3 ms·
Why is the cost to bend one of the roads slightly, creating an offset junction, £100,000?
by Symbiote 7y ago
Why is the cost to bend one of the roads slightly, creating an offset junction, £100,000?
- rozab 7y agoDid you see this other post on the front page right now? I Could Do That in a Weekend https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23019816 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23019816
- Dylan16807 7y agoYou're linking that just to be insulting, I guess? Asking why the cost is some number is very different from claiming you could do it yourself for cheaper. Is the biggest cost tearing up existing things, bringing out the heavy machines, the raw materials, the labor, or something else? How many man-hours are needed anyway? There is nothing wrong with asking why it costs a certain amount. The average person has zero expertise in the cost structure of laying paved road.
- RandomBacon 7y agoMy guess: purchasing the land, paying for studies, laying new road, removing old road. £100,000 sounds cheap. Two people already died. If I was a family member of a third victim, I would've wanted the government to pay £100,000. I would be asking government officials if it was worth it. (Approx 125,000 USD at today's exchange rate)
- Symbiote 7y agoThere's a linked response from Hampshire County Council [1]: "We are working with partners at New Forest District Council, the National Park Authority, English Nature, The Verderers, The Forestry Commission and the police to explore what can be done longer term and are currently carrying out a review of the junction, which we hope to finalise in the new year. The land beyond the paved road surface is Crown land and this will require permissions to be granted to us for any realignment of the road to be carried out." Crown land (part of the national park, presumably) means it "belongs" to the queen, so that shouldn't be an issue. Other comments on that discussion say the same offset junction has been done in many other places. The best thing is probably for anyone who lives in Hampshire to write to their MP. https://beyondthekerb.org.uk/collision-course/#addendum https://beyondthekerb.org.uk/collision-course/#addendum
- arethuza 7y agoA lot of times where they put in a kink at a junction like that they don't even remove the old road - just leave it and the farmer will use it for storing bales etc.
- Benji_San 7y agoSeems really cheap tho. I wonder what the Medical cost + opportunity costs for avoiding e.g. 50% of crashes in the junction would be over e.g. 10 years. Probably a lot more than 100k for fixing the junction.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI think California DOT tracks collisions and has at least some sort of algorithm to decide when to make changes. Scary looking link to guidelines. https://fhwaapps.fhwa.dot.gov/hsipp/Attachments/aa343eab-2cb8-474a-9101-8fc3d012c440_2017%20STATE%20HSIP%20GUIDELINES%20FINAL.pdf https://fhwaapps.fhwa.dot.gov/hsipp/Attachments/aa343eab-2cb... That said I looked at the intersection on google maps. Here it would have have had a stop sign at least or fixed decades ago.