6 ms·
I like in KC, KS, USA. So back in early late November early December, I had something that was exactly like Covid19 symptoms: lasted 2.5 weeks, mild fever, fati
by exabrial 7y ago
I like in KC, KS, USA. So back in early late November early December, I had something that was exactly like Covid19 symptoms: lasted 2.5 weeks, mild fever, fatigue, persistent cough, upper respiratory problems. The doctor said it was likely viral and they couldn't give me anything. Unfortunately, I don't know if there's a way to test how old my antibodies are IF this was in fact was Sars-Cov-2.
I think the bigger question is, let's say it did arrive much earlier that we think, does that mean the virus grows at a much smaller rate than current models?
- yters 7y agoor much faster and less serious
- xbmcuser 7y agoIt could also be a different strain that was spreading before it mutated into the more deadly and viral version. The virus spread is weird we can get a super spreader that can spread to 60-70 people like the church in Korea. At the same time I know personally of a family of 8 where 1 person got it had it for almost a week before getting tested positive and then sent to quarantine none of the other family members was infected.
- dgritsko 7y agoGiven the correlation between cases and deaths, isn't one of the big arguments against the early community spread theory that we would have seen death rates increase earlier on than they actually did?
- redis_mlc 7y agoNo, because the mortality rate is very, very low outside nursing homes. And cause of death in the early days won't be listed as corona, since it was an unknown disease. The Wuhan "first patient" was admitted Dec. 6, but nobody believes he was "patient zero". Since he likely contracted it Dec. 1, that means there were others with corona in Nov. or before. (Chinese people I've talked to invariably mention Oct. as when they started to hear chatter about corona.)
- taeric 7y agoI have been beating this drum for a while. I feel like I'm shouting aliens. The CFR for sixty plus is staggering. Below sixty? Still crappy, but not shut down the world. Below twenty? We wouldn't even notice. The problem is not whether this is more or less scary than the flu (or anything else), it is both. With no solutions aimed at buffering nursing homes/elderly. Am I just insane? This narrative seems completely absent in all of the coverage.
- JshWright 7y agoWhat narrative... that COVID-19 is most deadly for those over 60? That's literally the only fact that most people know about it. If you think that has been absent in all the coverage, I have no idea what coverage you have been paying attention to.
- taeric 7y agoIt is and it isn't. This thread is predicated on an IFR that is a flat 5 or so percent on the population. We all acknowledge that it is deadly. Because it is. And you are right that this is in all the data. But the narrative is still holistic. We are locking down everyone to try and kill the virus. Yes, it could work. But so could strict access to most nursing homes. Wouldn't be cheap, but could have even been more effective. Reasoning that we could reach herd immunity style buffer between the populations. (Note that I flat reject just letting people die. I am not saying to abandon the older at risk crowd. I'm saying take pointed measures to explicitly protect them.)
- philwelch 7y agoThis was more or less the original UK strategy: isolate the elderly and go full-bore for herd immunity. They scrapped that plan after they updated the model to account for ventilator shortages. There is lots of commentary on that strategy if you want to go back and read it. Even if you were gonna do this, you’d have to figure out how to isolate high-risk populations as thoroughly as possible, to the point of locking caretakers in with them and whatnot. If you lock everyone down, you have a lot more latitude to half-ass things as long as you keep R below 1. Isolating high-risk populations and deliberately pursuing herd immunity means operating consistently under the assumption that virtually everyone else will, as opposed to may, be contagious.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIf all countries had early community spread, then our knowledge of when death rates "should" measurably increase would be similarly delayed.
- aquadrop 7y agoWe're talking about all deaths here. https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps clearly shows when all deaths started to grow .
- elliekelly 7y agoAre the spikes in prior year Q4 from the flu? And if so was this year’s flu much more mild? It seems prior to coronavirus the number of excess deaths was quite low compared to past years.
- aquadrop 7y agoYes, that's how flu looks every year.
- wirrbel 7y agoYes and no. At the start of an epidemic the excess mortality is not yet measurable, its within the variation of normal deaths, and the "official" numbers of corona deaths (people who die after having been tested positive) are not yet observed because there is no testing. CDC estimates the basic reproduction number to be 6, German Robert-Koch-Institut IIRC around 3. Maybe the presence of earlier, undetected cases have lead to an overestimation of R0.
- bwooceli 7y agoI've run into a number of southern KC suburbanites who are all convinced they had it. One had attended a thing in Vegas in Jan and came back with bad con-crud. Two houses down the whole family is certain they all had it. I'm super skeptical, because the pattern we've seen in "real" hotspots like NY just don't play out the same. It is feasible that it's really only truly devastating to dense populations, but until we have any kind of reliable testing on the infection and recovered side, the only # we can use is the death rate over normal. And that view seems to point in the direction of people not actually having it until after Feb. But here we are, having exhausted 2 months of our collective patience and not demonstrably further along in our ability to measure this thing.
- Marsymars 7y agoThe other reason to be skeptical is simply by looking at the positive test rate of jurisdictions with high levels of testing. I was also ill in February and then again in March, but the rate of positive tests for COVID-19 in my area has never made it above low single-digits, so just by the numbers, it's pretty unlikely I had it.
- cblackthornekc 7y agoMy wife and I were just talking about this the other day. We both got really sick in January. We had a few of the symptoms that could be just a regular flu. My wife had one symptom that stood out the most was while she was sick, she lost her sense of taste. Not just lessened, but gone. Oh and also from KC.
- AlexMuir 7y ago> I think the bigger question is, let's say it did arrive much earlier that we think, does that mean the virus grows at a much smaller rate than current models? This absolutely makes sense to me and would explain a lot of weirdness in the statistics. Less infectious, with a longer incubation period and circulating among the population for longer.
- Hokusai 7y ago> grows at a much smaller rate than current models? I think that local data, mortality in just one care center, does not seem to fit with slow spread. Many people have died in a short period of time in just one care center. But, as any small sample of data, could be just an anomaly and not a trend. I guess that right now all options are open and as data gets cleared and accumulated we will know more. With more testing it would be easier to be sure who is infected, who has been infected and how the pandemic is behaving.
- ceedan 7y agoI have a friend in Philly who swears he had it around the holidays in December. Said he had a flu that wiped him out for a few days - said he had never had anything like it. After SARS-CoV-2 blew up and symptoms were being discovered, he swears that it's what he had.
- yborg 7y agoAt this point everyone that's had a sniffle in the last 6 months will be convinced it was COVID-19. Test data is the only thing that counts.
- skwb 7y agoFWIW SARS-CoV-1 specific antibodies last approximately 3 years or so [1]. The antibody test all have a very high specificity (all I've seen have been 98%+, but I'm going off of memory and not any specific cited information), so you'll for sure know you had it. [1]. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2851497/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2851497/