13 ms·
What You'll Need to Know in 2020 That You Don't Know Now (2000)
- apropostate 7y agoKind of eerie how much of that was spot-on. Except for the medicine bits, all of those things came true.
- aripickar 7y agoI think it's interesting how one prediction that they made was that 1,000,000,000 would be starving. However, the massive reduction in extreme poverty[1] that the world has made, especially since 2000, is amazing and under-covered. That's one prediction that I am glad they got wrong. [1]https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty
- jkingsbery 7y agoAgreed, although they aren't (necessarily) mutually exclusive - you can reduce the percentage in poverty while still having 1 billion. An interesting thing with these predictions is that they tend to focus on technology, when a lot of the reasons for problems like poverty aren't a tech issue, they are because we haven't figured out how to build functional institutions yet that overcome mismanagement and corruption, changing incentives to make education more common, ensuring supply chains that go through remote areas are safe.
- lihaciudaniel 7y agoHere's a food for thought: meanwhile 1,000,000,000 people starve and 1,000,000 starve emotionally (suicide) all in all 3 million children die every year from malnutrition.
- dcolkitt 7y ago> when a lot of the reasons for problems like poverty aren't a tech issue, they are because we haven't figured out how to build functional institutions I would argue that is still mostly a technology issue. Just social technologies, instead of physical technologies. Democracy is a social technology. Gender equality is a social technology. Market economies are a social technology. And like regular technologies, social technologies are often simple in theory but deceptively difficult to implement well. Over time, we learn the pitfalls and improve the engineering. That lowers the cost, increases the quality, and widens the distribution. Liberal democracy is a 300-year old idea, but the percentage of the world's population living under it has drastically increased in just the past 30 years. Also over time, we learn which social technologies are dead-ends. Marxist-Leninism is clearly a horrendously destructive social technology.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoYou're just calling all sorts of things "technology". Yes, you can make that definition fit, somewhat hazharzously: maybe ideas, concepts, ideologies are, in a certain light, "tools" to use to get some result. But how does that help? You're just throwing away whatever nuance is captured by the existing terminology. Are people more likely to rationally use and improve liberal democracy if you frame it in technological terms? If you believe so go ask emacs users what they like best about vim...
- igorkraw 7y agoI'd argue framing these things as technologies removes some of the mental blocks we have in them. Capitalism and socialism as ideologies can endlessly be argued about, but as technological solutions to the problem of control of the means of production that are stable and efficient you can evaluate their performance calmly. Moralistic thinking of how "people deserve their own world reward/a fair share" has it's place, but it's not a very tolerant one. A moral code that has some "higher" purpose is not something you can evaluate and discuss. A tool is evaluated only in the context it's in. This is a more flexible and pragmatic framing
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoYour "calm" performance metrics will be chosen subjectively, almost certainly on the basis of a moral code which guides your decisions but which you're not objectively aware of - because you consider it so correct it would never occur to you to question it. In fact we already do this with finance and economics. Neither are even remotely calm, unbiased, or objective. And if someone says that in fact you can evaluate moral codes on objective criteria - not least long-term species survivability and the dimensions of the collective predictive horizon and strategic IQ - how can you be sure that alternative criteria you might prefer are any better?
- philwelch 7y ago> Your "calm" performance metrics will be chosen subjectively, almost certainly on the basis of a moral code which guides your decisions but which you're not objectively aware of - because you consider it so correct it would never occur to you to question it. This is exactly what makes social and political systems a technology. People choose between different technologies based upon their personal judgments and preferences about acceptable trade-offs. Different people, and even different groups of people, will make different decisions because they have different preferences.
- philwelch 7y agoYeah, a lot of the predictions gave me classic “I was promised flying cars!” feeling but that’s far more important.
- hedora 7y ago> Globally, there are 821.6 million people that are considered undernourished or starving. https://www.statista.com/statistics/269924/countries-most-affected-by-hunger-in-the-world-according-to-world-hunger-index/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/269924/countries-most-af... Sorry to be a killjoy.
- aripickar 7y agoUndernourished != starving, and 821.6 million != 1 billion. While there is plenty of work to do left, theres a lot of progress that has been made so far and its important to recognize that.
- Lammy 7y agoFeel free to mentally substitute “has access to anything less than enough food” and round up slightly, but I don’t see much of a difference.
