8 ms·
So if I understand this correctly... YouTube took these videos down based on a copyright (DMCA?) claim. Which of course isn't a court ruling or anything. At t
by crazygringo 7y ago
So if I understand this correctly...
YouTube took these videos down based on a copyright (DMCA?) claim. Which of course isn't a court ruling or anything.
At the same time, no court would ever uphold this removal, because it obviously falls under "parody" which is protected. (Otherwise shows like Saturday Night Live couldn't even exist.)
After all, the end result is no different from a really good vocal impersonator. In fact, a really good impersonator will definitely do better.
It's disappointing that Jay-Z (or more likely some lawyer working for him) is abusing YouTube's takedown mechanism this way.
But at the same time, I can see how this could seem particularly scary for a performer. After all, if you've spent decades creating a recognizable profitable persona... the idea that anybody with a personal computer can flood YouTube with fake lyrics that aren't yours could feel terrifyingly like losing control of everything you've built.
What if some really nasty stuff went viral and became as associated with Jay-Z as the rest of his stuff? Stuff that did serious damage to his brand, which "nobody could unhear"?
I genuinely wonder if deepfake technology will actually result in new copyright restriction law. I.e. to make it a crime to produce unlicensed deepfakes that are genuinely indistinguishable to the average person, regardless of whether they're parody or not. (While "bad" parodies like SNL will continue to be protected as always.)
I kind of feel like that's going to have to be the outcome at some point in the near future -- in fact, as soon as really convincing yet nasty deepfakes of senators and representatives start making the rounds and spreading on Facebook, I suspect a new law will get passed incredibly quickly.
- kupiakos 7y agoI imagine that would likely fall under a new trademark or fraud law rather than copyright.
- blackearl 7y agoIt's a very fuzzy line they'll need to draw. The Onion seems like a good example of parody done really well, to a point that people often "eat the onion" and believe it. Would it be defamation if you published a quote that wasn't actually said by someone? That might be the analog they use to go after deepfakes in the future.
- colordrops 7y agoThe definition of parody is somewhat vague, and parody is often subtle. It seems difficult to define and enforce objectively.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoThe youtube definition is "Whoever has the most money is correct"
- travisjungroth 7y agoI could actually see it as libel. You’re leading people to believe the artist did something (created a work or said something) which isn’t true. SNL and other parodies would obviously be exempt because there’s no misrepresentation. A reasonable person doesn’t actually believe Trump went on SNL and happens to look like Alec Baldwin that day.
- judge2020 7y agoThe article doesn't go into detail on what happened. If it was a [manual] Content ID claim, there's no legal reason YT has to remove the video; the content ID system exists to provide an (arguably abusable) way for YT to scan every piece of uploaded content for copyrighted material. If it was a DMCA, YouTube has to remove the video to maintain impunity. But, as stated in a related comment, this is new territory in the eyes of the law. Maybe this video is a parody, but if it's not clear about that it would be clearly illegal. Even an extremely good impersonator can be sued if they try to actually pass themselves off as someone else.
- akersten 7y ago> I kind of feel like that's going to have to be the outcome at some point in the near future -- in fact, as soon as really convincing yet nasty deepfakes of senators and representatives start making the rounds and spreading on Facebook, I suspect a new law will get passed incredibly quickly. Ugh, that is the type of free-speech infringement that people should be worried about, not all this stuff about how YouTube taking down videos is government censorship. A really good deepfake is still fiction. Really good writing is fiction. Really poorly-written fake "news" blogs "reporting" lies as truth is fiction. These are all allowed to exist (in the USA) because of the 1st Amendment. It is the price that we pay for living in a free society, that the government cannot tell you "your fiction is not allowed." Textual accounts of real events, and lies about real events, have existed for ages. Sometimes the lies are more convincing than the truth. Audio recording and doctored audio has existed for ages. Photography and doctored photos have existed for ages. Video recording and doctored video has existed for ages. We'll survive another flavor of doctoring just fine without the government's help.
- jariel 7y agoNo, copying and 'reporting on' / parodying / sampling etc. are very different things. A writer who makes a book that is word-for-word the same as another book is infringement. Making a pixel-perfect copy of a photo, from scratch, is an infringement. Copying a song, perfectly, is infringement. Whether something is a 'lie or the truth' - or 'which one is more convincing' doesn't really matter. With 'deepfakes' we're going to have to get serious because people will literally be putting words in other people's mouths, creating fake representations of other people, it's going to cause problems. This issue may not actually fall under copyright.
- staticautomatic 7y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Prince https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Prince
- akersten 7y agoI feel like you've replied to the wrong comment - I'm not defending copyright infringement, misuse of celebrity likeness, or the content of this video. I'm specifically addressing the notion that the government would carve out a free-speech exception for "deepfakes", like "deep fakes of Politicians / Celebrities are illegal." Which would be clearly unconstitutional, because you are forbidding creation of a creative, expressive work. Whether the works that you are free to create, regardless of format (photoshopped image, deepfaked video), violate some other law - libel/slander - is separate as well. Yes, they certainly could, just like a photoshopped image today could be libelous.
