14 ms·
Inside of a Tractor Cab [video]
- jedberg 7y agoIt's fascinating how many different screens there are for all the different add ons. I also like the part where she says, "Dad can sit in the office and monitor my planting from there". Now even the hard working farmer is working in an office!
- holler 7y agovery cool! my first thought was that it looks way more complicated than a simple joystick/steering control.
- whalesalad 7y agoThey drive themselves. Tractors have been using autonomous guidance systems for a long time.
- jedberg 7y agoYeah the autonomous driving was the least interesting part to me. It was everything else that was running semi-autonomously that I found fascinating, and the fact that they aren't integrated. That every piece of equipment has it's own screen.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bluGill 7y agoNot everything has its own screen. The isobus standard has allowed one screen for years. It is easier to create your own screen than to use it. Also there is a lot to watch and so you sometimes want your own screen anyway just to ensure the important stuff is always in eyesight.
- DarmokJalad1701 7y ago> autonomous guidance systems They can do simple stuff like steering in a straight line at a constant speed or offset from a previously driven path. They still require a driver in the seat and more complicated operations like for example: unloading into a grain cart from a combine still has to be done by the driver. There is work being done in this area though.
- randomdata 7y ago> unloading into a grain cart from a combine still has to be done by the driver. Systems to have the combine take control of the tractor while unloading into the grain cart have been commercially available for a number of years now.
- masklinn 7y agoIt looks like older videos were removed from the channel but when this first made the rounds (on twitter) a few days back there was a video of filling some reservoirs, and on the video there was a man on crutches. I assumed that'd be the father and why he's not operating machinery.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoFor a while now I've shifted my perception of farming; it's more administration and management now than anything else. I mean for crop seeding and harvesting a lot of farmers will hire a company to do it, instead of purchasing combines that are stationary for most of the year.
- asdkjh345fd 7y agoFarmers haven't been hard working in decades. There's a reason most farmers are obese, sitting isn't hard work. Even when I was a kid everyone around here still did square bales of hay and tossed them around by hand. Now it is 100% round bales handled with a loader. As everything got bigger, there was simply no possibility of human involvement because people can't lift 800 pounds.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jonwinstanley 7y agoLooks like a pretty bad user experience. I understand why you'd want that many screens, so all the data is visible, but they all look like they are built by different companies and with different types of screens and different styles of interface. Surely it must be hard to use?
- searine 7y agoThe idea is modularity. This is just for seed planting, but you can swap out screens for different tools attached to the back. Also a lot of the screens can be attached to different machines, and or carried mobile which is useful.
- throwaway894345 7y agoIronically John Deere's experience was much better than many competitors, or at least it was for a very long time. Some competitors' cabs looked like the cockpit of a soviet era fighter jet, with everything controlled by a huge array of toggle switches.
- nas 7y agoThe user experience is a lot better than it was a few years ago but you are correct, it's a lot of screens. There are two screens for the tractor itself. The lower screen above throttle, displays and controls tractor related stuff. The screen above does GPS guidance and mapping (automatic steering). There is a screen from the planter tool. That does mapping as well and probably does seed (population) rate control. The small blue screen I think is for the fertilizer controller (separate system and manufacturer again). I guess the screen all the way to the right is also for the planting tool. Maybe monitors the tanks that store the seed and other planter properties. I'm not familiar with the planter she is using. They have integrated some things over the past few years (ISOBUS is the standard communication protocol for integrating). There is a lot more integration that could be done but it requires a lot of cooperation between companies. Also, the tractor is a multi-purpose tool and in this case is being used for a very specific job. So, many of the screens apply only for the job she is doing.
- HeyLaughingBoy 7y agoThis is the same situation in any number of industries where you can "mix & match" equipment. Even different products from the same company might have radically different UIs. Like anything else, it's not ideal, but you get used to it. In my previous job, the same thing happened. In fact, one of our selling points was that we had a unified look and feel for all our equipment UI's. It made it easier for salespeople to demonstrate how buying our stuff could reduce training cost and error rates.