- ccvannorman 7y ago"round up slightly" by >100 million humans? You don't see a difference? The point being made is that human civilization is making leaps and bounds globally because that number isn't a billion, and most importantly it has a strong, predictable trajectory downwards, towards zero. "I don't see a difference" is like saying "we were going 80 mph towards the wall, and we braked, but now we're going 50, and I don't see much difference, it's practically 80 if you just round up." Are you not interested in the fact that we're continuing to brake?
- wayoutthere 7y agoJust give it a few months; 2020 ain't over yet.
- JeremyNT 7y agoI think looking at the specific numbers in that prediction misses the bigger point. The first world countries would never altruistically provide their advanced technology to the third world, and so most of the technological breakthroughs envisioned in the piece remain inaccessible to huge portions of the world's population. > For Lanier, the most heartbreaking scenario is festering in the third world, where, he believes, the current generation of children— lacking food, lacking skills, lacking aid, lacking education— will be lost in the next techno-revolution.
- mikestew 7y agoEven in 2020 you will always need to know if the facts you've dredged up are accurate and truthful. You've always needed to do this. The internet just drives that point home hard. Because when I was growing up 50 years ago, I just assumed that all the good things said about Christopher Columbus (to pick an easy example) must have been true because they wouldn't print it in a book if it weren't, right? Years later, thanks to that same lie-spewing internet Discovery Magazine warns me about, I find out that Columbus guy was a real prick. That, and an idiot who thought he was the first to cook up this "round Earth" theory (only to be beaten by 2000 years by, eh, the Greeks was it?), and got it massively wrong at that. The article overall, though, is surprisingly even-handed, lacking in ridiculous hyperbole so rife in such articles, and amazingly spot on.
- reaperducer 7y agoI find out that Columbus guy was a real prick Interestingly, if you read contemporary accounts from the time of Columbus and shortly after, you discover that the allegations of his atrocities were actually mostly made up by his former first mate who had him dragged into court on made-up abuse charges in order to get control of his ship. This is the reason the history books of the last century didn't paint him as a horrible person. But political correctness isn't about finding the whole truth. It's about finding the easiest, most profitable truth.
- Ntrails 7y agoSo, I see you're being downvoted and I fundamentally don't know if you are spouting well know misinformation or simply telling a slightly different truth. I don't know what the %'s of certainty of either version is, I just know that someone on the internet thinks you're wrong. I guess the point I'm trying to make is that in two comments I've established that it really is hard to read things on the internet and make any judgement without spending 30 minutes doing some research.
- reaperducer 7y agoI don't know what the %'s of certainty of either version is, I just know that someone on the internet thinks you're wrong. I'm OK with people thinking I'm wrong. I based my statement on an English translation of a book from the 1800's that I personally read. I'm not just repeating a talking point I saw someone spout on the internet or the television, so I'm comfortable with my assertion. Could I be wrong? Sure. But on certain topics, I trust older sources more than newer sources.
- ripvanwinkle 7y agoamazingly prescient
- gshdg 7y agoThe technical predictions are hit and miss (as such things tend to be), but this bit is prescient: > On the one hand, your workload will multiply as you bat away each glitch resulting from the increased number of gadgets in your life. On the other, you will be forced to take on moral questions no human has ever faced. When will you find time to do that? How will you contemplate when everything is speeding up and time for reflection is practically nonexistent?
- dilippkumar 7y agoThe author of this article wrote this in a Jan 2020 blog [0]: > Am I a genius prognosticator and futurist? Hardly. I was just a reporter who interviewed a bunch of really smart people. As I recall, when the editors of the magazine hired me to write the story, they already had the title in mind but weren’t 100 percent sure that it would bear fruit. My editor and I drew up a list of scientists the magazine had worked with or had interviewed in the recent past, and set me free to contact as many as I could and ask them how they saw the future shaping up. > At the time I thought some of the predictions were off the wall. The one about cleaning up our digital reputations, for example, seemed nutty to me. ... [0] https://www.josephdagnese.com/blog/2020/1/20/that-time-i-predicted-the-future-and-cnn-noticed https://www.josephdagnese.com/blog/2020/1/20/that-time-i-pre...
- jere 7y agoI found all of that remarkably prescient except for this: >To reach that age you'll need to know enough to make more complicated medical choices: Do I want to jettison a limb and wait five years to regrow another? Shall I allow a phalanx of nanobots to scrape the plaque out of my arteries or opt to replace the vessels altogether? Why do we always seem to wildly overestimate progress in medicine?
- WalterBright 7y ago> Why do we always seem to wildly overestimate progress in medicine? Because we dismiss the role the FDA regulations have in greatly retarding innovation.
