5 ms·
My normal position is fairly anti-government, but there is a role for an agency here that I wish they'd fill. It'd be fantastic to have a centralised agency org
by roenxi 7y ago
My normal position is fairly anti-government, but there is a role for an agency here that I wish they'd fill. It'd be fantastic to have a centralised agency organise a panel of experts who have gone though all the known papers and studies, synthesised them then just sat for a week doing a massive public Q&A session. Targeted at people who are really quite clever rather than the usual aiming-low that the mass media goes for.
The volume of research has gotten far too much for me to keep track of; the media are in full swing polluting the channel with irrelevant and frequently political noise. I really do not care about what politicians think about given drugs, and honestly their justifications for why they are doing X or Y are not going to matter to me for a while because politics doesn't happen quickly. It'd be nice to have a centralised, low bandwidth well moderated information source for the smartest 5-10% of people to get good information in response to their questions and uncertainties.
There are great information channels for PhD medicine types & doctors (I hope). There are good sources for people who are at risk of drinking bleach because they heard it might help (try a local news channel). There is a hole for, say, the top 5% smartest people where they really don't have an in to figure out how they might help, because they need information hidden in very technical articles or behind rather black-box modelling as described in the media. But they are otherwise very educated, intelligent, capable, wealthy or what have you. These are coordination problems a government could actually help with.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Jedd 7y agoI agree in principle with your wish for some neutral <unquote>, informed, apolitical, insightful, measured, and cautious commentary that distils the current consensus. But it sounds like a lot of the concerns you express are specifically around the problems that are currently being experienced by one poorly administered country. I think elsewhere in the world, a lot of people feel they're already getting this level of information, without the political overload & misdirection.
- roenxi 7y agoI reject the notion that Australia is poorly administered. Our COVID-19 cases are extremely low [0] and the government has been doing a fine job compared to most others. :) [0] https://www.health.nsw.gov.au/news/Pages/20200503_00.aspx https://www.health.nsw.gov.au/news/Pages/20200503_00.aspx
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mlg10 7y agoAren't the cases low because the temperatures were high when the virus first hit (and are still comparatively high)? I'm sure Italy would have done better in the summer with 30 degrees Celsius.
- wbronitsky 7y agoDo you have any data to support the assertion that higher temperatures help calm Covid rates? Seeing as Singapore is having an extremely tough time right now, I don’t think you do. This is pure supposition.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoIt's a well-known correlation with influenza. Yes it may be untrue with Corona Virus, but that remains to be seen. It would be unusual if the correlation didn't hold.
- wbronitsky 7y agoPlease stop insisting we have evidence when none exists. My question was: do we have evidence that warm weather slows Covid outbreaks? So far, the answer is “no”, and asserting anything else is not an argument, it’s a made up story.
- 7y ago
- jandrewrogers 7y agoThis doesn't address the problem, it only moves it. These kinds of panels already exist in many countries on many topics -- I've worked with several. In all cases, the selection of the panel and the positions they take have political motivations. They are never constructed as a random sample of domain experts. Even when trying to achieve that appearance, "domain expert" is defined so as to justify the exclusion of many inconvenient domain experts from consideration. None of which should be surprising, since this is basic human nature. Indeed, the functional purpose of these kinds of panels, based on what they actually do, is to lend an air of authority to decisions that were made politically. For the participants, they are paid in prestige, which is a valuable currency.
- clairity 7y ago> "My normal position is fairly anti-government, but.... Targeted at people who are really quite clever.... It'd be nice to have a centralised, low bandwidth well moderated information source for the smartest 5-10% of people" that only reveals ego and information blindness. it's hard to triangulate toward the truth, much less a plan, with that kind of blindness, no matter the composition of expertise. smart people may know more of their little patch of elephant, but make no mistake, they know nothing of the whole elephant. it's so easy to miss massive swaths of the elephant because you're too smart to ask the simplest questions first. luckily, an easy first-order fix is to not dictate the composition of the audience asking questions. pick at random. then you'll get a truer picture of the bewildering complexity of the elephant and a better sense of where to take that (and a truer picture of the information holes between the panelists to fill for next time). besides, what you ask for is simply the standard academic seminar at any major research university.
- buboard 7y agoTry r/covid19
- knzhou 7y ago> It'd be nice to have a centralised, low bandwidth well moderated information source for the smartest 5-10% of people to get good information in response to their questions and uncertainties. Any such channel which is truly open to questions immediately gets swamped by political attacks, along with an endless horde who think they're in the smartest 5% yet accuse the scientists of being in the pocket of the lizard people. Malicious agents will be able to mine even slightly nuanced explanations for out of context quotes to show that their political opponents are stupid or evil. If the channel is to be useful at all, it must make statements under uncertainty, but that gives it the chance of being occasionally wrong -- and anything it ever gets wrong will be repeated ad nauseum as an argument to defund it. If the channel is visible and trusted, it also becomes a prime target for politicians looking to shift blame away from themselves. The reason I'm completely sure this will happen is that the information channel you're asking for already exists. It's called the World Health Organization, and they've been doing informative press conferences this whole time. However, everybody on this site has decided that they're useless because of a single, incorrectly read, out-of-context tweet from 4 months ago.
- 1996 7y ago> It's called the World Health Organization That's a political organization, not what is being proposed here.
- knzhou 7y agoYou’re perfectly illustrating what I talked about.
- leereeves 7y agoBut the objection is perfectly valid. They are a political organization that sometimes places politics over reality (for example, refusing to recognize Taiwan, repeating Chinese reports unchallenged and praising China's transparency, or as another comment pointed out, appointing Robert Mugabe as goodwill ambassador). That internal challenge should be added to your excellent list of external challenges the proposed organization would face, and the WHO does face: politically motivated people and powerful nations will capture the organization from the inside and abuse any trust it has built up to serve their own ends.
- bo1024 7y agoNormally, this is the role of peer review and top publishing venues. Those places should be putting a big push to rigorously review as many articles as and as fast as possible now.
- UncleMeat 7y agoA friend of mine runs a relatively popular blog on climate change. In this blog he discusses current research (including his own) in a manner targeted at relatively educated people. Its exactly the sort of thing you want. He receives hate mail constantly. Major players in political administrations troll his comment section and evade bannings. Its a mess. I don't know if what you describe is feasible.
- aaronbrethorst 7y agoThis would be the CDC. They stopped doing those briefings at the, uh, request of the President. https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/494187-trump-threatened-to-fire-cdcs-chief-of-respiratory-diseases-in https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/494187-trump-thr...