11 ms·
If I was being uncharitable I'd say that the problem is that companies beside Apple just don't care about a good user experience. Maybe they could produce the s
by chrisseaton 7y ago
If I was being uncharitable I'd say that the problem is that companies beside Apple just don't care about a good user experience. Maybe they could produce the same product if they thought it mattered. With almost all non-Apple laptops being flimsy, cheap-feeling plastic junk, stuffed full of ports and bezels, I feel like they're miles away from being at the stage where it makes sense to optimise the trackpad.
- ashtonkem 7y agoCompanies optimize towards whatever drives their customers buying decisions. For some makers that’s going to be performance or cost. For businesses laptops reliability and security are going to be big factors. For Apple the overall experience is a large part of why people buy; Apple users want a great hardware experience integrated into the OS, and they’re willing to sacrifice performance and price to get it.
- symlinkk 7y agoYou’re giving Dell / HP / etc too much credit. They’ve tried over and over again to build a machine with Macbook level quality. They have laptops that cost just as much, if not more, than a Macbook. And every one of them has some glaring issue. It’s not some purposeful design decision. They just don’t have the same caliber of engineers or management that Apple has.
- damnyou 7y agoEvery MacBook Pro these days has the glaring issues of * not having a top row of physical keys * not being able to run Linux natively * not integrating with any phones except the ones it makes Apple just doesn't have the caliber of engineering or management to compete with PC manufacturers.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThese are not glaring issues to most mac buyers, with the possible exception of the touchbar. Most Mac buyers both want OSX, and use iPhones. If you want Linux, don't buy a Macbook Pro, you'll save a ton of money on features you don't need, and get better hardware support.
- damnyou 7y agoWhat I'm saying is that — while the fact that all PC laptops have glaring issues is true, Macs just have a different set of glaring issues. Doing my bit to counteract the rampant sycophancy here.
- ashtonkem 7y agoYou don’t have to like Macs, but calling everyone else sycophants is out of line.
- dkonofalski 7y agoI love the Touch Bar and the fact that the new Macbooks have a physical escape key should pretty much silence any devs that were screaming about losing one.
- damnyou 7y agoI hate the lack of function keys. I hate the lack of touch typing support. It's a huge, glaring issue.
- dkonofalski 7y agoUnfortunately for you, you're in the minority. The Touch Bar is infinitely more useful than unlabelled function keys.
- ashtonkem 7y agoAll laptop keyboards are awful, and they encourage horrible posture. If you’re going to do extended typing in a fixed position, get an external keyboard monitor. The laptop keyboard should be for short term, mobile use only.
- pwinnski 7y agoI downvoted you before you added your second and third bullet points, because you were taking a cheap shot. Even with the additional points, you're comparing apples to oranges. Apple chose to remove physical function keys. No other manufacturer has previously had a smooth trackpad and chosen to remove it.
- ashtonkem 7y agoI genuinely don’t get what the big deal about function keys are. I never used them heavily, even on external keyboards. I actually transitioned to external keyboards that don’t have them, to save space. The only key that’s useful on that top row is escape, IMHO. They should make that a key. Everything else is low utility.
- FpUser 7y ago"Everything else is low utility." - says who? I can't imagine working without function keys.
- ashtonkem 7y agoSays me. This is a personal observation about how I use my keyboards.
- FpUser 7y agoIt is your personal preference, what makes it any better than mine? I do not like red color on cars. Hence they should stop painting it this way and concentrate on offering what I like.
- ashtonkem 7y agoI spoke about my personal preference and experience, I’m not sure why you’re interpreting that as an attack.
- chrisseaton 7y agoNone of these things even remotely matter to me. They aren't issues when I'm looking at what to buy.
- coldtea 7y ago>not having a top row of physical keys They instead get an adaptable keybed, that can be used as sliders, piano keys, timeline managers, and other controls, plus a fast and secure fingerprint sensor (PC ones are laughable), and a physical escape key again. >not being able to run Linux natively On exchange they get stronger security from the T2 controller handgling they keyboard, etc. Besides, most dodn't buy Macbooks to run Linux on them (though Linus used to love them for that purpose). That said, if they're willing to turn it off, there's ongoing work from the Linux side to let it boot, talk to the SSD, keyboard, etc. >not integrating with any phones except the ones it makes I'm pretty sure it integrates just fine with my Android phone. Do you know something I don't know?
