7 ms·
Let this be another nail in the coffin of the "walled garden" farce. We learn this lesson again and again. People want someone to trust, but a bureaucracy isn'
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
Let this be another nail in the coffin of the "walled garden" farce.
We learn this lesson again and again. People want someone to trust, but a bureaucracy isn't trustworthy. It has its own agenda and values inconsistent with yours. They take 30% from everybody whether they approve malware or not, and whether they reject legitimate apps or not.
Trust doesn't come from size. If you want someone to vet your apps, it has to be someone whose interests are actually aligned with yours, not just whoever is big enough to force everybody through the tollgate into their store.
- Razengan 7y agoI would still prefer to have to trust just one authority for my platform than a multitude of random developers. > Let this be another nail in the coffin of the "walled garden" farce. There is no coffin, the walled gardens are not dying, and have long since become the norm, which happened because the people found them to be better than the alternative: getting apps (and manually updating them) from many different sources of varying quality and convenience.
- papermachete 7y agoThat's why you have package managers to work with thousands of repos for you.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoyes, my granny loves working with her package manager with thousands of repos when she wants to install a funny kitty photos app.
- papermachete 7y agoFdroid, ubuntu store, Discover, etc are all graphical interfaces to these. There is no reason to have one authority over packages.
- realusername 7y ago> which happened because the people found them to be better than the alternative Walled garden only exists because mobile devices make self-install alternatives very difficult or impossible to get on purpose, otherwise they would not be able to compete in any ways. Case in point, the Mac App Store and the Windows Store are both moderate failures despite a lot of technical & marketing push.
- pjmlp 7y agoWhich is why with every macOS and Windows release there is some small fine tuning to drive the herd into the sandboxing model. Like frogs cooking in water, macOS and Windows users will be eventually realize that all their apps are store based as well. And for everything else they get Web apps, including AAA games.
- bathtub365 7y agoWhich AAA games are web apps?
- pjmlp 7y agoThe ones being served by Stadia, xCloud, GeForce NOW and PS Now. Plenty to choose from.
- bathtub365 7y agoThat's a pretty loose definition of a web app, but I agree that those services are pretty poor.
- pjmlp 7y agoWell, one needs a browser to access them....
- bathtub365 7y ago
- jmiskovic 7y agoYou misinterpreted. OP was saying that "Apple has walled garden while Google is open" farce is dying and this another confirmation. Sadly people in general can't be trusted to make good decisions because of lack of knowledge and preference of short term gratification over long term well-being.
- Razengan 7y ago> OP was saying that "Apple has walled garden while Google is open" farce is dying and this another confirmation. It's very hard to get that interpretation even after re-reading the OP's comment.
- oliwarner 7y agoThe authority isn't trustworthy though. They're a direct conduit to malware. That's the point here. And try not to conflate walled gardens with software repositories. The benefits of the latter are available without the wall. The wall is significant because it stops you making your own trust judgements.
- amelius 7y ago> I would still prefer to have to trust just one authority for my platform than a multitude of random developers. You mean like open source developers?
- coribuci 7y ago> I would still prefer to have to trust just one authority for my platform than a multitude of random developers. Single point of failure. > > Let this be another nail in the coffin of the "walled garden" farce. > There is no coffin, the walled gardens are not dying, and have long since become the norm, which happened because the people found them to be better than the alternative: getting apps (and manually updating them) from many different sources of varying quality and convenience. No. The people have no alternative. How many people are able to install F-Droid on theyr phone ?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Mindwipe 7y ago> There is no coffin, the walled gardens are not dying, and have long since become the norm, which happened because the people found them to be better than the alternative: getting apps (and manually updating them) from many different sources of varying quality and convenience. No they haven't. Given a fair choice customers have opted for the alternative the vast majority of the time. The walled garden models have only worked when companies have engaged in anti-competitive behaviour.
- Razengan 7y ago> Given a fair choice customers have opted for the alternative the vast majority of the time. As in, Steam versus... Buying and downloading directly from the publishers' websites? The Xbox and PlayStation stores? The Nintendo eShop?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe stores of the console makers use the same anti-competitive platform lock-in as Apple and Google. Steam is the alternative where you get to choose where to install things from -- one of those places is Steam. Installing Steam doesn't prevent you from installing other software from the developer's website or the Linux package manager or Windows store or wherever you like.
- Dragory 7y ago> I would still prefer to have to trust just one authority for my platform than a multitude of random developers. These are not the only two options. What about multiple authorities, but not random individual developers? That's basically how it works with e.g. game stores on PC (though Steam is certainly the largest), or package repositories on Linux. Like you, I like being able to trust an authority to vet the software I install rather than having to judge the trustworthiness of each individual developer, but I'm not a fan of there only being one authority by design (as it is on e.g. iOS). It introduces a single point of failure and gives that authority full control over all software on that platform - for better or worse. Many package managers specifically deal with the issue of consolidating updates to a single system while not relying on a single authority.
