8 ms·
3 things: 1. People keep saying about the market being up recently, but skip the part about it still being down about 10% since the start of the year. 2. S&P
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
3 things:
1. People keep saying about the market being up recently, but skip the part about it still being down about 10% since the start of the year.
2. S&P is heavily weighted towards the strongest companies. Amazon, Apple, Facebook, Microsoft and Google account for 20% of S&P market cap. Most of those companies have been helped by the pandemic, or at least not hurt nearly as bad as smaller companies.
3. The market is always very forward looking. It is essentially betting that things are as bad as they'll get. I don't know if I personally necessarily agree, but if you look at countries starting to open up it's not an unreasonable bet.
- steveeq1 7y agoBetter explanation: the fed is buying securities.
- lisper 7y agoThis. What you're seeing is the beginning of a massive currency inflation.
- ganeshkrishnan 7y agoIt's very hard to have currency based inflation especially for USD which is in very high demand.
- lisper 7y agoHave you looked at the Fed's balance sheet lately? It is quite literally off the charts. https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren... It is no harder to inflate the dollar than any other currency. Print enough of them, and the their price will go down. It's no different from any other commodity.
- asah 7y agoserious q: down relative to what other currency or asset? gold? bitcoin? real estate?
- lisper 7y agoWell, stocks at the moment. The real value of U.S. stocks has not risen 20% in one month. What has really happened is that the U.S. dollar has lost 20% of its value relative to stocks. Inflation takes a long time to work its way into the economy at large, and it is possible that it won't happen. We managed to avoid it after 2008, but back then we had some very competent people running the show. I'm less sanguine about that this time around. My reading of the tea leaves is that the Trump administration will prop up stock prices by whatever means necessary because they believe (probably correctly) that many people will vote according to the bottom line of their 401ks. But it is simply not possible to keep pumping currency into a shrinking economy without producing inflation. Sooner or later the law of supply and demand will catch up with you. The only question is whether it will happen before or after November.
- xxpor 7y agoInflation has only been on a downward trend since the early 80s, despite what everyone predicted when Nixon closed the gold window.
- lisper 7y agoThat's because the economy has grown more or less apace with the money supply (or, more accurately, because the Fed has controlled the growth of the money supply to keep pace with the economy). Now we are pumping cash into a shrinking economy. You can't do that for very long without producing inflation.
- dd36 7y agoIt’s also because of the undermining of labor unions. They haven’t returned.
- 7y ago
- tathougies 7y agoThat doesn't explain foreign markets
- jcfrei 7y agoSame is happening in Japan, Europe, China, etc.
- godzillabrennus 7y agoPaying a premium for junk...
- artursapek 7y agoThis is what the government does best!
- officemonkey 7y agoIt's called Lemon Socialism. Businesses keep their winnings. Governments pay their losses.
- JKCalhoun 7y ago> 1. People keep saying about the market being up recently So, down 10% from the previous bubble. > 2. S&P is heavily weighted towards the strongest companies Good point. Dow is also up almost as much though. > 3. The market is always very forward looking. I may be cynical, but I see perhaps 2 to 3 years to regain the jobs we are losing, to see the employment rate return to earlier levels. That's years of depressed spending, and all the other woes of society from high unemployment. So the market is looking to, what, 2025 or something? Sorry to pick on you, I still just don't get it.
- xienze 7y ago> So the market is looking to, what, 2025 or something? Well, another point not mentioned is, where else are you going to park your money? Interest rates globally are basically <= 0, real estate may be a dicey proposition for many years to come, bond yields are garbage, so... stock market. And considering so many companies are selling at a discount (regardless of whether or not you think that’s the case), dumping money in the stock market is a pretty good bet right now.
- lmm 7y agoYou can't even just spend it on crack and hookers. I wonder how many people's net worth is actually going up during the lockdown just because of reduced expenditure.
- JKCalhoun 7y agoYou're getting downvoted, but I agree — I have at least stopped eating out as much as I had before.
- sulZ 7y agoCould you share your thoughts on why real estate may be dicey in the years to come?
- mywittyname 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- matwood 7y agoYou're spot on. The companies you listed plus others are going to come out of this leaner, with fewer competitors, and a whole set of new people forced to learn how to use them. Great news for those companies. I would also add a #4 to your list that people often miss. There is risk and there is uncertainty (think unknown unknowns). The market hates uncertainty because it is so hard to price. Risk though can be priced. This is often why the market will go up with numbers that look really bad when they come in. They are no longer uncertain.
