17 ms·
There is no such thing as a DMCA notice for contributory copyright infringement. A DMCA take down notice describes a particular resource that the claimant claim
by michaelmrose 7y ago
There is no such thing as a DMCA notice for contributory copyright infringement. A DMCA take down notice describes a particular resource that the claimant claims to be their intellectual property.
It is a straightforward I own foo. Using it to take down a tool that helps people access foo is perjury. It's just that we will actually jail people for committing the kind of crimes poor people commit but we refuse to prosecute the crimes rich people commit.
It's entirely possible that in the scope of another legal action the parties behind popcorn time might lose out THAT unlike this is the actually complex question.
This is pretty straightforward. You can only take down popcorn time if you can claim to own it thus its just the kind of crime we allow rich people to perpetrate upon poor people.
- balls187 7y ago> You can only take down popcorn time if you can claim to own it thus its just the kind of crime we allow rich people to perpetrate upon poor people. In the US, the DMCA makes a criminal offense to circumvent access control. As with many matters, the law isn't necessarily black and white (coincidentally, today was the first time the SCOTUS heard a arguments via teleconference--that audio was streamed live, and the subject was whether or not the PTO could block a trademark on Booking.com), and it would be up to challenge in court. I suspect that whether an open source repository that allows anyone with technical know-how to build software to partake in copyright infringement--is subject to DMCA, would be a matter for the courts to decide. I could see one argument--plans to create a 3d printed gun are controlled, and a federal court has ruled those plans cannot be put online.
- duskwuff 7y ago> In the US, the DMCA makes a criminal offense to circumvent access control. Correct. However: 1) The DMCA takedown process only applies to direct copyright violations, not to circumvention tools. Part of a properly formed takedown request is an affadavit that the content infringes upon the requester's copyright; the request in the OP is technically deficient, and GitHub made an error by honoring it. 2) PopcornTime is not a circumvention tool. It does not itself bypass any forms of rights protection; it merely distributes content (which might have been obtained through the use of circumvention tools, but that's besides the point).
- balls187 7y ago> 1) The DMCA takedown process only applies to direct copyright violations, not to circumvention tools. Not according to this: Moreover, the Project in question hosts software that is distributed and used to infringe on the MPA Member Studios’ copyrights. See Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios, Inc. v. Grokster Ltd., 545 U.S. 913, 940 n.13 (2005) (“the distribution of a product can itself give rise to liability where evidence shows that the distributor intended and encouraged the product to be used to infringe”). Hence, my point that it's an argument for the courts.
- zaroth 7y agoI’m pretty sure what you are quoting is something else entirely, not a DMCA Takedown Notice. There is perhaps no argument that PopcornTime is committing contributory copyright infringement. The point is you can’t use DMCA Takedown Notices on the source code of a contributory tool. The form that must be completed as part of a takedown notice does not have a box for “this is a tool which contributes to infringing my copyright”. The box you must check is “this is my copyrighted work and I don’t want it posted at this address”.
- naikrovek 7y ago> I’m pretty sure what you are quoting is something else entirely, not a DMCA Takedown Notice. I'm 100% sure that you are guessing, and that the post you replied to is directly quoting the takedown notice. See: https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2020/05/2020-05-01-MPA.md https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2020/05/2020-05-0...
- resfirestar 7y agoThis seems irrelevant as the person you are replying to is claiming that the notice is by its nature invalid. Quoting the notice they claim is invalid does nothing to prove them wrong. Addressing the content of the quote more directly, Grokster established that companies marketing file sharing applications have liability for infringement conducted by users. It did not establish that the companies' service providers can be sent DMCA notices, as that wasn't at issue. So that particular case doesn't help your point.
- kd5bjo 7y ago> A DMCA take down notice describes a particular resource that the claimant claims to be their intellectual property. According to the text of the relevant statute (17 U.S.C. 512c), the purpose of the notification is to inform GitHub of “facts or circumstances from which infringing activity is apparent” (1.A.ii), and the notice should include, among other things, “A statement that the complaining party has a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not authorized by ... the law” (3.A.v). The notice provides the Grokster verdict as evidence for their good-faith belief that distributing the source code isn’t allowed by copyright law. I won’t get into whether or not Grokster should apply, as I haven’t read it and am not a lawyer. But, on the face of things, this seems like one kind of scenario envisioned by the drafters of the statute. That’s ultimately a good thing, because otherwise GitHub would not be eligible for 512(c)’s immunity in this or similar cases, and would need to keep an army of lawyers on staff to evaluate the copyright status of all the content that goes through thir systems.
- wtallis 7y ago> The notice provides the Grokster verdict as evidence for their good-faith belief that distributing the source code isn’t allowed by copyright law. Subsection c.1.A has very little to do with takedown notices. (c.1.C is the portion of c.1 that does.) The only part of the law that defines what a notice is supposed to include is 512.c.3.A. None of the six required elements listed by that subsection includes providing your legal theory. A DMCA takedown notice is only meant to be used to assert "hey, that's mine!": c.3.A.ii is where you identify what you own, and c.3.A.iii is where you point to it on someone else's server. If you don't own it, you cannot file a DMCA takedown over it, because you won't be able to fulfill c.3.A.ii.
