35 ms·
With questionable copyright claim, Jay-Z orders deepfake parodies off YouTube
- basch 7y agohttps://www.descript.com/ https://www.descript.com/ and Lyrebird prevent people from making copies of voices that arent their own, but it looks like that cat is out of the bag. Abuse potential notwithstanding, and ignoring the complete distortion of "reality" coming soon, I'm extremely excited for this technology to become more mainstream. Being able to edit audio and video, like you edit a word document. Record a conversation for a couple hours, compile the transcript, and synthesize it into something tight, all without the need for a traditional video editor. Voice synthesis for words that werent spoken, or misspoken, frame interpolation and morphing to prevent the jaggy youtube cutting effect.
- randylahey 7y agoA YouTuber (carykh) made a video where he explains an algorithm he made to automatically process lecture videos by speeding up, condensing and removing parts of the video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQ8orIurGxw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQ8orIurGxw
- AlexAffe 7y agooh. my. god. This is about to change... a lot of things. Stop motion by clapping totally has me.
- MiguelHudnandez 7y agoI was surprised to find carykh's video is over a year old now! This has so many applications, I'm surprised it's not already common.
- sneak 7y agohttps://s.sneak.berlin/@sneak/104054875133518950 https://s.sneak.berlin/@sneak/104054875133518950 I want a YT speed setting for “constant WPM” based on their autocaption timestamp metadata.
- aspenmayer 7y agoThat’s an amazingly obvious idea whose time has come. Who do we @ to get this on YouTube already?
- BrandonM 7y agoOvercast does roughly that for podcasts and it works great.
- aspenmayer 7y agoIs there a similar feature in Google Podcasts? I know that they are transcribing them automatically in the same way captions are generated for YouTube videos. I think it mostly blew over but I remember Google caught some flak for that in the same way they did for Google Books v Authors Guild fiasco. This is why we can’t have nice things.
- three_seagrass 7y agoDon't let your dreams be dreams. YouTube data API allows downloading captions, and the iframe API allows setting playback speed. You could build a site that inputs YouTube video URLs + WPM and then outputs the video playing at the desired WPM.
- egman_ekki 7y ago> https://www.descript.com/ https://www.descript.com/ and Lyrebird prevent people from making copies of voices that arent their own how do they check which voice is your own?
- basch 7y agoIf I understand correctly, you train it live. So unless you knew what script they were going to give you, and had the words prerecorded in order, it would be hard to do. Sort of like a captcha with a timer? I wonder if they also have signatures for famous voices they can blacklist.
- Dramatize 7y agoWe just posted a new post about Lyrebird alternatives now that they've been bought: https://blog.replicastudios.com/lyrebird-alternatives/ https://blog.replicastudios.com/lyrebird-alternatives/
- ex3ndr 7y agoIsn't parodies are explicitly excluded from requiring to hold copyright to an object of a parody?
- acomjean 7y agoIts a little tricky.. Even Weird Al gets the original artist's permission. "(Technically, a parodist does not need permission, but it is a legal gray area, and Weird Al prefers to have every artist in on the joke.)" https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/09/magazine/weird-al-yankovic.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/09/magazine/weird-al-yankovi... edit: the tricky pit is defining parody.
- jshevek 7y ago>Its a little tricky.. Even Weird Al gets the original artist's permission. Weird Al's preferences don't add any strength [evidence] to any argument regarding the legality.
- not2b 7y agoWeird Al is trying to save himself trouble, because going to court can be expensive even when you win. He can legally do parodies without consent, but since so many people are happy to give him permission, that's the easier route for him.
- minimaxir 7y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You%27re_Pitiful https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You%27re_Pitiful > While Blunt himself had no issues with Yankovic recording the parody, Blunt's record label Atlantic did; they forbade Yankovic from commercially releasing the song at the last minute. Yankovic eventually released the song online as a veritable free single; furthermore, in music videos and during live performances, Yankovic has made reference to his dispute with Atlantic. Since the initial debacle in 2006, Yankovic has occasionally reached out to Blunt and his label to see if he can release the song on compilations. However, each time that he has approached Atlantic Records, he has been denied permission.