- take_a_breath 7y ago==Great news for those companies.== The downside for those companies will be the regulators at DOJ. I have no doubt they will survive this pandemic in even better shape than before. The question then is if the government will work to break them up. Obvious examples would be splitting YouTube from Google, splitting Instagram and WhatsApp from Facebook and forcing Amazon to pick a side (own the marketplace or be a seller).
- short_sells_poo 7y agoThis is very much what most people don't understand. The primary driver of market stress is uncertainty. Once that is gone and the bad news has been digested, that's it. If lagging indicators further confirm the bad news, that's almost irrelevant because there is no new information content there. Most traders are not stupid, they know the economy is going to tank. The information that there is going to be a recession is already known and pricd in. The question at this point is how much is it going to tank? If it tanks more than expected, or 2nd/3rd order effects materialize (e.g. solvency issues, deleveraging, etc...) then prices will fall more. At this point I'd also like to stress that what you personally expect is not neccessarily what the market expectation is. The market is never wrong in this sence, it is just a consensus of opinions. Opinions are by definition subjective. When new information arrives, the opinions change. In a mathematical sense, the relationship isn't as much between the absolute level of the economy and prices, it is the tendency of the economy and the prices. You should look at the first (maybe second?) differentials. Furthermore, values like GDP are inherently lagging. They show data that has happened months ago. There's almost no new information content in that number. Yes the number is bad, but everyone knew it's going to be bad. It sounds like (judging by the market action) that it wasn't worse than consensus. Now, all the above is viewed through a lens of efficient markets. Reality is again more complex. As it has been pointed out, the price is not just driven by expectations about the economy or stocks, it is very much driven by central bank and government action. Easy money distorts prices. When Tesla which makes a puny 400k cars a year and has just about stopped being loss making is priced higher than VW which makes >6 million cars a year and made $17 billion, something is off. Let's put that into context, Tesla shares have priced in decades of non-stop geometric (20% YoY) sales growth to justify the _present_day_ valuation. Don't think for a moment that traders don't know this. It's absolutely a game of musical chairs and they know it. Everyone, and I repeat, even the most boring, backwater pension fund board knows that this is a bubble. Everyone is participating and hopes that when the music stops, they'll have already made some safe haven stockpile to weather the storm.
- bachmeier 7y ago4. Government policy, both current and expected future. I want to add emphasis on (2). The effects are not spread out uniformly across all businesses. The hard hit businesses including restaurants, bars, and hair and nail salons have seen almost all of their business evaporate. You're not going to find the corner nail salon in the S&P 500.
- notahacker 7y agoyep. The assumption is they'll be able to borrow more cheaply and easily than ever before and will be able to buy up [assets of] more cashflow-constrained businesses in related markets relatively cheaply. A related assumption is also that government bonds will be a less attractive alternative place for investors to park their money.
- lettergram 7y agoNo but you do find banks, chemical manufacturers, car dealerships, etc. the people employed by the corner nail salon buy goods, indirectly driving the economy.
- banannaise 7y agoThe economy's response to "a large segment of the population has no money to buy things" seems to be selling more stuff and more expensive stuff to those who do. The economy is essentially trying to cut many people out of it entirely. (and yes, I know 'the economy' isn't some sentient monolith)
- quickthrowman 7y agoWhere do you think those small businesses buy their supplies/inventory from? The employees of these businesses also consume products from large cap companies. Who is going to buy things if they’re out of work?
- bachmeier 7y agoAbsolutely. There will be some of those effects for sure, and they'll be pretty big. They will nonetheless be nothing compared to the small business owners that have bills to pay but no money coming in. Microsoft, on the other hand, is facing more of a blip.
- KirinDave 7y agoOn #2: No one is helped except perhaps medical supply companies. Folks are mistaking the durability of these companies in the face of SIP orders (due to their ability to function under WFH conditions).
