11 ms·
New bill threatens journalists’ ability to protect sources
- gnicholas 7y agoThis was the least informative article I’ve ever read on TC. It does not make clear how the ability to protect sources is endangered. Can’t journalists continue to protect sources by not naming them, and communicating via encrypted apps? What is changing?
- colejohnson66 7y agoThe EFF has a good write up that explains what’s actually wrong with it[0]. [0]: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/03/earn-it-act-violates-constitution https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/03/earn-it-act-violates-c...
- pdonis 7y ago> This was the least informative article I’ve ever read on TC. You evidently started out with a better experience of TC than mine. :-)
- showerst 7y agoThat article said nothing. Here's the bill text for the curious: https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/3398/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/339...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoThis is akin to reporting “Giant asteroid on collision course with earth, many journalists expected to be killed.” Basically, the article is saying that the EARN IT act would defacto outlaw end-to-end encryption. Thus people could not securely communicate with each other. One group of people affected by this would be journalists trying to securely communicate with sources.
- chaps 7y agoCan you please explain why this isn't a big problem to you?
- catalogia 7y agoThat doesn't seem to be what was said.
- krastanov 7y agoThey are saying it is a big problem. A problem much bigger than the already awful "journalists will have hard time protecting sources".
- alibaba_x 7y agoHe's just noting how the article is focusing entirely on how this bill will affect journalists in particular rather than literally everybody.
- chaps 7y agoThat's understood. That's obviously a huge problem, but isn't it worth pointing out one of the bigger issues of the bill? There are many, many people who agree with this bill who may not have thought about this specific issue. It's worth pointing out how the ends that supposedly justify the means, can have major, major faults. The weakening of structures that allow political journalists to expose corruption is not a small issue and should be discussed on its own. In other words, I'm asking: "Why does this topic not deserve its own conversation?"
- coldtea 7y ago>That's understood. That's obviously a huge problem, but isn't it worth pointing out one of the bigger issues of the bill? That's not "one of the bigger issues" of the bill. It's not even that interesting as an issue -- journalists have other ways to talk to sources. Deep Throat didn't use "end to end encryption". But not allowing end to end encryption affects all of society (e.g. everybody's text messages, chat, and voice calls), not just some specific use case of a specific line of work.
- whylie 7y agoI like the sound of that. I hear the words "according to someone familiar with X" far too often. Not interested in speculation, hearsay, gossip, scapegoat to promote one's own intentions...Lazy and agenda ridden through and through.
- seph-reed 7y ago> The same New York Times investigation found that law enforcement agencies devoted to fighting online child exploitation “were left understaffed and underfunded, even as they were asked to handle far larger caseloads.” The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC), established by Congress in 1984 to reduce child sexual exploitation and prevent child victimization, “was ill equipped for the expanding demands.” It’s worth asking, then, why EARN IT does not instead empower these agencies with additional resources to solve crimes. This is a very striking point that I think even the least tech aware person could understand. Also, the acronym EARN IT is marketing genius for the US. I can really easily see that convincing a lot of people of its validity just because it's kind of sassy/obstinate and for some reason Americans gobble things like that up. "You want encryption? Well why don't you EARN IT by not being a pedophile. - Karen 2020"
- saagarjha 7y agoBills often have these kinds of names. Don't want mass-scale surveillance? Guess you're not a PATRIOT.
- snarf21 7y agoOf course, it will also be trafficking or child porn or terrorism as the reason. We all know this is about surveillance unchecked.
- 0xy 7y agoThe EARN IT act is not really to prevent online child exploitation. It can't be. Because this act will push the people involved in those practices underground to places that cannot be censored like Tor. In fact, the EARN IT act puts children directly in danger. When evidence of child exploitation is pushed out of the regular internet, it becomes much harder to discover and prosecute.
- JoeSmithson 7y agoDo you have any experience in investigating online child sexual offences? I am just wondering what basis you are making claims like "the EARN IT act puts children directly in danger".
- the8472 7y agoDo cloud providers require section 230 protection for mere hosting? Or does the buck stop at their customers operating user-facing services on their infrastructure?
- cataphract 7y agoSo, this seems to be the gist of the article. > [I]t’s not possible to identify [child exploitation material] without also having the ability to identify any and all other types of material — like a journalist communicating with a source, an activist sharing a controversial opinion or a doctor trying to raise the alarm about the coronavirus. Other people suspect that the real goal of the bill is to force facebook/WhatsApp et al to do away with end-to-end encryption, which would be the only way the companies could police the material (and AG Barr has "expressed his desire for this outcome": https://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2020/03/the-earn-it-act-partially-repeals-section-230-but-it-wont-help-children.htm https://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2020/03/the-earn-it-ac... )
- 0xy 7y agoThe EARN IT act is not about child exploitation at all. Because the effect will be the opposite -- it'll be pushed underground and away from law enforcement's reach. It will put children in direct danger in order to further the actual goals of the legislation, which is to effectively ban E2EE in order for the intelligence community to put more deep surveillance in place.
- c3534l 7y agoI agree. These things are really about expanding bulk collection programs, not about catching whoever the big bad guy is at the moment.
- 0xy 7y agoAustralia's metadata retention law was sold as a child protection scheme, and immediately after it was made into law it was repeatedly abused by intelligence employees to spy on girlfriends, used to investigate petty crimes and given out to any government agency who asked for it including local councils and tax agencies. As soon as it's law, the children are irrelevant. This is mass surveillance legislation, and child protection is the shiny marketing.
- StanislavPetrov 7y ago
- smsm42 7y agoI read the whole article and couldn't understand what the proposed legislation actually proposed, specifically rather in vague "it's gonna cause problems!" way. Completely terrible journalistic work. Ironically, in an article emphasizing how important it is to protect journalists.