- searine 7y agoIf you want a more indepth explanation of what is happening in the cab and in the seed planter, check out Dodge Brothers Farm on youtube. He does a really great job of going through the details. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OjVZoniN2no https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OjVZoniN2no - how a modern corn planter works https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxMcl7ktEP0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KxMcl7ktEP0 - inside the cab of the tractor for a planter
- exabrial 7y agoHe is flying across that field
- nas 7y agoI'm guessing that video is taken in the US since she is planting corn. Here is another video from Southern Saskatchewan. People might be interested in the equipment being used. Mike is quite an character. He works on a big operation, I think over 20k acres. The equipment he is using costs a fair bit of cash. The seeding system (para-link hoe drill) and tractor to pull it likely costs between 500k and 1m CAD. They have multiple units like that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uM5ZBNzvKz4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uM5ZBNzvKz4 The video doesn't show too much of it but Mike's equipment a bunch of technology on it as well. Some of the stuff: - auto section control: turns off/on seed & fertilizer automatically to minimize overlaps and prevent skips. On large machines (e.g. 80 ft) the cost of overlap is quite significant. The seed and fertilizer is carried by a pneumatic system and optimally tuning the system is a bit tricky (he shows a bit of that) - auto rate control/variable rate control: with variable rate, the field is split into many zones and the applied rate of seed and fertilizer is optimized. That's a whole topic into itself, I won't explain here. - population/blockage monitoring: this system monitors seed and fertilizer flow in the pneumatic delivery system and will alert the operator is something is wrong (blocked run, rate to high or low). That's the "Agtron" system he is talking about. - I don't know if his para-link drill has it but there is a variable packing system available. That will monitor packer (the wheel behind the seed opener) and adjust packing pressure depending on field conditions. Wet areas of the field will need less down pressure compared to dry areas - As is typical these days, GPS mapping, guidance. He has two different screens showing the map. The Deere screen doesn't show the individual on/off sections of the drill and so it shows more overlap. The Topcon screen (comes with drill) shows the sections. - The system for controlling the metering on the drill is fairly advanced. For planters, it is typically more advanced yet (corn seed is really expensive and so very precisely metering it and placing it is key). On the Bourgault drill he is using, there is a variable speed hydraulic motor on the metering system with a feedback control loop to control the rate. Early in the video he is calibrating those meters so the system knows the mass-flow feedrate of the meter (e.g. RPM of meter -> lbs/min of material). That feedrate will be converted to a per-unit-area application rate. The variable rate prescription map will provide input to the rate controller. Just some info in case people are interested. Running a profitable farm is a challenge and most farmers are aggressive in adopting any new technology that will help them get an edge.
- throwaway894345 7y agoHey, I worked on the touchscreen at the end of the armrest. Internally at John Deere it was called GSix (6th generation). Built with Qt, WindRiver Linux, ran on a custom board (that 1"+ thick display is _just_ the monitor), resistive touch screen, speaks CAN/j1939/etc. One of the things it talked to was a buggy Bosch radio over a home-grown protocol that didn't actually expose the radio's state, so the display was forced to make educated guesses. This was a huge pain, especially WRT bluetooth pairing (at one point we had an error screen that told the user to just power cycle the radio because the display has already tried everything we could think of to get the radio back into a good state). The contractors for whom I originally took over apparently had a contract to write unit tests, probably for a certain amount of test coverage or something. There was a bunch of dead code buried that was only executed by the tests, apparently to bump up their unit test coverage. This was one of many such horrors. We ultimately told management that it was cheaper to rewrite the thing than it was to fix their backlog of "must have" bugfixes, and it was a huge success. Still didn't fix the radio issues, however.
- whylie 7y agoThanks for your personal story - I love reading stuff like this.