- chefandy 7y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2020/4/28/21239516/npd-consumer-spending-technology-work-from-home-education-entertainment https://www.theverge.com/2020/4/28/21239516/npd-consumer-spe... "Sales of monitors increased by 73 percent compared to last year, PCs were up 53 percent, printers were up by 61 percent, and microphones were up by a massive 147 percent. Chromebook sales are also reportedly seeing triple-digit sales increases, which makes sense given how popular they are in classrooms. Underpinning all this tech is a 70 percent increase in the sale of networking equipment. Although not detailed in Baker’s tweets, we’ve also seen a shortage of webcams, leading to skyrocketing prices." It does look like some businesses besides medical equipment manufacturers have benefited. I'd be shocked if other things like sewing machines haven't seen huge growth in sales, also.
- KirinDave 7y agoSure, but this is not a sustained trend. It's a panic buy right after a major disruption to the market.
- chefandy 7y agoPanic buy? Monitors? More like the role of these devices is changing in people's lives. I'd wager that more people are going to be spending more time at home for quite some time, and that even for the people who won't, they'll start to be more sensitive to the shortcomings of their electronics after spending way more time using them than the would have had there been more things to do outside of the house.
- kgwgk 7y ago> People keep saying about the market being up recently, but skip the part about it still being down about 10% since the start of the year. It's also at the same level as one year ago. The economic situation, and outlook, is surely worse than one year ago? What has improved is the Fed inclination to make it true that stonks can only go up.
- milesskorpen 7y agoGoogle and Facebook definitely are not being helped right now. Advertising is drying up.
- bhupy 7y agoAlphabet just reported a 13% increase in revenue for Q1.
- pc86 7y agoThe lion's share of the pandemic closures have been in Q2 so this seems either irrelevant or disingenuous.
- bhupy 7y agoWe'll see. Facebook might do poorly in Q2, but Alphabet does way more than advertising now: it does cloud infrastructure (GCP) and productivity (Google Apps for Business), both of which have experienced sharp gains in this pandemic.
- pc86 7y agoWe'll see if the lion's share of the pandemic closures happened in Q2? That's an objective fact. We started feeling it in March but the vast majority of action happened in April. April is in Q2.
- bhupy 7y agoNo, we'll see the degree to which Alphabet is exposed to the pandemic closures — which as you said, objectively happened. A key detail from the Alphabet earnings: there appeared to be different performance trajectories for the brand and direct response components of their advertising. Direct response continued to have substantial year-on-year growth throughout the entire quarter — can be explained by brands now directly reaching people at home under quarantine. Brand advertising growth accelerated in the first 2 months of the quarter, but began to experience a headwind in mid-March. Snap's earnings call appeared to include the same observation, from Evan Spiegel: "In the short-term, we are shifting sales resources and pulling forward some investments in direct response to better serve the advertisers who are trying to reach our audience during this time…". Additionally, Alphabet obviously also makes its money through Google Cloud Platform, whose compute usage will continue to pick up as more and more people consume online content at home. The net argument is that, even in Q2, Alphabet might come out looking stable because it is not as exposed to the downsides of COVID as, say, Twitter or Facebook. THAT is what I mean when I say "we'll see".
- claydavisss 7y agoIf markets were truly forward looking and near-omniscient, the dip to 18k would never have happened, because the far-looking and omniscient market would know that eventually covid and its impacts would be addressed. Reality: the market is a 48-hour sentiment guess
- cm2187 7y agoThe S&P is where it was in October last year, there, it just erased the massive gain in Q1 this year. No serious recession is priced in really. And the only thing that can explain where the stocks are now is that the Fed has pushed 2 trillions of liquidity into the market in matter of weeks, which is just unprecendented (the previous QE were much more gradual) and that lifted all asset classes. But at one point stock prices will need to get back in line with earnings. I don't really hear anyone talking about v-shaped recovery anymore.