- fao_ 7y ago> What about multiple authorities, but not random individual developers? That's basically how it works with e.g. game stores on PC (though Steam is certainly the largest), or package repositories on Linux. > Like you, I like being able to trust an authority to vet the software I install rather than having to judge the trustworthiness of each individual developer, but I'm not a fan of there only being one authority by design (as it is on e.g. iOS). You can already do this on Android though. Samsung offers an individual app store for it's phones, and FDroid works on all phones.
- Razengan 7y agoWhen it comes to the system's core sandboxing mechanism, only one authority can sign the certificates and provision capabilities etc. If multiple authorities can sign apps, it sort of defeats the point and makes the sandboxing less trustworthy. Right now, I can either: Rest assured that an app is sandboxed (via the App Store or macOS Notarization) or choose to let it run anyway (on macOS.) A dev could notarize their game (or not) and distribute it through Steam or the App Store, or both. If Steam and GoG etc. could sign apps, then you're back to having multiple authorities of varying trustworthiness.
- gowld 7y agoHTTPS has multiple authorities. do you use HTTPS?
- ajconway 7y agoBut security is not binary. They (especially Apple) are doing something to limit the amount of fraudulent apps on their platform. I would strongly prefer having a free-for-all platform because I have some basic knowledge of information security. Most people don't.
- scarface74 7y agoHow is your “knowledge” going to help you? Are you capable of vetting every app you install?
- ajconway 7y agoI’m capable of knowing which app I’m going to install. I’m unlikely to fall for Instagram-styled icons that promise me free face filters.
- scarface74 7y agoSo would you have possibly side loaded an app from a trusted vendor like Epic? https://www.theguardian.com/games/2018/aug/10/fortnite-on-android-phones-risk-malware-infections https://www.theguardian.com/games/2018/aug/10/fortnite-on-an... Back in the day would you have installed an app from a supposed trustworthy source like SourceForge? https://www.information-age.com/hotbed-malware-another-blow-sourceforge-google-discovers-588-pages-malicious-software-123459675/ https://www.information-age.com/hotbed-malware-another-blow-... Or even further back, would you have trusted downloading software from CNet owned Download.com? https://malware.wikia.org/wiki/Download.com https://malware.wikia.org/wiki/Download.com
- ajconway 7y agoNo, I only use Facebook and WhatsApp at the moment. I used to downloads lots of malware from porn sites back when I was much younger though.
- 7y ago
- gigatexal 7y agoGoogle play != Apple App Store
- virgilp 7y agoGood comment, I was just about to confuse them.
- scarface74 7y agoI never here users complain - just developers.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- peterwwillis 7y agoNobody has yet said the words "lock-in device". Everybody moans about lock-in devices when it's convenient for them, but then they throw away the ability to use anything else by committing full-tilt to these mobile platforms where to install "unapproved" apps you have to literally hack your own device. Apple and Google got rich doing what we would have lambasted Microsoft for, because our judgement is clouded by brands.
- _bxg1 7y agoAnd yet Apple's walled garden is stronger and hasn't had anywhere near the malware problem that Google's has? I don't understand your point. Privacy is where these companies' interests might not be aligned with users; when it comes to security, they very much are. It's just that for Google that's limited to their own services; they don't care so much when it comes to Android as a broader platform. But even then their interests are not not aligned with users. Just under-incentivized.
- UncleMeat 7y agoThis used to be true. But both Google and Apple release badware numbers and independent analysts do as well. Badware rates are similar on both stores and have been for several years. Play used to be considerably worse than the Apple store, but that is no longer the case. Being late to take security seriously has harmed google though, since this idea is now out there in the wild and keeps getting repeated regardless of the current evidence.
- Lammy 7y agoOf badware they know about. The linked article shows that isn't exactly a useful metric.
- UncleMeat 7y agoOf course it is of badware they know about. This is why 3rd party analyst reports are useful, since you get a second datapoint. This same issue is present for iOS too, so I don't see why it should lead us to believe that Play is worse.
- Darvon 7y agoWhy are you shilling for AAPL shareholders? All megacorps are regulated by the same lack of rules other than maximizing their limited liability profits.
- enjoyyourlife 7y agoWhat about Facebook's API? It is basically at the same level of malware as the apps mentioned in the article
- lkrubner 7y ago"a bureaucracy isn't trustworthy" This kind of rhetoric has been popular in California at least since the 1970s and it has consistently played the same role, which has been to disguise reality. Bureaucracy is expanding because complex societies need complex bureaucracies. This isn't new. You can trace this far back in history. In some sense, the era of bureaucracy began around 3,300 BC when the first Pharaohs wanted to put up the first pyramids and found that they need hundreds of scribes to keep track of all the material, and payments for the material. And bureaucracy has gotten a lot bigger since that time. There are some totally legitimate criticisms that you can make about civilization, especially the way a complex civilization necessarily infringes on some of our basic rights, and the fact that there is a certain kind of inefficiency to bureaucracy. All the same, bureaucracy also has a kind of efficiency to it, especially when organizing things of immense scale. Lazy libertarianism is popular but it is not an accurate guide to the changes happening in our society or our economy.