- EvanAnderson 7y agoI've done a few projects interfacing embedded devices, and the "I must guess at the device's state because the manufacturer didn't think communicating that was important" scenario fills me with sadness and rage. I'd love to slap around every developer who thought that making such a device was a good idea.
- Gibbon1 7y agoThat's a problem with abstraction layers and hiding state, observability goes into the toilet. Interesting thing I learned about designing production test equipment. If you show the operator all the nasty state information they quickly learn to associate trashy diagnostic output with corrective action. That janky message means, run it again, it'll pass. This other one means that row of pogo pins needs to be replaced.
- TYPE_FASTER 7y agoLogitech has controllers: https://www.logitechg.com/en-us/products/farm.html https://www.logitechg.com/en-us/products/farm.html https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vx3A-zDRTFQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vx3A-zDRTFQ
- masklinn 7y agoWeirdly that's significantly less technologically advanced than the video's control. It's just a bunch of switches and buttons. Though I wonder how programmable it is, could be a pretty cool automation control panel.
- JoBrad 7y agoThere’s a pretty significant difference in price, though.
- EvanAnderson 7y agoThose controllers look like so much fun! They're not hatefully expensive either. It looks like they're probably USB HID, too.
- jfim 7y agoThat controller looks like it would be a lot of fun with Kerbal Space Program.
- dchuk 7y agoAt first I thought this was a Tractor Cab in the sense of a Tractor Trailer and I got excited... But, still similar enough. I run product for a Telematics Platform company that sells into the large enterprise fleets. Have spent a lot of time in cabs of trucks learning about what driver's need and trying to "feel the pains" of being a commercial driver. It's a rough and tough environment, though the new vehicles are pretty damn nice. Building software systems for things that move and can't really afford any downtime is a great set of challenges that I never would have expected to enjoy. Much less trying to shift paradigms in a legacy-laden industry away from "boxes of software" to a true development platform.
- fit2rule 7y agoI've worked on software projects for safety environments - SIL-4 - as well as telematics, and I share your pain. But it's always amusing how far telematics folks will go to avoid certification for SIL-4. The whole telematics industry should just bite the bullet and catch up with, for example, the decades of experience the rail transportation guys have in making all those pieces fit.
- dsalzman 7y agoPeople in Ag love to say that they “built the first self driving vehicles”. The auto steers were cutting edge and have been around since the 80s. Those cabs are also air conditioned and usually have a nice comfy leather seat. Once it’s all dialed in it’s monitoring the screens and browsing HN. A lot of you could be farmers!! /s
- jackfoxy 7y agoWorked my way through college in Ag during 70's and early 80's, before self driving anything. I can tell you from experience it's easy to be lulled into a sense of complacency by the boredom. I'm sure the human is still there because things can go wrong in a hurry, and when they do go wrong with a piece of equipment that powerful they go wrong in a big way.
- vvanders 7y agoYeah, complacency and heavy machinery are a really bad combination. Even a smaller CUT can do an incredible amount of damage in a short period of time.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoHow did they solve this for the aviation industry? IIRC they've had autopilot for decades as well. The aviation industry seems (appearances anyway) a lot more diligent and disciplined for things like that, I mean for one they have at least two pilots to monitor things.
- red_admiral 7y agoConsidering what happened to AF447, "solved" is perhaps not 100% accurate.
- tonyarkles 7y agoHah, yup, one minute everything's fine and the next minute your combine is jammed, a belt starts slipping, and then it all catches fire. At least some of this fancy automation stuff helps catch problems like that before they get out of hand; now you just need a John Deere licensed technician to make a service call and reset the fault lockout...
- rexreed 7y agoAgtech is high tech now, especially for the large agribusiness. Without this tech I would think it would be difficult to feed as many people as we do. Does this mean there needs to be more tech hiring in agribusiness?
- shawn-butler 7y agoThat ship has already sailed. Also no one on the farm can repair any of this anymore.