- suizi 7y agoThe article doesn't really add much that we didn't know already (through other articles). You can search EARN IT on here or EFF for details or Signal's write-up on it. They want to hold people liable for "reckless endangerment" for offering anything that could be used to facilitate child exploitation. Encryption by it's very nature makes it very difficult to pursue, Barr has pushed much rhetoric of what he would push in the committee for this bill, and the writers of the law refuse to specifically exempt encryption despite having many opportunities to do so.
- AdmiralAsshat 7y agoThe scary part about the EARN IT act is that I've written both my congressman and my senator (both Democrats), and they're completely on board with the "Think of the children!" bullshit justification for this. I really expected better out of Mark Warner.
- snarf21 7y agoFear-mongering wins elections. It is a sound bite. "Senator Mark Warren thinks we should protect criminals who exploit children!!!!!" The general voter doesn't care about the rest of the details. People are afraid to be on the wrong side of it. If this doesn't pass, then even a single case is proof that we should have voted yes on EARN IT.
- the8472 7y agoWhy does "think of the children" work but "senators want to look into your bedroom" doesn't?
- snarf21 7y agoIt is a good question. My guess it is about perception. People don't really think the bad will happen so it is "free" to think of the children instead. Probably need someone more versed in human psychology to answer this.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoProbably because that immediately becomes: Senators want to look in your bedroom so they can see you fucking children.
- mattnewton 7y agoI think it is a combination of a) People think they have nothing to hide, and b) Nobody is running ads with the later.
- filoleg 7y agoBecause you can come up with all sorts of rebuttals from certain individuals, like "I don't care if they invade my privacy, they are welcome to look into my bedroom all they want, there is nothing interesting there". We already see a form of that reasoning from people regarding personal data tracking, saying stuff like "i have nothing to hide". On the other hand, you cannot come up with a similar simplistic argument when someone brings up "think of the children" without giving out some really bad soundbites of yourself. You cannot just say "well, I don't care about children, it wouldn't affect them much anyway" without being represented as a heartless moron by the opposition. Disclaimer: this is just all for the sake of the argument. I, personally, am very strongly against this "think of the children" bs tactic and am fully in favor of E2E encryption. It is just sad that the "think of the children" argument is so effective solely due to the emotional appeal and how difficult it is to fight against that argument without coming off in poor light.
- supernova87a 7y agoSometimes I wonder if there are unintended side consequences of an explosion in the ability of people to be private and have all their concerns / issues kept private (or more strongly, anonymous). And sometimes it makes me feel like an old Scalia for asking whether privacy is really a fundamental right. Or at least, whether we're fully considering the downsides of privacy as strongly as its benefits. Privacy now lets us hide things that we didn't want others to intrude upon. That may be a good thing. But I can also imagine that a byproduct of increasingly stronger privacy is that the social function of monitoring and group shaming of bad behavior is diminished. You no longer are allowed to know what your neighbors are doing, or speak up because someone's privacy might be violated. People used to know what taxes their neighbors paid. If you didn't want to be gossipped about, you didn't engage in certain behaviors. It cuts both ways I think. People now can report on things privately, yet increasing privacy itself enabled more bad behavior. Privacy (and anonymity) allows people to get help that they previously felt ashamed to raise or report. That may be a good thing. But maybe it also lets smaller and smaller (more individual) concerns take the stage away from things that are bigger more pervasive but less attention-grabbing important issues. Maybe we become a more individual-focused society because we gravitate towards paying attention to individual stories of troubles. I don't know. I'm not an expert in this area. But I wonder if sometimes privacy isn't overdramatized by its advocates and painted with the positive brush when there are negatives as well.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoIncreasing privacy? Can you demonstrate where privacy has increased when compared to some previous time in history?
- snarf21 7y agoThis is the "I've nothing to hide" fallacy. The question will become: who gets to decide? Who will watch the watchers? If everything you say and do is captured, it won't be societal norms but some singular point of view based on who is in power. Governments have shown an inability to protect citizen's rights when give this kind of power. Look at China and North Korea and Russia for proof. We don't have to conjecture about this, we know. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. I prefer freedom with consequences. Honest question: do you know your neighbors are doing today, pre EARN IT passing?
- enitihas 7y agoI never understood one thing about American Politics. A lot of folks who are fierce advocates for people being able to keep weapons, go quickly up in arms against encryption. As if the guns somehow can't harm the children. Even though the US has had so many school shootings, it seems a lot of politicians are still hell bent on saying encryption harms children, while guns somehow don't land in the conversation.
- justwalt 7y agoI’ve never heard anyone say they were against encryption.
- ignoramceisblis 7y agoIt was a straw man. Designed to make you think less of a certain group of people.
- hartator 7y agoWell. You can be pro-gun and pro-encryption. Technically encryption is actually considered under the same rules as ammunition by US customs.
- AWildC182 7y agoAre you sure you aren't thinking of ITAR et al? "Customs" is a bit of a broad statement here.
- hartator 7y agoMaybe! Was referring to this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_... Is ITAR part of customs or something different?
- krapp 7y agoThis is because law enforcement, which is strongly pro gun, is also against encryption, because encryption makes blanket surveillance and evidence gathering more difficult. Politicians from strongly pro gun areas also tend, politically, to be strongly pro military and law enforcement.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dang 7y agoThere have been quite a few large threads about the EARN IT act: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=comments%3E30%20%22earn%20it%22&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... This one doesn't seem to add significant new information: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20%22significant%20new%20information%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- suizi 7y agoIt's understandably a very controversial law, but there hasn't been any new information in a while. There may be some coming when they hold another hearing.
- suizi 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23040209 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23040209 CLOUD Act may also be attack on encryption.