4 ms·
I will say that the newer MBPs have decent video cards. They’re not great, but they’re ok-ish.
by ashtonkem 7y ago
I will say that the newer MBPs have decent video cards. They’re not great, but they’re ok-ish.
- Danieru 7y agoIndeed, new machines can have decent GPUs. Except the install base is where your game will be played. Thus the average matters.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThe install base of your buyer matters, not the install base of Apple. I doubt that the average MacBook Air buyer is the average Mac video gamer, and I bet that MBPs are over represented in Mac video game uses.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoI would bet otherwise. Most gamers are casual and casual games usually run on integrated GPUs. Only top-end MBPs are half decent for gaming anyway.
- arvinsim 7y agoI have a gaming PC but also used my MBP for gaming on non GPU intensive games. I was happy with this setup until Catalina killed 32 bit support. Most of the games I played on the MBP was 32 bit. Killed Mac Gaming for me.
- gumby 7y agoUnfortunately due to the mobile architecture you can’t sync frames. This is true on the windows side too but there you can get a “gamer” laptop which has a desktop cpu and video architecture. We could only demo castar for example On a gamer laptop or a desktop. Even a cheap desktop worked great. I’m a Mac user and develop on the Mac so you might think I’d bend over backwards to make an excuse, but...not possible in this area. Those gpus do render beautiful pictures and can do some cool gpgpu crunching, but aren’t appropriate for gaming.
- ashtonkem 7y agoGenuinely surprising. I’ve switched over from gaming on my older PC (very old CPU but a 1050ti) to my MBP for cable logistical reasons, and the MBP performs admirably. Admittedly I’m no hardcore gamer, but I’m satisfied with what my MBP can do.
- willis936 7y ago>can’t sync frames What does this mean?
- teddyh 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screen_tearing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screen_tearing
- willis936 7y agoRight, but display buffering is a solution to the vertical sync issue that has existed for as long as raster graphics. You can’t buy a GPU without it. Now that I’ve had more time since I read the post, I think they may have been referring to adaptive refresh rate.
- wtallis 7y agoI don't think adaptive refresh rate is what that post was referring to. Instead, I think it was referring to the difficulty in doing frame synchronization when the game is running on the discrete GPU but the display is connected to the integrated GPU. But I don't know how Apple's hardware is set up on that score.
- gumby 7y agoYeah, the problem was making sure we didn't have screen tearing. T he only path to video was through the mobile integrated graphics interface even when using the external graphics chip. On a desktop CPU you can DMA into graphics memory directly and get the frame sync. I think you have to do this if you want to be able to switch between integrated and external. Which we didn't care about but perhaps most people do?
- dralley 7y agoBut "decent" isn't really good enough for VR, where high refresh rates matter quite a bit. Another factor in play might be that, if rumors are to be believed, future Macbooks will be shipping with ARM chips, with yet-to-be-determined CPU and Graphics performance. That might be a bridge too far for crossplatform projects who are already frustrated about having to maintain a Metal backend just for Mac.
- ashtonkem 7y agoTotally fair. VR has much higher requirements than regular gaming.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoAnd yet it works and sells well on a 3 year old mobile chipset in the Oculus Quest.
- reom_tobit 7y agoIt’s not necessarily about the hardware, but (for me at least) more to do with the OpenGL hacks I have to do to get reasonable cross platform support rolling. Took about 2 days to take a win project to linux, that same win project took about 3 weeks to port to mac. That was the first time I’d done it of course (to either mac or linux), but I just found the mac documentation to be severely lacking. Also all macs are now stuck on OpenGL 4.1 forever, it may not matter much now, but it will show in future. And yes I know Vulkan is a thing but I think that’ll take a while to fully be adopted by the games community.
- bangonkeyboard 7y ago> Also all macs are now stuck on OpenGL 4.1 forever, it may not matter much now, but it will show in future. Not forever: OpenGL is deprecated on macOS and will be removed in the future. I will be very surprised if OpenGL survives the ARM transition.
- reom_tobit 7y agoImprecise language on my part. I meant that’s the final version that they’re ever going to support (if you can call the current state “support”), but yeah you’re 100% correct.
- ekianjo 7y agoThere is no Vulkan support on Mac as far as I know, except with MoltenVK...
- reom_tobit 7y agoThere isn’t, you’re right. I was more future proofing my answer :)
- kbumsik 7y agoHow is the proportion of MBPs in the macOS users?
- ashtonkem 7y agoProbably high as long as you include work machines, and otherwise low.
- izacus 7y agoThose GPUs are horribly underpowered for the screen they're driving. They would be fine on a 1920x1080 display, but on a Mac display the GPU barely squeezes stable 30fps on modern games... even in lowest settings.
- vmladenov 7y agoThe GPUs are not underpowered. A Radeon Pro is simply not intended for video games. There are less powerful standard Radeons that have better game performance.