- abyssin 7y agoWhat I see here is a machine that replaces human work with petrol. We could definitely feed people without these machines, but there might be less meat in their plate, and more workers needed to produce the food.
- asdkjh345fd 7y agoIt would just shift more to healthier meat like beef instead of so much chicken. Beef production requires no large tractors, seeders, harvesters, etc. You are just letting cows eat grass. Chicken production is basically an extra step in corn production, so it needs all the equipment involved in corn production.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoIt wouldn't be more difficult to be honest; you can do the exact same work with low-tech tractors and mechanical implements, you'd just need to hire more workers. And honestly, the US is not lacking in workers at the minute. But the problem the US has is that they just don't want to pay people a living wage or give them any guarantees. You know a farmer or machine operator in agriculture will have a full lifetime of work ahead of them. But in general, US employer culture does not want to commit to anything, they want to be able to fire a tenth of the workforce if there's a pandemic without any consequences. err. Ranting but I hope you see my point. Automation isn't necessary to maintain production, it's a means to do the same job with less people.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- WangComputers 7y ago"I could teach anybody, even people in this room, to be a farmer. It's a process. You dig a hole, you put a seed in, you put dirt on top, add water, up comes the corn." -Mike Bloomberg
- bluGill 7y agoAt the end of the year you get a gross profit of $0.016. From there you have to buy your seed ($0.04 each at your local hardware store), shovel, watering can... Those numbers are only semi realistic. Your local hardware store probably only has sweet corn seed (what I priced) which will not yield as much as field corn, but it is worth more if you sell as sweet corn not field corn as most farmers are selling corn. I have no idea how to account for this important factor. Mike Bloomberg hasn't heard of fertilizer, so I didn't bother pricing that, but to get the yield I quoted every year you need to replace what the corn takes out of the soil and that means fertilizer of some sort.
- londons_explore 7y agoIt still surprises me that modern agriculture doesn't seem to track each individual plant. Surely in todays world, it's very cheap to simply have a bunch of cameras looking down at the plants, and track from each seed, to each plant, to each leaf on the plants, to how many cents that plant earned you. When you have that kind of tracking, you can do things like "If a plant is within 30mm of a neighbour, we will earn more if we kill one plant and let the other grow. Kill whichever is currently smaller". Or "if a plant is growing within 2 inches of a rock, give it these extra nutrients". Treating each plant separately should give much higher yields. Our current system is equivalent to a human medical system which doesn't inspect each patient individually, but instead just prescribes medications to entire towns!
- ssully 7y agoI am pretty sure modern agriculture does a lot of this based on keeping track of everything (what's planted, how much fertilizer, weather, soil conditions, etc). I am not sure the last time you have been on a farm, but setting up a system of static cameras to constantly monitor every individual plant would be very expensive and I am doubtful that it would be any better then what is being done now.
- troutwine 7y agoAbsolutely. I really, really wonder how you'd manage to get equipment in under the camera rig. All those cameras are going to look pretty tempting for the folks that normally just steal diesel, not to mention pretty silly flying around in bad weather.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoDrone flying? With 20 acres need to fly back and charge ... and some ai software.
- kube-system 7y agoFarmers are already monitoring their crops by sensors in their equipment, in the fields, in drones, and by satellite. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precision_agriculture https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precision_agriculture
- rmason 7y agoTo give you some perspective when I left the fertilizer business here in Central Michigan in 1999 the only monitor in most tractor cabs was the seed monitor. In combines maybe 2-3% of farmers had a yield monitor, probably 2-3X that in places like Illinois or Iowa. I love it how people say farmers don't use technology!
- JamesCoyne 7y agoAm I reading this correctly? A five day old account has a video rocketing past 100k views already?
