4 ms·
Yeah, but assuming no right-of-way will lead to not having a life of any sort. I can't even imagine living life this way. Can you imagine that? A Tesla is stop
by renewiltord 7y ago
Yeah, but assuming no right-of-way will lead to not having a life of any sort. I can't even imagine living life this way.
Can you imagine that? A Tesla is stopped at a red light just before a pedestrian crossing. The Tesla can go from 0-30 mph before I can cross its width at walking pace. The walk light is on. I have the right-of-way. But considering the Tesla could go from 0-30 mph in the time I could pass it, your suggested course of action is to just wait until a slower-to-accelerate car stops at the intersection?
- RandomBacon 7y agoI can imagine it because I do. I always keep an eye on cars as I'm walking in their path. It's not hard. I don't stop unless they aren't slowing down, and I'm always ready to move in a different direction and/or a different speed. I'm not saying everyone can do that, and I think we agree that people shouldn't have to do that. Situational awareness, constantly coming up with alternative plans, and always making sure an "out" is available has kept me alive in dangerous situations. Anyway, that's how I live. People are wired diferently.
- renewiltord 7y agoAll right, describe your behaviour under these (very common, in San Francisco) circumstances: A Tesla is stopped at a red light just before a pedestrian crossing. The Tesla can go from 0-30 mph before you can cross its width at walking pace. The walk light is on. You have the right-of-way.
- RandomBacon 7y agoWhat are you trying to accomplish? To answer your question, it's like I said: situational awareness. Is the driver only looking at oncoming traffic, or do they look around? It's rare, but I have waited at crosswalks with the walk light on because it wasn't safe. I have also walked out of the way or not walked when a driver still saw me and went anyway.
- renewiltord 7y agoTo detect the boundaries of your rules to determine whether they can be implemented reasonably by an arbitrary individual and to illustrate that there are limits where your own stated rules would fail and you likely violate them. So far I have determined from your rules that you should never step in front of an electric vehicle under any condition. The driver could look right at you and accidentally step on the pedal. After all, situational awareness doesn't bring people back to life.
- RandomBacon 7y ago> I have determined from your rules that you should never step in front of an electric vehicle under any condition. That would be a poor deduction. It seems like you have a bone to pick. I don't care to facilitate or engage in such behaviors.
- downerending 7y agoI do regularly make eye contact before crossing in front of cars, even in the crosswalk with the right of way. But, yes, a car with that much acceleration has no business on the public roadways.
- Cogito 7y agoIn these threads it feels like you are not reading what they are saying, or at least reading it in the least charitable way. Defensive driving simply means to not assume drivers are going to take an action until they give evidence of it. If a driver is going to stop at an intersection, they will slow down before they get to the intersection. A defensive driver approaching a crossing with other cars approaching will look for evidence that the other cars are slowing down before assuming that they will stop. If a car is stopped at a pedestrian crossing and a defensive pedestrian is looking to cross, they will look for evidence the car is about to accelerate into the crossing. They don't assume the car will suddenly accelerate for no reason, because there is no evidence that they would! Evidence that they may suddenly accelerate includes things like looking down at their phone, or not looking at pedestrians. If the defensive pedestrian sees that evidence they approach the crossing with caution, ready to take evasive action or not enter the crossing if needed. Right-of-way tells everyone who has the right of way, it makes the expected behaviour clear. Assuming that everyone else will do what you expect them to do is extremely dangerous, as even without malice or carelessness it's very easy for each invloved party to have different assumptions about the expected bahviour. So, to be defensive it's important to - have a well informed understanding of what you think should happen - look for evidence that all parties are acting in accordance with what you think should happen - be prepared to change your actions if any party does not act in accordance with what you think should happen
- renewiltord 7y agoI think it's quite clear. These threads mostly involve people acting like they're better drivers than they are and claiming behaviour they do not practise. Then they'll come here and act a bit sanctimonious "Why didn't the X just do Y? I always do Y". It's just the Wobegon Effect in action. I don't read it charitably because of the sanctimony involved in not reading an accident situation with the Understanding Human Error strategy, thereby leading to a bunch of low-quality comments about how people should just be better, involving poor understanding of public health and traffic engineering principles. It's true, I probably shouldn't engage when the nth accident analysis by a HNer is "Why didn't the pilot just not crash into the mountain? When I see a mountain I just avoid crashing into it". No one is likely to get anything from that.
- valuearb 7y agoIf the Tesla driver does not make eye contact with you, be cautious. That’s defensive walking in a nutshell.