- jameslevy 7y agoWhether or not a deepfake is used for a parody is far less important than whether content using deepfakes identifies its artificial nature. Deepfake content masquerading as real content is actually dangerous and should be regulated as such. But no, Jay-Z should not be able to take down parodies on YouTube that make it clear to the viewer that they are using deepfakes.
- gpm 7y agoDeepfake used for parody is almost certainly protected by the first amendment under US law. So legally that is a very important distinction. (Morally, well, that's not a productive thing to debate on the internet usually)
- roywiggins 7y agoIt's not obvious to me that it's parody. Is it actually making fun of Jay-Z? Is it parodying his songs? His voice? It's not a caricature, it's not commenting on Jay-Z's character or vocal styles or lifestyle or opinions.
- Reelin 7y ago> no court would ever uphold this removal, because it obviously falls under "parody" which is protected Not a lawyer, but... It doesn't seem like parody to me. It also doesn't seem like it has much of anything to do with copyright at all - one of the videos taken down was reportedly a performance of an excerpt from Hamlet, which is definitely in the public domain. On the other hand it does seem like a possible violation of trademark law, but I have no idea how that would play out in court. Which is confusing, because I thought the DMCA only applied to copyright (it's the Digital Millennium _Copyright_ Act, after all) but perhaps I'm wrong and it includes provisions about trademark as well?
- cmeacham98 7y ago> Which is confusing, because I thought the DMCA only applied to copyright (it's the Digital Millennium _Copyright_ Act, after all) but perhaps I'm wrong and it includes provisions about trademark as well? As far as I know, a legally enforceable "DMCA takedown" can only be about copyright infringement. However, YouTube is under no obligation to not honor takedowns that aren't legally binding.
- stcredzero 7y agoHowever, YouTube is under no obligation to not honor takedowns that aren't legally binding. That's what's ripe for abuse. Why isn't it a fiduciary responsibility to their "partners" to make sure they aren't needlessly deprived of revenue, in situations where a 1st year law student could tell them there isn't a legal basis for the takedown?
- PeterisP 7y agoDetails matter - "takedown that is not legally binding" does not mean that "there isn't a legal basis for the takedown". The legal basis for the takedown is the language in the Youtube terms and conditions that says that Youtube can take down the content at their discretion. It does not matter if that decision is caused by a non-binding takedown request of a self-asserted copyright owner, or by a drunken manager randomly clicking to remove videos, the legal arrangement between Youtube and their "partners" does not assume any fiduciary responsibility to ensure that your videos will be kept unless absoltely needed, and no current law is forcing them to assume that responsibility. I mean, the statement "why isn't it a fiduciary responsibility to their "partners" to make sure they aren't needlessly deprived of revenue," seems very weird from the perspective of law - why would there be such a responsibility? Do you have some law in mind that would cause it? E.g. CEOs have fiduciary responsibility to shareholders, stockbrokers have fiduciary responsibility to their clients due to specific laws, but in general there is no fiduciary responsibility between parties in a contract, the parties can be 'hostile' towards each other as much as they want. The default legal position is that every private actor is free to act as they want for their own benefit as long as they are not breaking any laws or contracts. If I cause you some losses by doing things I am entitled to do, there's no possible liability - in order to claim damages, I have to have done something wrong. So in the absence of a specific law or contract requiring Amazon to ensure that their "partners" aren't needlessly deprived of revenue, that lost revenue is not Amazon's problem, and they're entitled to (for example) intentionally cause partners to lose that revenue if it benefits Amazon in some way and there's no statute or contract that restricts Amazon from doing so.
- ezoe 7y agoThese concerns should better be handled by other kind of law such as defamation, not the copyright or patent or trademark. The exact definition of defamation varies between jurisdictions so what constitute to be the defamation is another problem though.
- Rapzid 7y ago> no court would ever uphold this removal You mean enforce? Youtube can remove whatever they want; they don't need to be in the right about it.
- tathougies 7y ago> I genuinely wonder if deepfake technology will actually result in new copyright restriction law. I.e. to make it a crime to produce unlicensed deepfakes that are genuinely indistinguishable to the average person, regardless of whether they're parody or not. (While "bad" parodies like SNL will continue to be protected as always.) You don't need new law. It's already against the law to copy someone's appearance in an attempt to impersonate them other than fair use.
- andy_ppp 7y agoI think you’ve misunderstood the point of impersonation laws, they are about stealing someone’s identity, this is not that... anyone watching these videos can see that it is NOT Jay Z in the video.
- chrisco255 7y agoThere's also defamation laws. I'm sure a lawyer could make a good argument for banning a deep fake, or suing for the existence of one if it causes defamation.
