostly relies on existing precedent and serves to further clarify the disposition of the US courts toward patentability of abstract ideas. And most bizarrely, USPTO was not a party in this case. While the patent office does need to follow the law including the judgements of US federal courts, they were not bound by _Alice_ and so more or less can ignore it. When I consider the actual facts, I think the EFF is sensationalizing this particular case and heavy-handedly hyping it with provocative framing in order to spread propaganda. I even agree with the EFF nine times out of ten on issues of so-called intellectual property, but they undercut their argument when they push junk like this. This is a far cry from the days when the EFF was defending victims of the MPAA and RIAA or fighting to stop internet censorship or even campaigning against the DMCA and it's subsequent abuses. In short, I affirm your judgment.
- myspy 7y ago> because it's doing what the EFF hates: granting more software patents Is there anything that's good about patents on software?
- amelius 7y agoThe only thing that's good it is that it makes the law less arbitrary. E.g. why should my friends who are in mechanical engineering be allowed patents while I am not? But other than that, there's not much good about it.
- tinus_hn 7y agoSoftware patents could be reasonable if they weren’t about trivialities and their validity period was adapted to the pace of technology. But here we are, the mp3 format which really is obsolete just lost its patent protection. And that’s the exception where the patented material still holds at least some value after the patents expire.
- toyg 7y agoAfter observing politics for a bit, you can easily spot when progressives are winning the argument, because reactionaries will be attacking the communication minutiae, the uncouthness, and not the substance of the debate. It’s the last stage of the “they fight you” phase Gandhi famously listed. Thank you, EFF, for fighting the good fight.