- acomjean 7y agoBette Midler sued ford back in the day (1988) for hiring an impersonator to sing on an ad and won. (Of course it helped that Ford asked her to sing first) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midler_v._Ford_Motor_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midler_v._Ford_Motor_Co. "The appellate court ruled that the voice of someone famous as a singer is distinctive to their person and image and therefore, as a part of their identity, it is unlawful to imitate their voice without express consent and approval. The appellate court reversed the district courts decision and ruled in favor of Midler, indicating her voice was protected against unauthorized use.[4][5]" I was actually a little surprised. And this is different, but I think that they're imitating a famous voice (as opposed to my voice...) means they become a target. The fact you can fake anyone saying anything is little amazing. though there are people who can do it quite well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josh_Robert_Thompson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josh_Robert_Thompson Thompson's Arnold Schwarzenegger impression first gained national attention during the California gubernatorial recall election of 2003. Posing as Schwarzenegger, Thompson phoned in to Fox News Channel's morning program, Fox & Friends, fooling the hosts into believing (at least for a short while) that he was, in fact, Schwarzenegger.[4]
- css 7y agoVery important to note that the Midler case has very narrow interpretation. From the Opinion: > We need not and do not go so far as to hold that every imitation of a voice to advertise merchandise is actionable. We hold only that when a distinctive voice of a professional singer is widely known and is deliberately imitated in order to sell a product, the sellers have appropriated what is not theirs and have committed a tort in California.
- AlexanderNull 7y agoVideos on YouTube are selling advertisements so wouldn't this apply here?
- jszymborski 7y ago"the sellers have appropriated what is not theirs" IANAL but I think the argument can be made that YT are the sellers here and they are protected by the DMCA
- jedimastert 7y agoFor my own edification, wouldn't trademark law be more applicable?
- noizejoy 7y agoI deleted my own post to that effect, once I saw yours - so I also wonder about that. However I’m not sure if YT has a separate DMCA process for copyright vs. trademark, or if they or people writing about this are just too lazy or uninformed to make the distinction.
- Reelin 7y agoI'm quite puzzled as well. As far as I can tell (not a lawyer) copyright law shouldn't apply at all in this case. According to the article the actual works performed were an excerpt from Hamlet (public domain) and a song by Billy Joel (so someone likely has a valid copyright claim, but probably not Jay-Z). On the other hand, it seems like it might well be an infringement of his likeness (ie a trademark violation). I'm not sure about the nuances surrounding trademark law though - does it have to make money, do intentions matter, how obvious does it need to be that this is an impersonation, etc.
- rhema 7y agoLots of examples of their synthesis here: https://lbry.tv/@VocalSynthesis:2?page=1 https://lbry.tv/@VocalSynthesis:2?page=1 . I've been thinking about the deepfakes as a kind of computational thinking aid. We can all simulate reading text from the voice of random celebrities in our mind's eye. How different is the ability to bring that imagination into reality?
- anon73044 7y agoWhat with Jeff Bridges in Tron and Peter Cushing in Rogue One, I'd suspect in about a decade or so we'll begin seeing Disney movies with an almost full cast of deceased CG actors, complete with their own voice.
- chippy 7y agoSee The Congress: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1821641 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1821641 We should expect living actors to be signing away their likenesses for when they are dead.
- braythwayt 7y agoI feel like I missed something--what about Jeff Bridges in Tron? Or are we talking about Tron:Legacy, and the character of CLU?
- anon73044 7y agoyeah, CLU is what I was referring to
- paypalcust83 7y agoI hope Lawful Masses with Leonard French covers this. I think YT may not have to do it legally, but they may still do it to keep money happy.
- echelon 7y agoAm I going to get sued for having a website that produces arbitrary deepfake audio (Arpabet + Tacotron + Melgan) of Trump and Biden? My opinion is that state actors can already do this. If we train the public that "photoshop for audio and video" is a thing, then they'll learn to be skeptical.
- kauffj 7y agoCEO of LBRY here. These videos are welcome on LBRY. We'll have to get a real (i.e. not me commenting on HN) legal opinion should we get a take down request, but prima facie I don't see why these would be illegal. (If they are illegal and we are notified, we would put them on the company maintained blacklist, as we cannot remove anything from the network itself.) Edit: I wrote a rap on our perspective. If you're having deep fake problems / I feel bad for you son We got 99 deep fakes / And Jay-Z ain't taking down one https://twitter.com/LBRYio/status/1255273319739293703 https://twitter.com/LBRYio/status/1255273319739293703
- areoform 7y agoWhile I appreciate your hustle here, it might not be such a good idea to become the hub for deepfakes and the endless lawsuits they will invite. The deep ethical issues involved should make anyone pause, but taking on record companies and artists should make you pause further. Everyone loves Napster as a history lesson. But it is doubtful that anyone would want to live it. Your position seems to be inviting all of the controversy and lawsuits for little-to-no payoff.
- pc86 7y agoThere are no ethical issues in deepfake videos that weren't existent during the same infantile stages of faked and Photoshopped images on the internet. Some people could pick them out immediately. Some people are fooled even by obvious fakes. That will never change.
- ineedasername 7y ago>There are no ethical issues in deepfake videos that weren't existent during the same infantile stages of faked and Photoshopped images on the internet That is not the same thing as "there are no ethical issues". I'm sure some people, especially the celebrities portrayed, would feel there are the same ethical issues in all cases, and any difference is merely one of degree, not kind.
