9 ms·
Backblaze is also the founding member of Bandwidth Alliance, meaning getting those B2 via Cloudflare is essentially free. So you are only paying for Storage. (
by ksec 7y ago
Backblaze is also the founding member of Bandwidth Alliance, meaning getting those B2 via Cloudflare is essentially free.
So you are only paying for Storage. ( Correct me if I am on this one )
I wonder why doesn't ALL non HyperScale Cloud Vendors, like Linode and DO provide one click third party backup to B2. You should always store offsite backup somewhere. And B2 is perfect.
- Hamuko 7y agoHow does that work? Can I just dumb two terabytes of video into Backblaze B2, setup a Cloudflare account and have people watch those videos with it costing me only $10 a month? Because that doesn't sound right.
- hartator 7y agoCurious as well.
- varikin 7y agoI believe you still pay Cloudflare costs, but the traffic between Cloudflare and B2 is free on both platforms. But it might be worth double-checking the fine print.
- Hamuko 7y agoIsn't the Cloudflare CDN included in the free plan as well?
- shockinglytrue 7y agoCloudFlare's free plan can and does end at any moment, I wouldn't rely on it for any serious application
- georgyo 7y agoIt is, but they cap out the file size they will cache on the free plan to be 512MB. So you would need to chunk up your videos to get free bandwidth.
- derefr 7y ago> So you would need to chunk up your videos to get free bandwidth. Having a functional video player on your site or in your app (e.g. one where you can skip to arbitrary times without requiring the video be buffered up to that point; or where a video can be "resumed" from the middle if you leave it and come back) already requires that you use MPEG-DASH or HLS; which in turn implies/necessitates pre-chunking, no? Is there some use-case where people are currently serving 400MB contiguous video files from a CDN? I can't think of one. YouTube doesn't. Netflix doesn't. Even porn sites don't. I guess Archive.org has some large video files on there in various places, that can be direct-downloaded; but the recommendation Archive.org itself makes, is to consume those via BitTorrent. Presumably they don't have a CDN partner willing to handle their unique workload for cheap.
- Dylan16807 7y ago> Having a functional video player on your site or in your app (e.g. one where you can skip to arbitrary times without requiring the video be buffered up to that point; or where a video can be "resumed" from the middle if you leave it and come back) already requires that you use MPEG-DASH or HLS; which in turn implies/necessitates pre-chunking, no? Browsers are smart. They only buffer a few megabytes at a time and can seek around pretty efficiently.
- derefr 7y agoThat requires the video to be encoded in a way where you can just start reading the stream from any random byte offset, and everything will still work. Video files are not usually encoded this way (any more.) Resume an MP4 or MKV video half-way through, without reading the TOC-ish stuff from the first chunk, and you'll get garbage that maybe resyncs after 20 seconds. It's totally possible to "encode for streaming", but it usually results in both an increase in overhead [more keyframes] and a decrease in quality [inability to use predictive interpolation, instead relying only on forward-interpolation.] Mind you, this streaming-enabled encoding is how things were done on the web, before the advent of MPEG-DASH/HLS; and it's still how e.g. the MP2 encoding of digital cable/satellite video works. But we don't really want to go back to those days. They kind of sucked. Jumping to random byte offsets in a video also tends to screw with any embedded data streams like subtitles or thumbnails, which tend to just be stored in most media container formats as a single chunk at the beginning/end of the file, rather than being spread or copied across the stream. Again, the kind of captioning done back in the MP2 days is immune to this, but it kind of sucked as well (e.g. it wouldn't trigger if you happened to skip to the millisecond after the instruction for it appeared in the stream, often leaving you with ~30 seconds of untranslated audio.)
- heipei 7y agoThe Cloudflare ToS explicitly exclude that use-case. 2.8 Limitation on Serving Non-HTML Content The Service is offered primarily as a platform to cache and serve web pages and websites. Unless explicitly included as a part of a Paid Service purchased by you, you agree to use the Service solely for the purpose of serving web pages as viewed through a web browser or other functionally equivalent applications and rendering Hypertext Markup Language (HTML) or other functional equivalents. Use of the Service for serving video (unless purchased separately as a Paid Service) or a disproportionate percentage of pictures, audio files, or other non-HTML content, is prohibited.
- DoctorOW 7y agoFrom what I can tell that's more about their caching service. It mentions exceptions for hosting from a paid service and correct me if I'm wrong but wouldn't Backblaze be that paid service?
- jjeaff 7y agoThey are talking about their own paid service, obviously. I don't think they care whether you are paying for someone else's product or not.
- celicaraptor 7y agoPerhaps they are talking about a paid service that they offer,like Cloudflare Stream https://www.cloudflare.com/products/cloudflare-stream/ https://www.cloudflare.com/products/cloudflare-stream/
- mikehearn 7y agoIn a previous HN post [1] where someone wrote up how to use B2 as an image host, the Cloudflare CEO chimed in and addressed rule 2.8 specifically, saying if Cloudflare workers are used for URL prettifying and redirecting, a different ToS is applied and that use-case would be fine. Does that mean your video use-case would also be fine? I have no idea. An HN comment from the CEO doesn't seem like it would hold up if Cloudflare suddenly shut down your free account. I'd love for Cloudfront to officially clarify the limits of the Cloudfront/B2 alliance in terms of external traffic. The confounding issue here is that B2, as a storage service, is not really intended for "serving web pages and websites" — it's for larger files, binaries, etc. — and therefore any traffic from B2 going through Cloudfront is sort of de facto in violation of 2.8. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20790857 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20790857
- Dylan16807 7y agoCloudflare's main service excludes video.
