4 ms·
The fact that the central authority made the right call in this instance doesn’t ultimately mean that the central authority isn’t still dangerous. I hope this
by sneak 7y ago
The fact that the central authority made the right call in this instance doesn’t ultimately mean that the central authority isn’t still dangerous.
I hope this serves as a wake-up call to everyone who got scared by this.
- geofft 7y agoCentral authorities are the worst form of governance, except for all the others.
- SEJeff 7y ago"God save the king!" - OP, probably
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoActually some of the others are just objectively better. Like local authorities which can adapt rules to local conditions and give people the option to exit and go somewhere else if the local rules are sufficiently outside what they find reasonable. It's like asking whether you'd prefer your landlord to have a national monopoly on land. (No.)
- TeMPOraL 7y agoLocal authority is still centralized wrt. a local problem :). It's always nice to have options by being able to deal with multiple people... except when a given issue becomes a tragedy of the commons or some other kind of coordination problem, at which point you really want to have a single superior authority above the ones you were dealing with. This applies recursively. So you want to have one city authority, but many cities; one county authority, but many counties; one state authority, but many states; one country authority, but many countries...
- xxpor 7y agoOh yeah, balkanized local government has worked so well for the bay area.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoFortunately it's also what allows you to move somewhere else where it works much better. Having different problems in different places is actually preferable to having the same problems everywhere, because different problems affect different people differently. It gives people choice. If you don't like San Francisco, move to Austin, or New York, or Miami. Whereas if a central authority makes a rule you can't live under there is nowhere to hide. And even if you stay where you are, it gives you more of a voice, because you aren't being diluted by a constituency so large you can never be heard.
- ivalm 7y ago> Fortunately it's also what allows you to move somewhere else where it works much better. You mean like moving from .org domain to something else? The whole point is that certain resources (like gTLD) are global in nature.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> You mean like moving from .org domain to something else? Consider the alternative -- corruption at ICANN where they sell the root to a private company. Then what are you going to do, move from DNS whatsoever? > The whole point is that certain resources (like gTLD) are global in nature. It's only "global" in the sense that its jurisdictional boundaries are administrative rather than regional. The .org gTLD is operated by different people than the .com gTLD.
- ivalm 7y agoBut .org has a semantic monopoly on “gTLD for NGOs”. If I want to start a new non profit I want a .org, not a .com. One is not an alternative for the other.
- xxpor 7y agoThat's in fact my exact point. It doesn't let you move somewhere else because local governments have set themselves up to only be accountable to a small group of people that already live in the city. (AKA fuck you, I got mine) If housing costs were lower, more people would be able to move to the bay area and take advantage of the incredible wealth creation and job opportunities available. I wouldn't be shocked if the bay areas housing policies were responsible for the loss of 1 percent of GDP growth every year in this county.
- geofft 7y agoSo you're saying DNS registration should work more like how living in a physical place works? Well, where I live, - My landlord and my city are both subject to laws from a national government, and if they're egregiously misbehaving, the national government can step in, but they usually don't. - If I switch landlords, let alone cities, my address changes. - I can choose a landlord and to a lesser extent a city by reputation, but I might end up choosing a city because it's where I want to be for business etc. reasons, even if I disagree with its leadership choices - I have limited ability to influence my city's decision-making and essentially no ability to influence my nation's decision-making, but it's not unheard of. Which all seems very similar to having a choice of registrar, limited choice of TLD/registry, no choice in ICANN, the theoretical (and occasionally practical, as in this case) ability to influence ICANN, and the ability to change registrars and TLDs if I like - as long as I'm okay changing addresses.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> my landlord and my city are both subject to laws from a national government, and if they're egregiously misbehaving, the national government can step in, but they usually don't On the other hand, your city is also subject to its constituents, who care more about what happens there than people in the nation's capital do, so you already have a mechanism to hold them to account when they misbehave. (And the city has jurisdiction over the local landlords.) Meanwhile, what do you do if the national government is doing something that ruins your life, but there aren't enough similarly situated people to get them to stop? If it was only a city you could at least move. > if I switch landlords, let alone cities, my address changes This is costly. It could still be less costly than having nowhere to hide from policies that cause you significant harm, which makes the availability of that option very valuable. > I can choose a landlord and to a lesser extent a city by reputation, but I might end up choosing a city because it's where I want to be for business etc. reasons, even if I disagree with its leadership choices It's all trade offs. If you really want to be there for business reasons and mildly dislike their policies then you might go there anyway. If there are minor business reasons they're preferable but their policies make your life unlivable you might go somewhere else. This is still better than having the unlivable policies imposed nationally, whereupon you would choose your location for business reasons (because the ruinous policy is everywhere), but still have a worse life than having to move to avoid bad policies, because then you'd at least have actually avoided them. > I have limited ability to influence my city's decision-making and essentially no ability to influence my nation's decision-making, but it's not unheard of It's not a binary matter of impossibility, it's a matter of difficulty level. Getting your city to do something is a lot easier than getting your whole country to do it, and they're more likely to be receptive to local problems because a larger percentage of their constituents are affected by them. > Which all seems very similar to having a choice of registrar, limited choice of TLD/registry, no choice in ICANN, the theoretical (and practical, in this case) ability to influence ICANN, and the ability to change registrars and TLDs if I like. It's not the wrong analogy, the question is how much (if any) of the authority actually has to be in ICANN. You could in theory give them no power at all, or have them not exist, and rest control of each gTLD entirely with its respective registrar. I could even turn it around and say that the problem here is that the .org registry is itself too centralized and once it delegates a name to someone it should cease to be under the registrar's control and become permanently under the control of the domain owner, so that who owns .org would only matter to new registrants and not existing ones who already have their delegations.
- colechristensen 7y agoWell, there really is a national monopoly on land. There is no "ownership" natural to the world, just the social contract between the people and their government ensuring rule of law, protection of rights, etc.
- rasengan 7y agoExactly. Organizations shouldn’t be governed by ORG who in turn shouldn’t be governed by ICANN. This action thoroughly makes clear that ICANN controls DNS. Alternatives like Handshake [1] move the root zone to a blockchain as a root of trust avoiding any centralized control and is currently used by many [2]. [1] https://handshake.org https://handshake.org [2] https://dns.live https://dns.live
- jimktrains2 7y agoIt's not as if there haven't been many attempts at distributed dns. Zooko's Triangle [1] is one hurdle. Namecoin and related block chain technologies have similar drawbacks to Bitcoins when it comes to transaction volume. There are also legitimate concerns with many distributed techniques in terms of domain squatting that need to be addressed. I'm not trying to discourage you from creating your own system to try to solve these issues, or support one you think is close. I do find it a bit insulting that you just seem to assume that this problem has never been tackled before. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zooko%27s_triangle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zooko%27s_triangle
- sneak 7y agoThe solutions are hard, because they are social and political, not purely technical. I’m simply serving as a reminder that they’re important despite being hard, and that we should not be dissuaded by their difficulty: the danger is real. > I do find it a bit insulting that you just seem to assume that this problem has never been tackled before. Please try to assume good faith before you assume bad faith.
- jimktrains2 7y agoIf you're going to make people remember and type a cryptographic value, you've missed the whole reason DNS came to be: to provide memorable names. I'd argue that building a system that a computer illiterate person can use is a technical challenge. it's a constraint on the design and architecture of the system.
- battery_cowboy 7y agoThere's other ways to do distributed DNS, I'm sure, than a cryptographic hash. I haven't looked into it much, but "Handshake" is a new distributed DNS system that supposedly works very well. I used to be averse to that idea, but this .org issue clearly shows we cannot trust icann much longer.
- 7y ago