5 ms·
It seems really hard to imagine how that could be so. Why would random commentators or protesters care so passionately about unemployment budgets?
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
It seems really hard to imagine how that could be so. Why would random commentators or protesters care so passionately about unemployment budgets?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoHere on HN somebody posted an analysis of the websites pushing these narratives. I recall it was two guys selling T-Shirts. They discovered the power of the meme, and align it with their business interests.
- txcwpalpha 7y agoRandom commentators and protestors don’t. Certain politicians do, and those politicians have done an outstanding job of convincing those random commentators and protestors that this situation is political one, bringing all of the fervor and zealotry that politics brings. This situation went from being “we are staying inside to defeat the virus” to now “we refuse to stay inside (reopen) because that lets those evil democrats (Republicans) win, and I won’t ever allow that”.
- BEEdwards 7y agoI love how you politically both sides this, when the science is clearly on the stay at home side. Those damn democrats playing politics and listening to the doctors on health issues...
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI'm not sure what you're referring to as "the science". People who disagree with stay at home orders largely acknowledge that staying at home makes it harder for infectious diseases to spread. If you're saying doctors and scientists have cooked up a master plan that will eliminate the coronavirus if we just stay home a bit longer and catastrophically fail if restrictions are loosened at all, I don't think that's true.
- clairity 7y agothe democrats and democratic media (npr, nytimes, etc., which tend to be my news sources) are absolutely playing up the fear and panic for their political ends (elections, legislation, fundraising, and everything else). if you don't see the politics of it, you're just not using your critical thinking skills. the science is not on the stay-at-home side. the science is on the don't-spit-in-other-people's-mouths side. how you effect that has been absolutely politicized.
- txcwpalpha 7y agoI fully agree with you, but I intentionally made it two-sided because AFAIK HN guidelines don't like it when a comment thread becomes clearly politically one-sided.
- BFatts 7y agoTo be clear, no one is asking to stay inside - everyone wants the economy reopened again. But, there's the sensible way and there's the stupid way. The latter method involves just going to back to the way things were and pretend the virus doesn't exist. That is untenable, and the smarter folk who think that a phased opening is a better approach are the ones being shouted down.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoOne of us is getting media bubbled here. I've seen a lot of people argue that they do not want the economy reopened and everyone should stay inside because it's not safe yet. Attempts to engage in a phased opening have produced headlines like "Georgia's Experiment in Human Sacrifice"[1], and major figures are still talking on Twitter about how "No life is worth losing to add one more point to the Dow."[2] [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/04/why-georgia-reopening-coronavirus-pandemic/610882/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/04/why-georg... [2] https://twitter.com/JoeBiden/status/1258184774486642688 https://twitter.com/JoeBiden/status/1258184774486642688
- pwinnski 7y agoI want to stay inside. Most people I know want to stay inside. The economy can limp along for the rest of this year just fine. The sensible way of re-opening involves not doing so now. Texas is still gaining new cases and deaths at a high rate. Our curve is not flattening. And yet with one eye on the unemployment coffers, Governor Abbott is overriding the same local decision-makers he deferred to just weeks ago, and forcing business to re-open. Hair salons open tomorrow, while four of the six days of May so far have set new records for new COVID-19 cases. Everyone I know who works retail jobs would rather be home. Some of them are being forced back, some have never been able to stop working. None of them are happy about it.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoI agree. The beginning of this crisis really did hold promise of 'we are in this together'. And yet it quickly morphed into 'the other guys are out to get us'. I watching all this with genuine worry that things can easily spiral out of control.
- claudeganon 7y agoThey don’t. They’re stirred up by rich people through astroturf groups: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/22/opinion/coronavirus-protests-astroturf.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/22/opinion/coronavirus-prote...
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoYour thesis here is that the movement is made up and nobody actually agrees with it? I guess I don't know how to rigorously disprove that, but it strikes me as unlikely as well. The easiest way to stir people up is to tell them things they already believe! It seems naive to look at even a moderate sized protest and say "oh, nobody actually believes in this cause, it's astroturfed".
- claudeganon 7y agoI believe that their is real discontent in the face of a deadly pandemic and massive unemployment, but also that rich people are harnessing that discontent to their own, cynical ends. These protests would not exist if we had UBI like Spain or a sane, well-managed response like Taiwan. I dunno how much history you’ve read, but the rich cynically exploiting the masses to direct their anger away from themselves and towards their enemies or other scapegoats is hardly a novel development.
- jerf 7y agoUBI can't solve this problem. UBI does absolutely nothing if there's nothing to buy because nobody is working. You can't UBI your way around meat plants closing, restaurants not being staffed, stores closing, and so on. If anything, UBI encouraging more people to not work can only make it worse. The whole premise of UBI is that there's such a surplus that the only sane thing to do with it is to distribute it. There is now no surplus, and indeed credible threats of shortages. Therefore, it is only logical that the rest of the argument is now invalid. Hopefully, only temporarily.
- claudeganon 7y ago
- DuskStar 7y agoBecause they pay for those unemployment budgets, perhaps? You may not agree with that perspective, but it is held by quite a few people.