- rswail 7y agoOr maybe it's because the human body is an incredibly complex mechanism and our analysis skills for determining the impact of making changes to that mechanism are yet to reach the levels we need.
- WalterBright 7y agoOr maybe it's the regulations. See "Regulation of Pharmaceutical Innovation" by Sam Peltzman.
- Apocryphon 7y agoThe FDA is not the enforcer of the laws of physics preventing the invention of medical nanites.
- elil17 7y agoIf it was the FDA's fault, you'd see scientists regrowing limbs and testing nano-bots in rats. The FDA actually has a great system of emergency and compassionate use authorizations that allow early testing of experimental drugs and devices. These systems came into place because of a long history of medical disasters: see thalidomide, Elixir sulfanilamide, and so many more.
- titzer 7y ago> By 2020 you'll need to know how to clean up that electronic trail day in and day out. "Say you were searching for information on hats," theorizes Jaron Lanier, computer scientist, musical composer, and virtual reality pioneer, "and you saw a link about hats, but when you got to it, it was actually a weird pornography site about hat fetishes. Then it turns out there's a record that you visited this site, and now you're getting bombarded with offers from people with hat fetishes. Furthermore, your friends are being contacted in case they have hat fetishes. All of a sudden you're the hat fetish person in your social circle, and you have to go in and undo it." Well, this happened, but it's simultaneously more pervasive and more silent than we would have suspected. The ad networks know everything about your online behavior, not just hat fetishes.
- smabie 7y agoI mean do they? Isn't it just as simple as installing Ghostery? Anyone who cares already doesn't see ads and already isn't being tracked. If you don't spend a minute of your time installing a free extension in order to protect your privacy, than the logical conclusion is that you don't really care (which is fine, you do you).
- titzer 7y agoAd tracking is a lot more pervasive of a problem than can be solved by a browser extension.
- hedora 7y ago> "Say you were searching for information on hats," theorizes Jaron Lanier, computer scientist, musical composer, and virtual reality pioneer, "and you saw a link about hats, but when you got to it, it was actually a weird pornography site about hat fetishes. Then it turns out there's a record that you visited this site, and now you're getting bombarded with offers from people with hat fetishes. Furthermore, your friends are being contacted in case they have hat fetishes. All of a sudden you're the hat fetish person in your social circle, and you have to go in and undo it." This is charmingly naive. He thought you could undo targeting and social networking snafus! If only we could replace all the Internet propagandists and seo content shovelers with hat fetish people. That would be objectively better, right? I don’t even really like hats, but I’d be OK with it.
- dang 7y agoThat's a bit unfair to Jaron. He didn't make a hole-in-one but he hit the green in one stroke (I'm sure there's a golf name for that, but know nothing about golf metaphors). What he said was pretty astonishing for 2000. Google didn't even introduce ads until...checking...oh! three weeks later, and the privacy concerns that he's depicting have basically become the water in which we all swim.
- webnrrd2k 7y agoIn America you can't undo much about social networking issues, but in Europe they have this "right to be forgotten" thing... But then again there is also things like the Five Eyes surveillance network, and companies that track every credit card purchase, etc... If I had to make a call on it, I think it was a good prediction, but a lot of the details are still being worked out. So I'd put it in the "success" column. As a prediction, what's the alternative? I mean, how useful is a prediction like "extensive social tracking, but with a ton of exceptions"? He got the biggest part right - that people will be much more concerned with various aspects of social tracking.
- flowerlad 7y agoAnyone want to make predictions for 2040? Here's a start: Self-driving cars will be the norm. Humans will not be allowed to drive. Extreme weather will make many parts of the planet unlivable. Manufacturing will return to America, where robots will do the manufacturing. Universal Basic Income will become a thing. Humans will work fewer hours, fewer humans will work, and fewer workers will work from work. Wealth and power will be concentrated among fewer people. There will be no retail industry. Sports will be the only reason to leave the house.
- _bxg1 7y agoAfter watching the self-driving car hype crash and burn (so to speak) over the past 5 years, I wouldn't bet on having fully-autonomous vehicles in the next 20. In fact I don't think we'll have them until they no longer have to coexist with human drivers, which could be a chicken-and-egg scenario.
- flowerlad 7y agoFrom Tesla's earnings report: "We enabled stop sign and traffic light recognition and braking for our Early Access Program users at the end of Q1 and to the wider public in April 2020. As we have done with previous releases of major new features, drivers will be required to confirm their attention in order to continue. Once enough real-world data is collected, the system will become more capable and our vehicles will continue driving through intersections without a confirmation." Source: https://ir.tesla.com/static-files/c1723af4-ffda-4881-ae12-b6f3c972b795 https://ir.tesla.com/static-files/c1723af4-ffda-4881-ae12-b6... Sounds like great progress to me!