- flukus 7y agoThis isn't about impersonation but your copyright over your own likeness that can't be used without consent. Take a game like FIFA or Madden, they have to negotiate with the players (or their unions) in order to create realistic digital counterparts (including the names) and arguably better games often find themselves unable to compete because of this. > anyone watching these videos can see that it is NOT Jay Z in the video. I'm not that familiar with JayZ and it's more than enough that I would have been convinced and not given it a second thought. It's not obviously parody and the only tip off it was even fake was "(speech synthesis)" in the title.
- eythian 7y agoIs it really copyright? Based on what I know of it, it doesn't seem like copyright would apply. Trademark I could sorta see, if they registered their likeness.
- SilasX 7y ago>After all, the end result is no different from a really good vocal impersonator. In fact, a really good impersonator will definitely do better. Really? I thought if it was "so good" that people don't realize it's a parody, it loses the relevant protections against defamation and infringement on likeness rights/image/trademark/whatever.
- xyproto 7y agoIf that were the case, then people could claim that any parody was "too good" to get it removed.
- icebraining 7y agoParody must include a component of criticism or commentary. If it's just imitation, it's not fair use.
- nerdponx 7y agoI wonder if there's any legal grounds in the USA for trademarking the sound of your voice, and thereby protecting it from "counterfeiting".
- sandworm101 7y ago>> as soon as really convincing yet nasty deepfakes of senators and representatives start making the rounds and spreading on Facebook, I suspect a new law will get passed incredibly quickly. No. This isn't a new area of law. Legal "Deepfakes" have been around a long while. There is even a supreme court case covering the matter: Falwell, 1988. That involved a fake interview with Billy Graham, using his image and putting words in his mouth. If the 1988 supreme court wouldn't protect the reputation of a national religious leader, they aren't going to do so for politicians today. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hustler_Magazine_v._Falwell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hustler_Magazine_v._Falwell This is from the movie, but it is accurate to what was said. This interaction really did change supreme court procedure, introducing a far less formal back-and-forth oral argument. Jokes were almost unheard of before this case. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MeTuNES82O0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MeTuNES82O0 The trial court argument: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TsvB61mDoG8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TsvB61mDoG8
- rustybolt 7y agoFrom [1]: > In an 8–0 decision, the Court ruled in favor of Hustler magazine, holding that a parody ad published in the magazine depicting televangelist and political commentator Jerry Falwell Sr. as an incestuous drunk, was protected speech since Falwell was a public figure and the parody could not have been reasonably considered believable. The post you're replying to explicitly talks about convincing deepfakes. Also, Falwell was a televangelist and political commentator, not a senator. So I don't think this court case is a good example. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hustler_Magazine_v._Falwell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hustler_Magazine_v._Falwell
- curiousgal 7y ago> If the 1988 supreme court wouldn't protect the reputation of a national religious leader, they aren't going to do so for politicians today. Well that gave me a good chuckle! The fact that a supreme judge is appointed by the sitting president and confirmed by the Senate means that they can push whatever dogma the ruling party has.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 7y agoI believe the DMCA defacto REQUIRES youtube (and others) to work like this. Once the DMCA take-down comes in, if they leave something up, they become liable if the court case goes against them. So if 1000 takedowns come in, and you correctly leave 999 videos up as fair use etc, you still get demolished on the other 1. Meanwhile the company requesting 999 incorrect takedowns owes you nothing. This is a key problem with DMCA, it shifts all the risk/cost of deciding cases onto platforms, their only logical response is to take things down, so everything gets taken down.
- icebraining 7y agoThe DMCA process also includes a counter-claim provision: the uploader can simply contest the takedown and have the content reinstated. But YouTube doesn't follow the DMCA process at all, they have their own procedure, with no such recourse.
- LatteLazy 7y agoMy understanding is that if a uploader does that, youtube has to decide whether to keep it up. If they do, they can then be sued by the right holder if it does infringe. If they take it down, no one can sue them. So that's a huge incentive to just take everything down. Effectively the whole point of DCMA (this part at least) is to pierce the common carrier protection platforms have. Am I wrong? If so, any idea what Youtube don't just let people counterclaim and leave everyone else to argue it out in court?
- icebraining 7y agoUnder the DMCA (technically Section 512), they have to reinstate access to the content at least 10 days and at most 14 days after receiving the counter-notice, in order to keep the safe-harbor (they have to wait 10 days to give time for the rights holder to decide if they want to sue the uploader). > any idea what Youtube don't just let people counterclaim and leave everyone else to argue it out in court? Essentially YouTube in the pre-Google days was purposefully uploading infringing videos, and Viacom (and others) used that to sue them and under the settlement agreement forced YouTube to build the Content-ID system and have a more lax takedown system.
- DyslexicAtheist 7y agoI don't get it. the videos are still here and I can access them just fine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iyemXtkB-xk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iyemXtkB-xk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m7u-y9oqUSw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m7u-y9oqUSw was this an automatic takedown and maybe they have meanwhile been made available again?
- visarga 7y ago> I.e. to make it a crime to produce unlicensed deepfakes that are genuinely indistinguishable to the average person automatic Turing test pass