- piercebot 7y agoLaura (https://twitter.com/carlsonlaura64 https://twitter.com/carlsonlaura64) hosted the "Ag of the World" twitter account (27k followers; https://twitter.com/AGofTheWorld https://twitter.com/AGofTheWorld) for the past week, and there was a lot of demand on Twitter for her to upload her videos to YouTube. So you could say that the market was already primed to receive the product :)
- maxerickson 7y agoMany more on Twitter: https://twitter.com/AGofTheWorld/status/1252965311269273602 https://twitter.com/AGofTheWorld/status/1252965311269273602
- RandallBrown 7y agoThis video made it to the front page of Reddit yesterday.
- callesgg 7y agoShe is a cute girl talking about novel shit (as seen from the majority YouTube audience ) I think it is quite explainable.
- bob33212 7y agoMore importantly she is doing real work. She isn't promoting a brand or developing a line of clothes. If COVID has done anything good it has reminded us what matters. Who cares if you have 10 million followers, if all you "do" is promote brands. At least this lady is making food while getting followers because of her looks.
- globular-toast 7y agoIt's an easy life if you're attractive.
- pj_mukh 7y agoQuestion from not-a-farmer. Is this all corn and/or wheat? What does such tech look like for non-corn/non-wheat related crops?
- ojame 7y agoIt looks relatively the same, can be similar (or more, or less) amount of screens. It all depends on what what model the tractor is (some only need one screen for control) and what attachments you have on. Some attachments have one or two screens, some have none. Even if you're in livestock, you have a screen for the tractor, likely screen for GPS guidance too. Perhaps a screen for stock management across fields etc.
- tonyarkles 7y agoShe has another video with soybeans and it's a pretty similar process. She said they adjusted a couple of things but were using the same tractor and seeder.
- abledon 7y agolink for her soybean planting video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PpJ2Xe_cyeU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PpJ2Xe_cyeU
- nas 7y agoShe is using a "planter". That is a quite expensive and complicated machine. It's used for crops that have expensive seeds or very precise planting requirements. Corn seed is expensive and a significant cost of growing the crop. So, you want to make the best use of the seed. A planter will meter out seeds one at a time and place them a fixed distance apart in the seed rows. Seed depth is also carefully controlled. Corn will yield better if plants are optimally spaced in the row. Less sophisticated seeding equipment (e.g. air drill, air seeder) will randomly space out seeds in the row. For lower cost seeds like wheat, that's typically good enough and it is a simpler machine. Another difference is that planters typically have wider row spacings. For corn, that's not a problem because the plants want more space. However, for cereal crops like wheat, ideally the spacing should be smaller. Typically spacing for wheat might be 8 to 10 inches but even narrower might give optimal yield. To get narrow spacing, you need more seed rows and those get expensive given the complexity of the planter system (high cost per seed row). In area she is farming, corn and soybeans are the major crops. There are a bunch of other field crops they might grow. Wheat is one but there are many others. Example planter manufacturer (lots of other companies make them): https://www.monosem.com/Products/Planter/Monoshox-NG-Plus-M https://www.monosem.com/Products/Planter/Monoshox-NG-Plus-M
- glaberficken 7y agoMy 9yo daughter just came up behind me and asked: "What are you watching? Is that lady 'driving' an airplane?"
- jedberg 7y agoMy five year old walked up and said "hello!" and waved because she assumed I was in a Zoom meeting with the woman in the video.
- glaberficken 7y agoHaha! brilliant =)
- hirundo 7y agoClassified Ad Real Soon Now: Farmers wanted, remote ok. We are approaching the point at which people who like to play farming simulators can be charged a fee for the privilege of actually farming. Using the same app. Even Tom Sawyer didn't dare to charge Ben Rogers to whitewash Aunt Polly's fence.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoI think a lot of people wouldn't mind a remote operator job, but it would have to be safe - in the case of tractor driving, you need to look out for other people and nature itself. Over here in the Netherlands anyway, in the US it seems like fields are a lot bigger and more mechanized. But yeah, what do you do if you have a breakdown or an issue in the machine (like a rock stuck somewhere) that needs fixing? I guess if you look at US large-scale operations (five combines next to one another) you could have one maintenance guy / foreman with five remote operators? I do think we'll see more of that. I mean there's the jobs depicted on TV (so I don't know if this is actually a thing) of people looking at security cameras, that can be done from home I think. Plenty of FNAF fans that have done that for ages. But it has to be secure. I mean another remote operator job I can think of is in factories and power plants, but that's really not something you want to be doable over the internet. Even without internet, stuxnet (?) proved you can cause damage in that kind of systems.