- bhupy 7y ago> No serious recession is priced in really. That's not entirely true, the composition of the S&P500 has pretty dramatically changed in the last few months[1]. If you look at the linked chart most sectors are down — energy is -50%, consumer discretionary is -27%, financials are -22%. However, a few sectors are up — healthcare is +5%, consumer staples +6.5%, information technology is +8.5%. So with shelter-in-place and quarantine, it makes sense that the world's demand for oil and travel is at all time lows, and the stock prices reflect this. Instead, the demand is now almost entirely online, on the internet. Nearly every IT sector company is surging. Even real-estate is down, as expected (fewer moves happening, less commercial leasing), but it appears to have a high variance[2]. Why is that? There are actually a few real estate companies on the S&P that are doing really well: $SBAC (operates wireless infrastructure), $EQIX (specializes in datacenters), $AMT (wireless and broadcast communications infrastructure), and $CCI (shared communications infrastructure). So, many sectors of the economy are down, as are most companies. The current pandemic has pushed more capital to businesses which operate online. So the reason why the market cap of the S&P500 hasn't changed dramatically is because the distribution of the money underlying it has. The S&P500 is a capitalization-weighted index. > But at one point stock prices will need to get back in line with earnings. I don't really hear anyone talking about v-shaped recovery anymore. This week a lot of tech companies are reporting their earnings. Alphabet announced a 13% increase in revenue. If other tech, communication infrastructure, consumer staples, and personal health companies report similar earnings, then this whole thesis will be validated: the S&P500's current market value can largely be attributed to a flight-to-quality, where the "quality" is pandemic-proof stocks. [1] https://imgur.com/a/6ZOCbBI https://imgur.com/a/6ZOCbBI [2] https://imgur.com/a/JF3u463 https://imgur.com/a/JF3u463
- Aperocky 7y agoAdd to that the feds have been quantitatively easing and the money has to go somewhere. The market doesn't need to reflect the reality when you have an excess of cheap cash on the market.
- mcguire 7y agoI'm going to have to argue with 3 a bit. The market incorporates news quickly, such as that there is a pandemic and it is going to have bad effects. Then it essentially forgets about it. I suspect most of the 12% is a response to government actions to control the pandemic and to the recent news that it is coming under control. You will see another drop if relaxing controls leads to another covid spike, and when economic effects appear on corporate financial reports, and when long term job losses are reported. Those are perfectly foreseeable, but in the meantime the market will likely go up as the memory of why they went down in the first place fades.
- asdff 7y agoWe are heading for a leg down now that earnings are coming up, and everyone is going to whiff.
- snarf21 7y agoI agree and there is one other thing. Interest rates are 0 you can try to sit on cash but with the increase in money into the system, that is a loser long term. The Fed is buying things to keep prices up. There are trillions that have to go somewhere. Asset prices continue to propped up and people and funds are chasing returns.
- jkqwzsoo 7y ago> 2. S&P is heavily weighted towards the strongest companies. Amazon, Apple, Facebook, Microsoft and Google account for 20% of S&P market cap. Most of those companies have been helped by the pandemic, or at least not hurt nearly as bad as smaller companies. I thought I'd look up the performance of various indexes for the past month (as of the time I looked them up): * S&P 500: +15.2% * Dow Jones Industrial Average: +14.1% * Nasdaq Composite Index: +17.9% * Russell 2000: +21.7% * Russel 3000: +16.0% * Wilshire 5000: +16.3% I then looked at the YTD, and didn't bother comparing them because they all essentially looked identical to one another. Note that the DJIA and NDQ are mostly contained within the S&P are they are highly correllated. Weighting aside (I'm not actually sure what differencs their might be), the S&P is contained in R3k and W5000, but not R2k. So no, I don't think the idea that Apple and Facebook are doing well (thus keeping hte S&P numbers inflated) holds weight. In fact, the Russell 2000 does not include the top 1000 companies (like the Russell 3000) and shows the highest return for the past month. Rather, it seems like all of these indices are correlated. It reminds me of the Hillary Clinton autoregression of prediction markets during the 2016 election: immune to new information.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> So no, I don't think the idea that Apple and Facebook are doing well (thus keeping hte S&P numbers inflated) holds weight. The easiest, and best, comparison for this is to look at the S&P 500 vs an S&P 500 equal weighted index (where all stocks are weighted equality, instead of weighted based on market cap). Over 3 months (i.e. just before the market peaked) the equal weighted index is down almost 15%, while the market cap weighted index is down just over 10%. This is clear evidence the larger companies are significantly outperforming the smaller ones.
- three_seagrass 7y ago4. Investors are driven by quarterly results. Q1 earnings are all being released right now by major companies, and since the pandemic only really hit in March, they're reporting pretty good results and investors are reacting as they always do. This is despite the economic slow down as B2C companies losing 20-100% of their customers and B2B companies lose their B2C customers who no longer have income.