- 7y ago
- wayneftw 7y agoI went and found them and listened to them out of spite. Thanks for bringing my attention to this Jay-Z!
- jskek9 7y agoHe’s weeping so hard. Oh wait that’s champagne bubbles streaming down his cheeks. “What’s that web chud? Can’t hear your impotent rage over my actually baller life!”
- Animats 7y agoThis was approached all wrong. The first highly publicized demos of singing generated like this should have been of dead people - Michael Jackson, John Lennon, Elvis. First, it's not clear who has the right to sue, and in what jurisdiction. Rights associated with those people have been transferred and resold enough times that there's no clear claimant. Second, many people have impersonated those voices, so there's a strong argument that this is just automating a manual process. Someone could have probably gotten a few tracks out the door and onto airplay before the first litigation. Going up against a living performer whose main asset is their vocal style makes a weaker case. Living people have stronger publicity rights than the estates of dead ones. This could result in a decision which expands the scope of copyright. One of those weird copyright decisions, like the one where Owens-Corning trademarked PINK, as a color, for insulation. Coloring insulation was so unusual that it was held to be a valid trademark. Now there are other copyright on colors. Bad cases make bad law. This thing has been botched so badly that one wonders if it's a fake case from the music industry to get a losing decision.
- OrgNet 7y agodead people's copyrighted work sues for copyright issues all the time... not sure how that would help.
- em-bee 7y agoif you see a new video with elvis presley today, you know it's not really him. the chances of mistaken identiy is low. if the person is still alive then people might believe it's an original and the impersonated can legitimately claim that the fake is profiting from that mistaken identity.
- ineedasername 7y agoMistaken identity doesn't come into play here. It's copyright that got the videos removed, not publicity rights.
- 7y ago
- 00__00 7y agoIf your image if your income, having it defamed via a deep fake or the image rights, aka copyright is only fair. Can't understand why anyone would not back a creator. So many on here are themselves working to create a unique creation that they can live off of.
- ineedasername 7y agoA human impersonator, clearly labelled as such, probably wouldn't have received the same treatment. These videos were simply computer-assisted impersonations.
- rictic 7y agoA difference in quantity can become a difference in kind. Consider a situation down the line where your phone can do this in real time, and at a quality that is hard for the untrained ear to distinguish from the genuine article. It's not at all clear to me what the right thing to do here.
- ineedasername 7y agoMe neither. Companies have been sued when they use impersonators in their ads, but individual impersonators are generally left alone (excepting that they license any songs etc by those they're impersonating) Doing things computationally allows a scale that humans alone can't achieve, and as you said that may make all the difference.
- crazygringo 7y agoSo if I understand this correctly... YouTube took these videos down based on a copyright (DMCA?) claim. Which of course isn't a court ruling or anything. At the same time, no court would ever uphold this removal, because it obviously falls under "parody" which is protected. (Otherwise shows like Saturday Night Live couldn't even exist.) After all, the end result is no different from a really good vocal impersonator. In fact, a really good impersonator will definitely do better. It's disappointing that Jay-Z (or more likely some lawyer working for him) is abusing YouTube's takedown mechanism this way. But at the same time, I can see how this could seem particularly scary for a performer. After all, if you've spent decades creating a recognizable profitable persona... the idea that anybody with a personal computer can flood YouTube with fake lyrics that aren't yours could feel terrifyingly like losing control of everything you've built. What if some really nasty stuff went viral and became as associated with Jay-Z as the rest of his stuff? Stuff that did serious damage to his brand, which "nobody could unhear"? I genuinely wonder if deepfake technology will actually result in new copyright restriction law. I.e. to make it a crime to produce unlicensed deepfakes that are genuinely indistinguishable to the average person, regardless of whether they're parody or not. (While "bad" parodies like SNL will continue to be protected as always.) I kind of feel like that's going to have to be the outcome at some point in the near future -- in fact, as soon as really convincing yet nasty deepfakes of senators and representatives start making the rounds and spreading on Facebook, I suspect a new law will get passed incredibly quickly.
- kupiakos 7y agoI imagine that would likely fall under a new trademark or fraud law rather than copyright.
- blackearl 7y agoIt's a very fuzzy line they'll need to draw. The Onion seems like a good example of parody done really well, to a point that people often "eat the onion" and believe it. Would it be defamation if you published a quote that wasn't actually said by someone? That might be the analog they use to go after deepfakes in the future.
- colordrops 7y ago
- Vaslo 7y agoMaybe this will get the Streisand effect and people will make scores of videos saying all sorts of things, some not so nice...
- erynvorn 7y agoWho is Jay-Z ? Who cares ?
- javanscala 7y agoWouldn't deepfakes have similar legal requirements as the Tupac hologram used at Coachella? http://www.ipbrief.net/2012/04/19/tupac-hologram-rocks-coachella-and-ip-laws/ http://www.ipbrief.net/2012/04/19/tupac-hologram-rocks-coach...