- kd5bjo 7y agoc.1.C describes the effect of a notice in essentially the same terms as c.1.A.iii, which describe how to maintain immunity generally when informed of the circumstances in the other two clauses of c.1.A . My (possibly incorrect) interpretation of this is that notices of the form described in c.3 represent a sufficient de jure form of providing the information in c.1.A.iii that would void immunity if not acted upon. Other means of providing this information to the service provider also require them to act, but will need to be examined on a case-by-case basis in court. Also note that the infringed and infringing material are to be specified separately (c.3.a.ii,iii). In this case, the infringed material is a list of movies owned by the claimant that are distributed via PopcornTime. The infringing material is the PopcornTime software itself. Though they needn’t cite anything to justify their “good-faith belief” that the software itself is in violation of copyright law wrt. their IP, nothing prevents such a statement being present, either.
- nikanj 7y ago> There is no such thing as a DMCA notice for contributory copyright infringement. Yes there is, Popcorn Time just got hit with one. And it's going to be a long and arduous battle in courts before the repository is back up. You're right that the law as written does not recognize those notices, but they get filed, and they get respected by the hosters, ergo they exist.
- wtallis 7y agoThe law defines whether a document qualifies as a DMCA takedown notice, not the manner in which the document is being used. Somebody other than a court declaring a document to be a DMCA takedown notice doesn't make that true.
- michaelmrose 7y agoPeople have also successfully gotten videos taken down from youtube by claiming copyright to bird noises that doesn't mean anyone owns bird sounds. It's understandable for Microsoft to follow the DMCA notice and take down procedure but none of this adds legal weight to a "creative" reading of the law. If something isn't clearly in line with the clear text of the law it means exactly jack shit without a actual court decision backing up the lawyers interesting interpretation of the text. Its insidious because it probably wont be settled at all and the settled truth is that you can mostly abuse the DMCA to have anything taken down for 2 weeks unless they have the funds to sue you for it. Future imitators will presumably be toolkits where you plug in your own "channels" and will be promoted as tools for people create their own youtube competitors. With a bit of work you could probably have actual non infringing users for example a provider of tech or how to videos with a more generous sharing arrangement compared to youtube.
- ballenf 7y agoYou can own a bird sound just as easily as you can own a picture of a bird. In the copyright sense of "own".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Retric 7y agoIt’s not an insurmountable issue, but you need to avoid hosting anything derived from copyrighted works. I would suggest public keys that can be used to verify some other repository is legit. Then running a distributed network those signed repository’s are passed around. Hashes of copywrited works are derivative works and therefore still subject to the DMCA. Much like how down sampling 4K content to 1080 is irrelevant for DMCA takedown notices. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_work
- afiori 7y agoHashing and down sampling cannot possibly be covered for similar reason. A down sampled movie is still a movie, an hash cannot possibly be used to obtain anything of the copyrighted content. You would need to make the argument that the hash of the movie was somehow relevant to the original content of what made the movie that movie.
- Retric 7y agoIt’s not a question of being the same thing. If you use a single frame from a movie in a painting that’s still a derivative work. It’s not about format, it’s a question of the source of originality. Hashes are a mechanical transformation without creative input, they use the entire work, and are frankly as close to the definition of derivative work as it gets. Normally the way around this is a fair use exception, but I doubt that applies here.
- afiori 7y agoI disagree on this definition of derivative. A still frame is still clearly part of the movie, on the other hand if I buy an harry potter book, scan it by hand, print it on paper then burn the print and sell the ashes, that is clearly not a derivative work. A derivative work need to use the copyrighted work for what it is. The hash of a movie is no different that the weight of a printed book or its number of pages, it would be absurd for an author to file a DMCA takedown against all books that weight the same amount of milligrams.
- koheripbal 7y agoSCOTUS has ruled that creating a program who's purpose is to circumvent copyright, is a violation. > Held: One who distributes a device with the object of promoting its use to infringe copyright, as shown by clear expression or other affirmative steps taken to foster infringement, going beyond mere distribution with knowledge of third-party action, is liable for the resulting acts of infringement by third parties using the device, regardless of the device’s lawful uses. source: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/04-480.ZS.html https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/04-480.ZS.html
- fennecfoxen 7y agoBut is it a violation that you sue about, or a violation that you are entitled to take down with a DMCA notice?
- koheripbal 7y agoThe title is incorrect - there was no DMCA notice.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- CWuestefeld 7y agoSCOTUS has ruled that creating a program who's purpose is to circumvent copyright, is a violation. This doesn't contradict the claim you're responding to. It may well be that Popcorn Time is illegal by way of contributing to copyright abuse, as you claim. But that doesn't make a DMCA claim the correct tool for taking it down. As was said earlier, a DMCA claim specifically asserts ownership of the IP in question, and that is clearly not applicable here. So sure, there's probably some tool that could be used to get it removed, but DMCA is not it. I'd guess they'd need some kind of more general cease and desist.
- koheripbal 7y ago...which is there was no DMCA in this situation. The title is wrong. They didn't file a DMCA claim.
- annadane 7y agoWhy are there so many apologists on HN? (Not you, the person you replied to)
- TomMckenny 7y agoEven if Popcorntime was considered functionally the same as Grokster, GitHub certainly isn't. In order for GitHub to be held liable, not only would the DMCA have to stretch to Grokster like tools but even further to anyone who provides any service to such a team building such a tool. So any Patreon account or Slack account a Popcorntime team uses. I imagine this is what The Motion Picture Association is aiming for. And as you hint, the difference between the court's regard for ordinary people vs powerful organizations is especially stark here. Copyright infringement and any tool that might be used for it is mightily prohibited while car theft tools like the Slim Jim are still manufactured and easily available in stores. But only tools made by less powerful groups like Popcorntime and Grokster, as far back as VCRs, those tools produced by large corporations remain legal.