5 ms·
One issue with fundamental theories that I've seen is that it's really easy to come up with a model that reproduces some aspects of relativity or even quantum m
by jiggawatts 7y ago
One issue with fundamental theories that I've seen is that it's really easy to come up with a model that reproduces some aspects of relativity or even quantum mechanics, especially in some approximation, such as low energies or weak fields. In that regime, you can wave your hand and pretend that everything is linear or nearly so. The symmetries are common symmetries that a lot of algebras or geometries share, so things just "seem to work" almost magically.
This is like saying you've invented a car from scratch because you've made something with mirror symmetry that can roll forward. Obviously, this is missing more than a few details.
What Stephen Wolfram seems to have done is come up with an extremely generic system that can describe anything, in much the same way that a CAD program can use meshes to describe any piece of machinery you'd like to design. That doesn't mean that meshes are equivalent to metal and concrete. Just because meshes can have various symmetries and can be used to represent circular things doesn't mean that a mesh is a car either.
Similarly, in a very real sense the Universe performs computation, because -- duh -- it contains computers. And brains. And many things of that nature. Brains and computers run by the same rules of physics that stars and experimental particle beams do. Hence, the Universe computes. It also computes in the trivial sense that if you add 1 hydrogen atom to 1 hydrogen atom you get 2 hydrogen atoms.
So if you come up with a very generic form of computation, such as automata, or substitution rules, or whatever, of course you're going to find many things that "look like" various aspects of the computation the Universe is performing. But analogies are just that: comparisons of vaguely similar features. That doesn't mean they're isomorphic to each other, nor does it mean that some random theory is actually the rules the Universe follows.
Stephen spends a lot of his time jumping up and down and pointing at some trivial aspect of his theories and saying "Look at this! My theory can perform addition! The Universe does addition too! Hence my theory is the theory of the Universe!"
I've been interested in the fundamental theory of everything for two decades now, and I spend about an hour a day on average poking through random arXiv papers looking for ideas or signs of progress.
I've noticed a few things: Much of Wolfram's criticism of academia and modern theoretical physics is correct. It's much the same as Eric Weinstein's criticism. They both say that the politics and economics of academia make it nigh impossible to rock the boat and come up with radical new ideas. I noticed this too. Modern theoretical physics isn't. It's intellectual wankery and dick measuring as a way of getting pieces of paper and tenure. There's zero motivation or incentive to do anything useful, because the system has slowly evolved over time to disincentivize it.
However, this doesn't mean that their particular "rebel" flavour of TOE is correct, just because the models produced by Universities have gone nowhere. Progress in some arbitrary direction is not necessarily better than no progress at all! Progress in the right direction is needed.
Over the years (decades!) I've developed an acid test to quickly sort the wheat from the chaff:
1) Does the theory even mention particle generations? Bonus points if demonstrates at least three and explains why we haven't found four.
2) Is it a truly local theory in that global communication is never required? (Many current theories implicitly involve "solving" something, which is often implicitly a global minimisation.)
3) Can the theory be applied to single systems, or just ensembles? (Most QM theories automatically fail this one. Single particles exist, single electrons go into higher orbits from a single photon, etc... Either you can model this, or your theory is woefully incomplete)
4) Can it explain the observations of Quantum Mechanics without resorting to the "infinite dimensional" mathematical wizardry? Can it produce computable models, or just symbolic gibberish that I guarantee you no particle "computes" as it goes about its business.
5) Nobel prize winning stuff would explain the origins of constants that are currently experimentally determined inputs. (Most theories I've seen don't even have numbers.)
6) The ultimate requirement is for a TOE to "not only" produce the known observable physical behaviour but to also naturally exclude everything else. That is, the ideal rules should have some sort of incredibly tight self-consistency that can only happen in one way and can only produce physics. For example, an algebra that can only be used to represent valid combinations of particles and fields, and can never represent any other "invalid state" that makes no sense.
Unfortunately, 99% of the stuff I see fail at all of the above. Wolfram's theory does too. His current graph-based theory and his previous cellular automaton theory spectacularly fail the 6-th requirement. They're both nearly unconstrained computation models with infinite flexibility, the exact opposite of a good TOE.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danpalmer 7y agoFrom my understanding of where the research is at, I think you're asking too much of it, and rebutting it on that basis. My understanding is that it is being posited as a category of models, of which one could be the "theory of everything". They haven't said that one of them is, and they know they haven't found the one that is yet if there is one. I'm interested in discussions about why this type of model can't work, rather than people repeatedly pointing out that they haven't found the exact model yet, which seems to be a strawman argument. As for your 6 acid test elements, that's exactly the sort of thing I'd like to learn more about, but in the current wording I feel like I'm missing about a Phd's worth of understanding. I think communicating this in a more accessible form would be great! I understand that theoretical physicists have reasons why they don't like his theories, but I don't understand what those reasons are, whereas I do understand a bit about the theories. This makes it hard (as much as I want to) to be persuaded by physicists.
- jiggawatts 7y agoTo be a bit more concrete, this is a bit like saying "Computers could be used to simulate/represent physical theories, hence studying computers could lead to a theory of everything." That's not even wrong! Studying computation, computation systems, or even just mathematics in general almost certainly could assist with progress towards a TOE. That doesn't mean that pointing at a computer running a few dozen lines of code[1] and saying "A TOE could be in there... somewhere" is materially useful. [1] I'm paraphrasing Stephen himself here! Personally, I feel that if Stephen really wanted forward progress towards a TOE, he's uniquely positioned to do so. He controls a company that makes one of the best Computer Algebra Systems. He's in a position of power over a large, highly talented staff of mathematicians, and he could push Mathematica's features towards multiple relatively unexplored areas of computational mathematics where there isn't much available at the moment. Unfortunately, he's made the decision that the only two such areas worthy of his time and his company's resources are cellular automata and graph rewriting. Sigh. Meanwhile, he could have done added all sorts of features for things like handling Einstein summation convention, tensors, Geometric Algebra (and noncommutative algebras in general), topology, etc... Those would at least have immediate utility to working physicists, and if pushed to the extreme could maybe help uncover some fundamental theory somewhere. But nope. He likes to play with graphs, like a kid with with a Spirograph only interested in making pretty patterns.