- tpmx 7y agoThis is key for many.
- celicaraptor 7y agoThis thread might help https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20790857 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20790857
- anon102010 7y agoThis is huge if true - folks keep on saying Cloudflare can replace cloudfront for free. If we could put 20TB of binary content for software distro / videos etc on B2, then stream by cloudflare I'd actually believe the claims. Every time we've tried this with other "free" providers there always seems to be "fine print" when you start pushing huge bandwidth on these "unlimited" plans. It seriously is not worth the time at some point.
- chx 7y agoThe way I understand, you can do this with images, eastdakota confirmed that here earlier https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20791660 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20791660 not sure about videos.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- atYevP 7y agoYev from Backblaze here -> That's correct. We're a founding member of the Bandwidth Alliance and you can find more info about that on our Blog (https://www.backblaze.com/blog/backblaze-and-cloudflare-partner-to-provide-free-data-transfer/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/backblaze-and-cloudflare-part...) or FAQ (https://help.backblaze.com/hc/en-us/articles/217666928-Using-Backblaze-B2-with-the-Cloudflare-CDN https://help.backblaze.com/hc/en-us/articles/217666928-Using...). May the 4th be with you ;-)
- drenvuk 7y agoHey I've been wondering this but are the transaction costs also waived or is it just the bandwidth fees? I feel like if both are gone it'd be hard to make a profit...
- atYevP 7y agoFor that integration it's just the download fees. The transactions do still get billed, but many people can stay within the free daily allotment.
- TechBro8615 7y agoWhere can I find the pricing info for this allotment?
- atYevP 7y agoAll of our pricing is available on the site (no need to call anyone) - B2 Cloud Storage is listed here -> https://www.backblaze.com/b2/cloud-storage-pricing.html https://www.backblaze.com/b2/cloud-storage-pricing.html. Just scroll down for the transactions!
- dxxvi 7y agoStorage Download BackBlaze .5 cents/GB 1 cent/GB S3 (one zone infrequent access) 1 cent/GB 9 cents/GB I'll transfer my 250GB of videos and images from S3 to BackBlaze some day.
- rochester46 7y agoDoes AWS (and GCP and Azure) not do the exact same thing when transferring data out via Cloudfront (or their respective CDN)? Is Backblaze really special in that regard?
- wrkronmiller 7y agoCloudfront costs a non-trivial amount of money per GB: https://aws.amazon.com/cloudfront/pricing/ https://aws.amazon.com/cloudfront/pricing/
- rochester46 7y agoHow does that compare to Cloudflare? Is Cloudflare completely free for CDN? I can't find a clear pricing page.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ksec 7y agohttps://www.cloudflare.com/plans/ https://www.cloudflare.com/plans/ Cloudflare dont charge per GB. They are more like per "feature" CDN.
- budmang 7y ago(backblaze ceo here) AWS is free to Cloudfront because that's an AWS service. AWS/GCP/Azure are not free (and quite expensive) to Cloudflare. Backblaze is free to Cloudflare.
- microcolonel 7y agoAnd Cloudflare is also the winning reverse proxy caching provider, the one that people tend to use even despite transit charges to AWS/GCP/Azure.
- bvivek77 7y agoBit confusing. Need more clarity. Read 10 times. Pls recheck mr. ceo :)
- hangonhn 7y agoThis is so mind-blowing-ly crazy and awesome. I've always loved the idea of Backblaze but never tried it. But this combination is so insanely good and valuable. When an efficient market/economy works correctly, the results are just amazing: Cloudflare and Backblaze essentially got their unit costs for their respective products so low that for just a small money fee, I can do something that would have been prohibitively expensive maybe just a decade ago.
- ksec 7y agoOn the note of unit cost I doubt it will be much lower in the near future. Cost / GB isn't falling much if at all, and their Load balancer are already eating into their margin which means any further reduction in unit cost are only gaining back what they took in with the S3 API. Hopefully the new S3 compatible API means they could make all that back with volume. But this is also a sad realisation that storage tech aren't getting cost reduction any further. ( Of course Blackblaze can always prove me wrong :D )
- toohotatopic 7y agoWasn't there a startup on hn some weeks ago that used a crypto mining approach to server management that was much cheaper?
- ksec 7y agoYes and it had little redundancy with limited up time and speed guarantee, with no S3 API compatibility. And if I remember correctly even that was $0.003 per GB, with lots of unit cost that a lot of people including me thought to be miscalculated, where it should be closer to $0.4 for it to be somewhat break even. So may be it is cheaper, but not really comparable.
- ADefenestrator 7y agoDisclaimer - Backblaze employee here, but just speaking for myself: It was.. sort of cheaper. They didn't actually build the servers, and as described the server wouldn't work (onboard SATA didn't support port multipliers, lack of ECC would probably cause problems in practice, bit hand-wavey on power/space/network/manpower costs, etc). The goal of the article was to get other people to build cheap storage and put it up for rent on their network. They do have some amount of storage space available for very cheap on the network now, but personally I suspect it's people who figured "what the heck, I'll give it a try!" as opposed to people actually building storage servers and making a profit renting them out. I was honestly pretty disappointed - I'd hoped they'd found a cheap motherboard with ECC and support for port multipliers, but nope.