- kentosi 7y agoLooks like the Jay-Z deepfake rap of Shakespear's "To Be, Or Not To Be" is still 5 hours after this link was published on HN: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m7u-y9oqUSw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m7u-y9oqUSw
- coverband 7y agoSorry to dilute the topic but you’ve got to listen to Frank Sinatra singing the “Navy Seals CopyPasta” with this technology. It’s the best thing I’ve come across so far this month: https://youtu.be/8ixYcyslmSI https://youtu.be/8ixYcyslmSI
- Rebelgecko 7y agoThe video of 6 US Presidents performing NWA's "Fuck Tha Police"[1] is also pretty incredible. Some of the older presidents (JFK, Roosevelt, Regan) are a bit rough, presumably due to less training data. But even in FDR/MC-Ren's verse you can hear echoes of his cadence when saying the "only thing we have to fear is fear itself". The Obama and Trump verses also have moments that sound uncannily realistic. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAZVp-n-5TM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAZVp-n-5TM
- russellbeattie 7y agoOne could argue that the audio used to train the deepfakes was the actual infringement, as it is essentially a copy of presumably copyrighted audio, even if not republished in its original form. This would be similar to the Google Books scanning issue. Their original plan was to scan all the books in the world so users could search them. Though Google did provide extended samples in the search results, the core issue was the scanning, which was literally a copy of the books into Google's database without permission. This was considered infringement. [1] Where the original sound comes from and who owns the copyright for that, I don't know. Maybe the person used CNN videos, so Time Warner should be involved as well. 1. https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authors_Guild,_Inc._v._Google,_Inc https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authors_Guild,_Inc._v._Google....
- SubiculumCode 7y agoThis would be a great voice processing effect for musicians. Want that Grunge Kurt Cobain sound to your vocal part? How about a Lennon?
- erdos4d 7y agoSimilar stories and even worse have been happening for years. I'm not sure why this sort of thing registers as news anymore. I'd expect more ink if YouTube actually said no to a copyright claim.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoAs an update, it looks like the videos are back up and the copyright strikes are removed
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI thought Jay-Z had trademarked his image, if so couldn't he keep a deepfake off with an argument that it is a computer generated version of his likeness?
- codefisher 7y agoBut we expect this don't we from YouTube? Just as an example of how broken it is I have been live streaming at our local church, our parish priest decided to sing "Tantum ergo" which was written and set to music at best guess 1264. YouTube flagged it.
- icu 7y agoThe law is going to have to catch up here. Jay-Z has worked very hard to make his 'voice fingerprint' have value. Having listened to the deepfake, it's an extremely accurate copy of Jay-Z's voice. To what degree does Jay-Z's voice constitute a 'work of art' and to what degree does a copy become a forgery? You could say that an impression made by a real person is a 'work of art' but if you remove a real person and use ML, is it still a 'work of art'? We really need to consider the existential questions raised by primitive forms of AI and consider what AGI means from a philosophical perspective before lawyers and judges start defining what can be done with AI in society.
- INTPenis 7y agoNow maybe it's time for society to catch up and provide some sort of digital identification method for citizens. Sort of like keybase but from the government. Because deepfakes should not be under assult for being parody. Instead artists should be able to verify their own works in a secure manner. Some countries have already started with this, mostly in the EU.
- easton_s 7y agoI know its meant a a joke but Jay-z copypasta over a beat is legit cool. https://soundcloud.com/odyssey/jay-z-copypasta/s-JRXSJCBFsPu https://soundcloud.com/odyssey/jay-z-copypasta/s-JRXSJCBFsPu So I get where he's coming from. If I heard this version first I would have thought it was actually Jay-Z. The naked recording has all artifices of AI generated voice but mixed into a composition they are gone to my ear. And also there are a few moments that are surreal. A dragged out s at the end of a phrase. Change of flow from smooth to a fast staccato. Fucking the inflection was near perfect. There is something to this AI stuff.
- gohbgl 7y agoCopyright is brain damage https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XO9FKQAxWZc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XO9FKQAxWZc
- sametmax 7y agoWe really need a law that forces people to label fakes when they willingly produce ones that are hard to tell from the real thing, and harshly punish the ones that omit the label. It's ok to fake stuff, but it should be clear that you are doing so. We already have fake cars in advertising, fake food on menus, fake news, fake expert advices... I really don't want to add perfect impersonification to the list.
- ec109685 7y agoUpdate to the article: “I just heard from Vocal Synthesis’s creator that the copyright strike was removed, and both videos are back on his channel. He’s not sure if YouTube reversed its decision or Roc Nation removed the claim, but I suspect the latter.”
- kpennell 7y agoDoes anyone have a mirror for these? They were super funny