- bluGill 7y agoUS large scale is not large in general. Ukraine (or maybe Kazakhstan) are much bigger (the old collective farms from the soviet union, the collective broke up but not the farm). Brazil and Australia both tend to much larger farms than the US as well (but not on the scale of Ukraine). It will be interesting to see what happens in Africa - there are signs that continent is modernizing. Of course if you are in western Europe US farms are big, but there is more to the world than Europe and the US.
- hoseja 7y agoDifference is in game you're not actually responsible for a very expensive piece of hardware.
- JetBen 7y agoWomen shouldn't be driving tractors. Forget texting while driving. Forget using instagram. She's going the whole "I'm a millennial, look at me on youtube!" angle. It's reckless and dangerous, and she should have her license revoked.
- bigpoppa 7y agohot
- pragmatic 7y agoVery different from the last time I operated a planter. I wonder how much the tech cost in the tractor cab, let alone the tractor and planter.
- jcrawfordor 7y agoSeems like a big opportunity for improved operator ergonomics would be some kind of open standard bus used for simple commanding - could be either electrical or software. This way, a set of "soft buttons" could be provided on the wheel or front panel which can be mapped to actions on accessory equipment, so that e.g. starting and stopping the seeder (and perhaps seeing its OK/NG status) could be done without having to reach around to its own controller. This would be fairly simple to implement using a commodity serial bus if everyone could get together and agree on something, but I don't know if agricultural implements have enough of a vendor lock-in paradigm that e.g. the tractor manufacturer would be discouraged from building features to support third-party implements.
- randomdata 7y agoWhat you describe sounds pretty much exactly like ISOBUS.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoinsert xkcd about adding another standard here. I mean I agree, but it'd require a lot of backwards compatibility and a push to get rid of existing standards, which can take decades. I mean we don't even have a unified cable standard around computers / laptops yet. Ideally I'd be able to buy a new PC with only USB-C ports in it, but we're nowhere near that.
- bluGill 7y agoThere is a problem safety. I work for John deere. We have some products that are not being developed because if they were some remote hacker could open the vavles on the anmoina tanks as the farmer is driving by a school and kill all 60 children out at recess. There are real dangers here, and things are going to get more locked down in the protocol over time to ensure that those scenarios don't happen. The above is not about third parties. If we conclude we can trust you we will even give you a key to our cryptography. However trust will not be easy to establish.
- rocauc 7y agoThe first self-driving tractors were used in research environments in 1996(!) [1] Automatic steering of farm vehicles using GPS. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.2134/1996.precisionagproc3.c91 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.2134/1996.precisi... [2] First results in vision-based crop line tracking https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/503895 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/503895
- arijun 7y agoIt seems the job of driving a tractor involves everything but the one thing I would have guessed, actually driving it!
- paypalcust83 7y agoAlso, Millennial Farmer has similar videos. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCp0rRUsMDlJ1meYAQ6_37Dw https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCp0rRUsMDlJ1meYAQ6_37Dw
- Jemm 7y agoWelker farms has some good videos about the tech of farming.
- blendo 7y agoSoybeans, I think (from the same channel): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PpJ2Xe_cyeU https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PpJ2Xe_cyeU So likely growing for animal food. Or possibly the field is corn, for either animal food or ethanol. Growing human food can be somewhat less complicated (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a_7TRko1VwQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a_7TRko1VwQ), but can also be backbreaking (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=O1aHpSu7F4o https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=O1aHpSu7F4o)