- rsynnott 7y agoI honestly think a lot of it is just (bad) prioritization. An analogous situation; remember when Mac laptops had far, far better battery life than PC laptops? Like ridiculously better. People usually thought it was some magic property of the PowerPC; then Intel Mac laptops came out and they were still ridiculously better. Then Intel started taking it seriously, and a few Centrino revisions later the gap had narrowed dramatically. I remember reading at the time that, when idle, the chipset in many PC laptops used more power than the CPU...
- karatestomp 7y agoAll Apple stuff's that way, it seems. A lot of it's the software. Just compare the effect of Safari versus Firefox or Chrome on MacBook battery life. One of these projects clearly gives a quite a large damn about power use—the other two... not so much. I worked on software for phones and tablets right around the 2/3 split for Android, up through Android 5 or so. We had lots of testing devices of all quality levels. The joke-but-actually-100%-true around the office was that an Android tablet left unplugged on a desk over the weekend was always dead when you got back on Monday, while an iPad forgotten in a drawer for a month would have a useful amount of charge left on it (and come to life instantly, of course, as if it had never been asleep). Didn't seem to matter how much the Android device cost.
- wpietri 7y agoTotally. I own Android phones and tablets. But when I pick up a friend's iPhone or iPad, it's clear that the user experience is more polished. Is that because Google has a lower caliber engineers than Apple? I doubt it. Certainly the people I know at both companies are equally smart.
- Daneel_ 7y agoTo be fair, apple hardware also has some catastrophic issues. The ongoing keyboard disasters and overheating/throttling are two that come to mind.
- kube-system 7y agoYou're right, it's not a design decision. That degree of optimization is not something that happens at the product design level -- it is organization-wide optimization. When Apple leverages iPhone R&D for their MacBook, they get it for free. If it takes Dell 50 million dollars to develop the tech, and Dell expects to sell 100,000 laptops, then if we assume everything else is equal, an equivalent Dell laptop would carry a premium of $500 over a MacBook. In which case, they probably wouldn't sell 100,000 laptops, and it would be a failure and a waste of 50 million bucks. Horizontal integration is powerful.
- nimish 7y agoThis is it. Apple is willing to spend money on actual R&D for user experience. Dell and hp and friends essentially just assemble off the shelf parts into a styled chassis. It took dell years to bother developing a thin camera module instead of having a nose cam. It does come at a cost and until recently windows machines were not able to recoup it (probably chicken and egg scenario) Until Microsoft forced precision touch pads windows touch pads were awful since the oems just slapped in garbage vendor drivers. Screen aspect ratio is another thing. Everyone but apple moved to 16:9 since it's cheaper but 16:10 is better for productivity and not bad for media. But even the business windows laptops pinch pennies and do 16:9. Only apple was willing to buy 16:10 panels.
- abrowne 7y agoMy new-this-spring HP EliteBook (ordered custom with FreeDOS) running Ubuntu 20.04 seems flawless to me, although YMMV. This coming from someone who has only ever owned Macs and uses Macs at work.
- asdff 7y agoWow what a mac clone! I thought these facsimile designs died out, but I guess they must sell.
- abrowne 7y agoI agree there's nothing original about the basic design, but that's true of a lot of mature products. With USB ports on both sides (in additional to Thunderbolt 3) and an HDMI port, it's a lot like the 2015 MacBook Pro aka the "best laptop ever made"¹. But mine has a great matte touchscreen, so there are some new ideas. 1: https://marco.org/2017/11/14/best-laptop-ever https://marco.org/2017/11/14/best-laptop-ever
- wpietri 7y agoI would bet cash money that Dell, etc, could do just as poorly with equally good engineers. With differences that persist this long and are this far-reaching, I think you have to look at culture, process, and values. For all Jobs' flaws, he built an amazing culture around valuing user experience and putting that first. That's extremely hard to do, especially with a dominant business culture that instead values things like individual performance metrics, quarterly profit numbers, and low labor costs. The average piece of consumer electronics gets 3-7 physical prototypes before launch; the iPod had over 100. That's not down to the caliber of engineers or line managers.
- symlinkk 7y agoI think “culture” and “management” kind of bleed into each other, because at the end of the day you’re going to do whatever the manager tells you to do. If they tell you to make 100 more prototypes until you perfect the iPod, you’ll do it. If they tell you what we have isn’t perfect but it’s good enough, then you’ll go with that.
- wpietri 7y agoI think doing only what managers say is a fine example of bad culture. People who have been trained to not care can make a hundred prototypes and still not make anything great. People who believe that the organization will support them in making something great for the users will push to do more prototypes until they get it really right.
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>They have laptops that cost just as much, if not more, than a Macbook. And every one of them has some glaring issue. You can go to many laptop review sites and find that Apple are not dominating every category. What do you know that they don't?
