3 ms·
Print? Forget 3d printing, if you want a cheep medical microscope you can 2d-print and the fold one out of paper. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foldscope http
by sandworm101 7y ago
Print? Forget 3d printing, if you want a cheep medical microscope you can 2d-print and the fold one out of paper.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foldscope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foldscope
Foldscopes illustrate an interesting reality when it comes medical testing: more often than not a general-purpose medical microscope is total overkill. For medical testing, seeing if some pathogen is present or not, you do not need massive optics creating large fields of view. Answers can be found using extreemly small optics of, literally, disposable microscopes. The problems of foldscopes largely surround issue of contamination and testing methodology, not the limitations of the optics.
- enchiridion 7y agoDoes FOV help improve the accuracy?
- sandworm101 7y agoThat depends on the test. If you want to count the number of something, a larger area (the sample size) is better. But if you are looking for the simple presence of something, say a parasite, then seeing only one of them is all you need. It's like checking a dog for ticks. To say "no ticks" you have to check the entire dog. But if you check one spot and see one tick you can safely say that the dog has ticks.
- dekhn 7y agoThis isn't really comparable on any dimension. The foldscope uses a tiny ball lens that introduces a ton of distortion and even its ability to detect disease is pretty questionable (that said I really think it's got a bunch of clever ideas). Note that this scope really isn't as cheap as described; the printer and the labor involved massively outweight the dollar cost of the components.
- paypalcust83 7y agoIt's good for rough pathology of certain infectious diseases and fluid and tissue conditions. Also, you're throwing around a strawman about fixed costs that are amortized in volume. Plus, robotic manufacturing and packing can produce these in massive quantities that drive the net unit costs down. I've played with similar microscope prototypes IRL and they were quite impressive for something seemingly primitive at first, they were quite usable and adjustable.
- paypalcust83 7y agoI saw laser-cut prototypes of something similar at Stanford around the med school at some sort of "science fair" ~6 years ago. The cost is mostly the magnifying bead. What's also great, besides being cheap, is that it doesn't need power, packs down quite small, and can work in the field.
- jtc9242 7y agoHey! I'm an author on the OpenFlexure paper. The Foldscope is awesome. We know the project well, but we fundamentally have very different aims. The foldscope is a fantastic simple microscope at rock-bottom cost. Our design is focused on providing automated, accurate positioning, hence the titular "flexure" design. For pathology applications described in the paper, being able to scan huge samples at high magnification is really important, but relies on motorized positioning and autofocus to work well. That's where our design is really unique.