4 ms·
There are perpetual reminders all around that Microsoft's only pretending to like f/oss because that's where the developer attention (and thus corporate money)
by sneak 7y ago
There are perpetual reminders all around that Microsoft's only pretending to like f/oss because that's where the developer attention (and thus corporate money) is. There's spyware in all of their open source apps (TypeScript excluded, because they couldn't get away with it there) that you can of course patch out, but you can't get it removed from the project because, free software or not, Microsoft gets to decide what goes in or out.
Bet you a dollar the GitHub mobile app that's going to come out pretty soon will also be totally proprietary with no source provided. It's a growing trend in developer tooling: even Docker's desktop versions (not Microsoft's fault, but still) are not even open source (much less free software).
It's going to be really sad in a few years when Microsoft starts turning the screws to extract more revenue from this free software ecosystem (GitHub/npm) that they are coming to exert major control over.
Soon, the most common "industry standard" tooling for the largest and most popular software development ecosystem (javascript) will rely heavily on proprietary software that spies on you continuously while you use it, just like Windows.
- oefrha 7y ago> Bet you a dollar the GitHub mobile app that's going to come out pretty soon will also be totally proprietary with no source provided. Stable version already came out a while ago, been using it on my phone. Also, GitHub the website has never been open source and they never pretended it was or was going to be, so no one was holding breath for source code of the mobile app.
- kick 7y agoGitHub has always been a proprietary company unconcerned with user freedom. They actually have a whitepaper that predates acquisition on exactly this: https://resources.github.com/whitepapers/introduction-to-innersource/ https://resources.github.com/whitepapers/introduction-to-inn... The company has always been unethical; Microsoft didn't change that.
- PanosJee 7y agoWait for radicle.xyz
- carapace 7y agoYeah, this. The analogy seems clear to me: The web is to IE as git is to VSCode, eh? At the very least, it makes it harder for an editor to be a competitor to VSCode w/o integrating with GitHub (not just git) now, eh?
- cema 7y agoNot really. At least: the web happened well before IE was introduced as an answer. In contrast, VS Code was invented much later than git which at the time was an established technology and in some ways a standard.
- zerkten 7y agoThe other context here is that IE was a competitive browser in its time: 1998-2001. The problem is that it won and then languished. IE had a lot of sway over how developers built things as the market share grew. Then it locked in users in various ways which starved the other competitors. It took until Phoenix (now Firefox), for there to be something better that grabbed the attention of developers and those sick of being stuck with IE. It became Firefox and Mozilla hatched a pretty effective plan to steal market share. For all of Mozilla's recent failings, we forget (or weren't around to remember) the success of Firefox was pretty impressive as it was a grassroots effort.
- mr_toad 7y agoIt’s telling that they went with VScode and not Atom. Makes me wonder what the long term outlook for Atom is.
- meysholdt 7y agoThe view of the Eclipse Foundation onto VS Code may be interesting here: https://blogs.eclipse.org/post/mike-milinkovich/theia-open-source-alternative-visual-studio-code https://blogs.eclipse.org/post/mike-milinkovich/theia-open-s...
- knodi123 7y agowhoa, slick.
- yarrel 7y agoThose of you downvoting this - can you explain what you disagree with here? Because it looks like a good analysis of this part of Microsoft's strategy to turn "Open Source" into a spyware-laden sausage machine for Azure.
- hamandcheese 7y agoI think the downvotes are because Microsoft has been providing some amazing tools completely free of charge. If that helps them sell more Azure... great! Everyone wins, except GitLab and AWS. Calling it spyware is hyperbolic. Keep it up Microsoft.
- sneak 7y agoNot at all. There are no objective criteria to define spyware that do not also apply to Windows or VS Code (and probably the GitHub mobile app, but I have not yet confirmed that).
- eeZah7Ux 7y agoMicrosoft has been adopting standards to then extend them and lock-in users for two decades. > Microsoft has been providing some amazing tools completely free of charge Yes, and they are the opposite of a no-profit. This are just the first steps: "embrace" and "extend".
- cutler 7y agoSome of us have longer memories of Microsoft's game-plan - embrace and extend. With so man now willing to grant Microsoft open source cred don't forget that it wasn't so long ago that Microsoft was running a Linux patent racket. If we allow The Beast to monopolise open source development tools we have only ourselves to blame.