- asdff 7y agoThe older I get the more I realize raw performance matters far less than the experience of using the machine every day. Macos is comfortable, so that's what I go with. Heavy lifting is better done with something permanently plugged into a wall.
- soperj 7y agoLike apple cares about a good keyboard?
- chrisseaton 7y agoWell people make mistakes. I guess they got it wrong if so many people don't like it. But they were trying to improve it, even if it failed. Other companies aren't trying to improve anything.
- damnyou 7y agoWhat nonsense is this? It is very clear that Dell has tried to improve the XPS 13 over the years and it has gotten better. They figured out a way to have the webcam on top and super thin bezels, something Apple hasn't been able to do.
- chrisseaton 7y agoIf Apple didn't care they'd use some junk off-the-shelf keyboard, like PC laptop manafacturers use. They're trying to build something better themselves. A lot of people think they got it wrong this time, ok, but they're trying. Nobody else is!
- kitotik 7y agoObviously they do care, as you can see by their investment in numerous attempts at in-house proprietary designs. They of course fucked up a few times, but you can’t say they haven’t tried. Otherwise they’d just be using some off the shelf keyboard assembly from a 3rd party supplier.
- foldr 7y agoI love the typing experience of the butterfly keyboard. The reliability issues obviously suck, but Apple cares enough about those to have switched to a new design. That being said, I have a MacBook Air and MacBook Pro with 4th gen butterfly keyboards and haven't personally experienced any reliability problems with them. I suspect that the 4th gen pretty much fixed the reliability issues, but Apple recognized that the PR battle had long been lost.
- thomashobohm 7y agoHave you seen any Windows laptops in the past five years? Many Windows ultrabooks rival Apple's in terms of "ports and bezels." The XPS 13, for example, has significantly thinner bezels than the MacBook Pro I'm typing this on, at a much more reasonable price.
- foldr 7y agoThe XPS 13 isn't much cheaper than a MacBook Pro once you opt for the high res screen.
- thomashobohm 7y agoYeah, but almost nobody opts for the super high resolution display because the screen is so small that the difference is basically unnoticeable. A similar configuration to my laptop is several hundred dollars cheaper, and that's a not insignificant difference. Edit: I owned both.
- solarkraft 7y ago> the screen is so small that the difference is basically unnoticeable At the same scaling, maybe. But I use the high resolution display on my work-provided MacBook at 125%, which means a massive virtual screen estate gain.
- thomashobohm 7y agoPresumably the vast majority of people are not going to want to scale their 13-inch display so that everything is significantly harder to read for the sake of increased screen real estate. But I'm glad that the MacBook works well for your specific use case. I currently work on a MacBook Pro 13 and I switched from a XPS 13 with a 4k display. They're largely comparable, and the only difference I notice or care about is the OS. It seems that is how it is for most people.
- OJFord 7y ago
- twic 7y ago> stuffed full of ports Imagine thinking this was a bad thing.
- diag 7y agoHow long were VGA ports commonplace in laptops? Few, if any, laptop OEMs were interested in trying to refine the mobile experience until just a few years ago.
- doteka 7y agoNot that I’m a fan of those (haven’t owned a non Apple laptop in over a decade) but the reason they had those is that a VGA is the only way you’re gonna be sure that the projector in whatever random Fortune 500 meeting room you’re in can connect to your laptop. They’re kind of compensating for corporate IT being absolute garbage.
- chrisseaton 7y agoBut I don’t need them! I just need USB-C! Nothing else! Get rid of the legacy junk and give me simpler, lighter, thinner, better sealed laptop.
- likeclockwork 7y agoYou're not the target market.
- chrisseaton 7y agoSo what should I buy if I want a powerful, long-life Windows laptop but don't want umpteen silly ports down the side?
- likeclockwork 7y agoI'm not your personal shopper. I'm sure if you want a machine with no ports someone is willing to oblige you. Or you can go back to one-size-fits-all Apple-land.
- Traster 7y agoThis makes no sense whatsoever, firstly you have to ignore the thing less than a centimetre away from the trackpad - the keyboard that Apple completely fucked up for half a decade. Does Apple just not care about a good user experience? Secondly, non-Apple laptops aren't cheap-feeling plastic junk. This is the classic "Let me compare my iPhone 11 Pro to this Alcatel 1" - well the iPhone 11 Pro is 25x the price. The Dell XPS 13 isn't cheap-feeling plastic junk, nor is the Thinkpad X1 carbon, nor is the Microsoft Surface Laptop. They're all premium products.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]