- _bxg1 7y agoPeople have been claiming it's six months away for half a decade. I'll believe it when I see it. One very real effect of all of this research, though, is that if we did end up with an autonomous-only environment (dedicated lanes?), we wouldn't need special infrastructure - as some have suggested in the past - or a new software protocol to get all the different brands to coordinate. Probably even the ones we have today could just follow the normal rules and be sane drivers and would do perfectly. Human drivers are the only problem we can't solve.
- _bxg1 7y agoRemarkably accurate aside from the healthcare stuff
- chaos_a 7y ago>By the year 2020, for example, you will need to know how to talk to your house. Today your home contains dozens of appliances, each working independently. >The lights will flicker on, the air conditioner will have kicked in, the refrigerator will clamor to enumerate all the meals you can assemble with the groceries cached inside. It's amusing that this is sort of true, however every voice assistant I've ever used kinda suck. The most they really can do is tell the weather and set reminders. Add in the fact that a smart fridge might not use the same AI platform as a smart speaker and that dream is shattered.
- mikekchar 7y agoYou'll need to know how to build a website that loads its ads before the reader has finished skimming the article.
- travbrack 7y agoIt would have been so hard to predict Twitter.
- DyslexicAtheist 7y ago> Tomorrow's Kaczynskis will be able to concoct harmful viruses and insinuate them into the food supply, or perhaps release pathogens in public places. You'll need to be ready for them. TK was heavily in the news back then so it's no surprise they predicted more people like him may be causing mayhem at a far bigger scale. I don't think this kind of terror is likely though since people rather commit suicide before going down TK's path. They mentioned TK but didn't go into what drove him to criminal insanity: environmental destruction due to systems thinking (TK got heavily influenced by Jacques Ellul's "La Technique" and references him throughout his writings). Difference from 2000 I see today which I wouldn't have imagined in my worst nightmare is environmental destruction. The places where I went diving in the 90ies: like Great Barrier Reef, Gulf of Thailand, Indonesia's "ring of fire", that were full of life back then, they are now underwater wastelands. The primal forests / jungle I trekked in North Sumatra are nearly burnt down and forests of Borneo under threat from total destruction thanks to the new capitol they want to buid there. Apes such as Orang-Utans (Malaysian for "forest-man") nearly extinct. The beaches where I hung out in my early 20ies are now full of plastic and need to be cleared daily otherwise tourism there wouldn't be possible at all. I'm not TK but I do wish humanity wouldn't be "making leaps and bounds globally" because we destroy our own home and therefore ourselves for no reason other than pure greed. When the human race makes leaps and bounds it also leaps further towards its own demise. And I wonder if this is unique to humans or if other species given enough time would also race towards their own destruction in such fashion. And if capable of language would they describe their leaping as progress or would they be smarter and see it for what it is? We need to think of ways to reduce our population back down to size for the planet to recover and in correct proportion to our surrounding. Because thinking that we can just use smarter-Tech or geo-engineering will destroy us. The only way to get there is less of us. I already had kids so it's too late for me. But I hope I won't be a grandparent, and I hope other people also stop reproducing. I also cheer for this virus to wipe out as many as it can, even it means I or my loved ones die. Not because I'm a lunatic but because it's the only fair way (without a human deciding who is removed from the gene-pool). I also hope people will voluntarily opt not to have children but I think that's just a fantasy and example of dangerous systems thinking (who would enforce such insanity?). https://philosophynow.org/issues/45/The_Last_Messiah https://philosophynow.org/issues/45/The_Last_Messiah
- CM30 7y agoWell, some of this list was surprisingly prescient, like the stuff about online tracking and home assistants. The points about online misinformation and fact checking were pretty ominous too, though the internet of the early 00s had the exact same problems. The medical predictions however were way off (it'll probably be a while until nanotechnology as mentioned in the article becomes that ubiquous or limbs can be regrown), and the self driving car ones sounded like something people would write today in their list of future predictions. And for the moral quandries? Well, it seems the human response to those has been what it always has; ignore everything that's happening outside their tribe/local area/country. That's probably never going to change, since any creature that lives its life constantly thinking about everyone else's moral struggles is going to be living its life on the constant verge of a mental breakdown.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]