5 ms·
One thing that is ignored by the punditocracy is that a laptop has a lot of other silicon beyond the CPU.* Apple would have to have all the support chipset as
by gumby 7y ago
One thing that is ignored by the punditocracy is that a laptop has a lot of other silicon beyond the CPU.* Apple would have to have all the support chipset as well. Internal connections like memory controller etc they already have from iPhone/iPad, but Intel provides support for peripheral access. This works for the iPad, but note that the iPad Pro doesn't have laptop-class USB-C support much to the annoyance of some people. A laptop would have to, and probably would need USB4/TB4 (since if you're designing your own you might as well go straight there -- classic Apple move) which would need all the PCIe, DP etc plumbing they are currently getting from Intel.
Certainly doable, but there's a lot more boring spadework needed beyond the sexy CPU.
* This is why I always laughed when I saw articles comparing laptops by CPU clock speed rather than actual performance.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- adiabatty 7y ago> note that the iPad Pro doesn't have laptop-class USB-C support much to the annoyance of some people. What would make it laptop-class, other than by adding more USB-C ports?
- gumby 7y agoIn short, thunderbolt. I suspect they went to the USB Type-C connector (on the iPad Pro) mainly for power delivery and while they got DisplayPort, they don’t have full peripheral support. USB 3.1g2 (putatively 10 GBPs) is the fastest supported; may be ok for an iPad but not really suitable for a non-archival external disk. These limitations are perfectly reasonable for an iPad but not for a laptop. FWIW nothing but a single TB 4 port (not even an audio jack) would work just fine for me, but I know some others feel differently for their use.
- jkestner 7y agoThunderbolt is built on PCIe, which iPhones don’t use except for the SSD.
- ryukafalz 7y agoThunderbolt is almost entirely Intel-only; IMO not having Thunderbolt on type-C ports certainly doesn’t make something not “laptop-class.” By that metric, the most powerful AMD laptops wouldn’t qualify either.
- saagarjha 7y ago> Thunderbolt is almost entirely Intel-only Considering that USB4 will be Thunderbolt 3 compatible, I'd guess that we'll start seeing more Thunderbolt ports soon.
- turdnagel 7y agoIt's almost certain this is why Apple has taken so long to move their laptops (and desktops, eventually, probably) to ARM. The top-of-the-line iPhone has been benchmarking at or around MacBooks for the past 2-3 years.
- jandrese 7y agoI think backwards compatibility is a bigger stumbling block than support for peripherals. x86_64 emulation on ARM is still pretty bad AFAIK and there is a tremendous amount of Mac software that won't be ported on the first day, or ever in some cases.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eyesee 7y agoI wonder if there are (legal) hurdles to Apple adding an additional x86_64 front end to their custom Mac chips to have hardware 'emulation' for backwards compatibility.
- gumby 7y agoThey could get around that by simply buying AMD who has an old-but-still valid second source license from intel plus of course the true 64-bit x86 architecture. They could also just license it from Intel. AMD has some hot designers (some who cycled through Apple!) but overall has little to add to Apple (in my ignorant-of-the-true-state-of-Hines opinion. And I admire both companies). Apple’s never been afraid to license something rather than do a perfectly legal legal clean room but-almost-perfect clone. I doubt they’d bother.
- mr_toad 7y agoI’ve heard that AMDs license gets voided if the company gets sold.
- monocasa 7y agoYou can get USB RTL cores off the shelf, they're basically a commodity. And they've been shipping PCI-e on their chip for T2. I'm pretty sure the iPad displays are Embedded Display Port, but don't have a source for that.
- edude03 7y agoI'm not sure if this[0] counts as a source, but people have been re purposing iPad LCDs by making DP to eDP breakout board for awhile now. 0: https://emerythacks.blogspot.com/2013/04/connecting-ipad-retina-lcd-to-pc.html https://emerythacks.blogspot.com/2013/04/connecting-ipad-ret...
- zitterbewegung 7y agoThe counter to this argument is that why is Apple putting so many resources to making a keyboard case for the iPad Pro and adding trackpad support. Is this some kind of test for when they move to ARM? Or do they want to do what they have done before and cannibalize the Mac platform for non professionals?
- m463 7y agoIt could be that their customers are growing up with their platform. Kind of like how the Honda Civic has gotten bigger with more features over the years, to where it surpasses the original Accord. I'll bet the Honda Fit from now will grow in the same way and they'll have to invent a new "budget honda" for the next generation of young people.
- 13rac1 7y agoA reason cars keep getting larger is fuel-economy laws. > Expanding a car's footprint — the wheelbase multiplied by the track width — gives it a lower fuel-economy target to meet under the CAFE standards negotiated by automakers and regulators. https://www.autonews.com/article/20160814/OEM11/308159946/is-cafe-making-cars-bigger https://www.autonews.com/article/20160814/OEM11/308159946/is...
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoHuh, so why do cars in Europe tend to be smaller, where I was under the impression that emission laws are stricter?
- ggsp 7y agoBecause the CAFE standards are a US thing
- ultrarunner 7y agoDuring diesel gate I did a lot of research, none of which I still have sadly. Diesel emissions regulations were generally slightly stricter in the U.S. I found that pretty surprising at the time.
- wtallis 7y ago> Apple would have to have all the support chipset as well. Hasn't Apple been pretty obviously moving in that direction? Their T2 chip does a lot. Given how Intel doesn't let third-parties make alternatives to their own southbridge chipsets any more (a change that screwed Apple's product strategy at the time), there's not much more that Apple could move into the T2 until they're ready to abandon Intel CPUs, too.
- tenebrisalietum 7y agoIntel used to only make the CPU in the PC platform. It joined the chipset game sometime in the late 80s or early 90s and eventually pushed everyone like VIA, SiS, OPTi out. Just about all peripheral communications standards for consumers are open standards, like PCIe, USB, SPI, Ethernet, SATA, SAS, and even Thunderbolt now. The only problem I could think of would be the Intel-owned HDMI but it's nothing DisplayPort + a simple dongle can't sidestep. I know Apple couldn't depend on Intel for it's basic GMA acceleration anymore but it could simply use what's in the iPhone for basic display acceleration.
- draw_down 7y agoPunditocracy, good grief.