4 ms·
What's the actual plan here? Ban services like Uber? I am not comment on whether that's a good idea, I'm just asking as it doesn't seem anyone can operate this
by LatteLazy 7y ago
What's the actual plan here? Ban services like Uber? I am not comment on whether that's a good idea, I'm just asking as it doesn't seem anyone can operate this sort of business and comply...
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoCalifornia regulators think Uber is just being greedy and could operate fine with drivers as employees. There's no plan for what'll happen if they're wrong.
- LatteLazy 7y agoThanks. The plan does seem to be for them to put up and shut up as far as I can tell. I wonder what Uber will do? Suspend all services?
- Barrin92 7y ago> I wonder what Uber will do? Raise prices, stop subsidizing their rides, shift some resources from marketing and tech to the people who actually drive the cars? Plenty of options.
- LatteLazy 7y agoWe will see I guess. Do they need to supply cars too?
- Barrin92 7y agoNot sure if they'd need to supply cars but my guess would be they'd need to reimburse drivers for costs associated with work like repairs.
- bhupy 7y ago> stop subsidizing their rides They don't subsidize their rides on a per unit basis. The driver expects to earn a base fare + some amount based no distance + time, and Uber takes a 20% cut from that. The actual marginal cost to providing a second ride, for Uber, is maps licensing, server costs, and maybe marketing promotion costs for that market. The loss that Uber makes, instead, is because the amount that they pull in from the service fee isn't enough to cover the facilities and corporate salaries (they have 27,000 employees). Uber rides were "adjusted EBITDA" profitable for 2 straight quarters before this — take "adjusted EBITDA" with a grain of salt, but it's also not "nothing". Instead, Uber will almost certainly have to raise prices. We all collectively pay for the Uber drivers' welfare, but rather than having it be progressively paid for through taxation, it will be regressively paid for through price increases that disproportionately impact the poor / middle class.
- Barrin92 7y ago>We all collectively pay for the Uber drivers' welfare, but rather than having it be progressively paid for through taxation, it will be regressively paid for through price increases that disproportionately impact the poor / middle class. Sounds like a very American centric view to me and not even sure it applies in the US. In most countries personal ride services are consumed by upper-middle-class professionals at the expense of public transportation and road congestion. I think it's very likely that the utilisation of ridesharing services skews heavily towards people with lots of disposable income in urban areas so having them pay higher prices is actually correct and internalizes the cost they put on public infrastructure. edit, some stats according to Gallup: People with incomes over 90k are almost twice as likely to use ride-hailing services than people who make under 25k, and usage rises with income. (https://news.gallup.com/poll/237965/snapshot-uses-ride-sharing-services.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/237965/snapshot-uses-ride-shari...)
- bhupy 7y ago> Sounds like a very American centric view to me and not even sure it applies in the US. In most countries personal ride services are consumed by upper-middle-class professionals at the expense of public transportation and road congestion. Usages definitely rise with income, but that's true for most goods... Consumers of ridesharing are anywhere from white collar workers with college degrees, to working parents that use Lyft/UberX to get to the airport, etc. But a $10 increase in fare means literally nothing to a millionaire / billionaire, but means a lot to a new grad, or even a median white collar worker. It's still regressive. And also, this argument applies to any form of wage floor, not just ridesharing. We as a society try to guarantee a minimum standard of living (which is a good thing), and we can do that either by employing wage floors, or through raw welfare — we collectively pay for it in one way or another. The moment you institute a wage floor, for any kind of wage: food worker, transportation worker, etc — we collectively pay for it through price increases, which means nothing to a billionaire. Instead, having a robust social welfare system ensures the same standard of living, except the new grad worker pays less into it than the billionaire.
- asdff 7y agoIn my eyes, they are. Uber doesn't own any cars, they don't pay maintenance on these vehicles, so no matter what uber states you make, your actual take is far lower. I had a driver whose car had been totaled and was being held by the dealership, the driver was using a rental car to try and save up enough to pay the dealer. The people who drive for uber are often desperate and struggling, and given these two rideshare companies are famous for burning millions of dollars in VC money with little to show for it, quarter after quarter since they began, why not burn just a little bit more and actually offer benefits that any other employee in any other profession would already be entitled to?
- bhupy 7y ago> no matter what uber states you make, your actual take is far lower. It depends. For a lot of drivers, the car is a sunk cost. That is to say, they would own the car regardless of whether or not they were driving for Uber because they need to meet their own personal transportation needs regardless of Uber/Lyft. For example, you can't take into account vehicle depreciation, because the vehicle depreciates regardless of whether or not you drive for Uber/Lyft. The one significant cost that increases strictly as a consequence of driving for Uber/Lyft is vehicle wear-and-tear. However, when you take into account vehicle maintenance, Uber/Lyft drivers still make far more than minimum wage.
- toast0 7y ago> For example, you can't take into account vehicle depreciation, because the vehicle depreciates regardless of whether or not you drive for Uber/Lyft. For taxable depreciation, which is generally equally spaced over a fixed time, ok. For actual economic depreiciation, as in the difference in what you paid vs what you could sell it for, time and mileage are both factors, extra miles from driving for hire reduce the sales value of the vehicle.
- bhupy 7y ago> time and mileage are both factors, extra miles from driving for hire reduce the sales value of the vehicle. Yes, but time impacts depreciation far more than mileage, and the time-based portion of depreciation is a sunk cost. You can definitely argue that drivers accrue more miles driving for Uber/Lyft, and that they should be reimbursed for that, and I would agree with you. However... Compare the Bluebook value of a typical car that might be used for this kind of work at ten years old with 120k miles (12k/year) vs. ten years old with a million miles (100k/year). The difference will end up being around $2500, because after ten years the car will be worth hardly any more than that no matter how many miles it has on it, and it can't lose more than 100% of its value due to higher mileage. ~$2500 amortized over 880k additional miles is <0.003/mile. A 2016 Camry with 60,000 miles is worth about $5000 more than a 2016 Camry with 500,000 miles, which works out to about ~$.01/mile of depreciation. So in a regime where drivers are compensated for the mileage-based component of the vehicle depreciation, and if the average number of miles per trip is, say 10 miles, you're looking at drivers earning about 10 cents more, per trip.
- gnopgnip 7y agoWhat is the plan for businesses that pay less than minimum wage when minimum wage was passed or raised?
- LatteLazy 7y agoThe plan is to just sue them into oblivion then? Again, I'm not saying that's right or wrong, I just wanna know what the expected outcome here is...