6 ms·
We need to clone decephalized humans and livestock. With thousands of brainless bodies kept alive on life support, you have test subjects for a limitless numbe
by echelon 7y ago
We need to clone decephalized humans and livestock.
With thousands of brainless bodies kept alive on life support, you have test subjects for a limitless number of experiments that would have never been possible before. You also create a never-ending O negative blood supply and organ harvesting program.
It the case of decephalized animals, you also get cruelty free meat. And that's how you bootstrap the program and port it to the human model.
There would be a lot of political pressure, but this would be a space-age jump in supporting fundamental biological research, supplying renewable body parts and tissues, and keeping us healthy and young.
We need to do it.
If I ever get Elon Musk money and power, I'm doing this instead of rockets.
- bollu 7y agoInteresting; I have never heard the word "decephalized" before --- in what literature in this used?
- encephaloner 7y ago>With thousands of brainless bodies kept alive on life support, you have test subjects for a limitless number of experiments that would have never been possible before. You also create a never-ending O negative blood supply and organ harvesting program. what society would ever produce decephalized humans when they could produce cephalized humans? a weak society that could not possibly adapt or grow. >It the case of decephalized animals, you also get cruelty free meat. only if you redefine cruelty to mean "what happens when bad things happen right in front of you". If a tree falls in a forest and no one hears... >And that's how you bootstrap the program and port it to the human model. of course, it's really no surprise. why are farmers less intelligent than hunter-gatherers? the process of domestication is self-imprinting. I think vegetarians really do have a point- not one that has to do with the cruelty of animals on an individual level, but with the very nature of domestication of animals itself. because the slippery slope of husbandry is ALWAYS eugenics. and the morality applied to animals always gets applied to humans given enough time. >There would be a lot of political pressure, but this would be a space-age jump in supporting fundamental biological research, supplying renewable body parts and tissues, and keeping us healthy and young. >We need to do it. >If I ever get Elon Musk money and power, I'm doing this instead of rockets. of course WE need to do it right? for millions of years humans lived and were forced to accept death, but THIS is the generation that we need to change by creating unholy abominations of our own kind. You are pathetically evil. I will patiently wait for you to die. Let me tell you who you are: "Many modern people, on the other hand, are disturbed by the prospect of physical deterioration and death, as is shown by the amount of effort they expend trying to maintain their physical condition, appearance and health. We argue that this is due to unfulfillment resulting from the fact that they have never put their physical powers to any practical use, have never gone through the power process using their bodies in a serious way. It is not the primitive man, who has used his body daily for practical purposes, who fears the deterioration of age, but the modern man, who has never had a practical use for his body beyond walking from his car to his house. It is the man whose need for the power process has been satisfied during his life who is best prepared to accept the end of that life."
- echelon 7y ago> You are pathetically evil. I will patiently wait for you to die. I have posed an engineering solution to disease that harms zero humans and furthers knowledge many fold, yet you wish for my death. Wow. You are incredibly misguided in your anger. > what society would ever produce decephalized humans when they could produce cephalized humans? a weak society that could not possibly adapt or grow. You can't dissect or experiment on thinking, feeling humans! That's immoral. Decephalized humans never have a thought process or consciousness. They're vegetables grown in a lab. Using them to further science and heal sick people is even more ethical than using lab animals, and I would argue it is our moral imperative to attempt this as soon as possible. You do know that humans are animals and that our time in the universe is limited? My perspective is that there is no god other than us to lift ourselves up to reach the stars. We have to help each other as best as we can, and this technological reverse salient is begging for exploitation. It unlocks so much potential. Biology is a platform, a machine, an ecosystem. We need to fully commandeer it. We're still in the punch card phase, and I want to see us reach the biological equivalent of compilers. It's a fluke that I even exist, and I want to take full advantage of my limited time here. You're putting up artificial barriers and limitations.
- encephaloner 7y ago>I have posed an engineering solution blah blah blah "Don't worry guys, all Nazi Germany did was invent and execute engineering solutions! they are free of all moral consequences!" >harms zero humans >You can't dissect or experiment on thinking, feeling humans! That's immoral. >there is no god other than us to lift ourselves up to reach the stars >Biology is a platform, a machine, an ecosystem. let me get your argmuent right: treating humans like mindless animals and dehumanizing them = immoral bad nazi experimentation, playing god. it's cruel! don't you know that people have dignity and can feel pain! making humans like mindless animals and dehumanizing them = moral, good, playing god, the purpose of society is just to live forever so I can post on hacker news, if we make them into genetic abominations they can't feel pain, and can't have dignity! You have the simplest understanding of morality that contradicts on the slightest inspection. the reason you think this way is because you never question the basic axioms of your belief system that was handed down you. It is clear that you have a completely meaningless understanding of cruelty beyond hedonistic "pain = cruelty". >Biology is a platform, a machine, an ecosystem. We need to fully commandeer it so we can make it into a perverted abomination as soon as possible. I think life itself has some intrinsic value (it could perhaps be described as a type of pervasive-yet-hidden beauty) besides just existing forever in a perverted and impotent form. >You do know that humans are animals and that our time in the universe is limited? yes I am quite aware
- trianglem 7y agoDecephalized humans would be great for the sex industry.
- encephaloner 7y agoDecephalized HN posters would be great for fascist dystopia. If you can justify the creation of human cattle the purposes of masturbation, you are a monster. You are worse than hitler, because even hitler cared about german people. You would be complicit with "I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream" just for your own sexual amusement. and because you "LOVE SCIENCE" so much
- amankl 7y agoI've seen a lot here, but this takes the cake. I'm not sure if that post is a troll, assuming it is not: Half of the energy and time of any decent person with morals goes into stopping smart psychopaths like that poster from doing whatever the heck they want. I'm not religious, but it makes me wonder if the church is actually needed to keep those people in check.
- mattigames 7y agoIf you want to be taken seriously you need to specify what morals is this violating exactly, it may be obvious to you but not to your readers.
- ngla 7y agoAs Shapiro says, you need to be taken seriously where it matters. If you sincerely need to ask which morals this violates, you show that you have no classical humanistic education. Such an education cannot be provided in a web forum. It is sad that because of a couple of psychopaths tech people are not taken seriously outside of web forums.
- mattigames 7y agoIs easy to claim the moral high ground when you don't define it, meaning where are you drawing the line? If I lose a leg in an accident and some scientists (plus doctors) can make a clone of my leg and my leg only to reattach it on my body is that moral or amoral? If yes then what about the complete lower body? If yes what about everything below the neck?
- joyj2nd 7y ago"With thousands of brainless bodies kept alive on life support," It is questionable, if you can do this without a brain. Have you seen Elysium? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elysium_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elysium_(film)
- alevskaya 7y agoI worked as a genetic engineer in human cell therapy: developmental biology doesn't really work that way. You can't just "decephalize" without causing massive secondary effects in body development and maturation - the nervous system is very much a central part and organizer of animal development, and also centrally important in a lot of the physiology you want to test when doing drug trials! And good luck keeping decephalized animals alive long enough to harvest outside a sterile lab. You don't need to be an edgelord billionaire to make a difference, but you'd benefit by learning more biology.
- echelon 7y agoI don't have firsthand experience, but it seems like you could play with ectoderm development in conjunction with manual surgical techniques. Program the neural tube cells to die at a certain stage of development or when treated with certain media. I think keeping the body alive will pose a much greater problem than preventing the brain from developing.