9 ms·
Extremely Large Telescope
- dang 7y agoRelated from 2015: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9185815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9185815 2012: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4096294 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4096294
- nabla9 7y agoESO had plans for Overwhelmingly Large Telescope (OWL) but they did not get enough funding so they had to settle for ELT.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI wonder how the successor to the OWL would be named. “Insanely large telescope”?
- srl 7y agoJust to avoid ambiguity, the parent comment is not a joke: see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overwhelmingly_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overwhelmingly_Large_Telescope.
- pantalaimon 7y agohttps://xkcd.com/1294/ https://xkcd.com/1294/
- dylan604 7y agoI was expecting something along the lines of The Final Telescope v2 or The New Final Telescope v2.03
- superkuh 7y agoThis is a joke though: "The reinstatement of funding to the Overwhelmingly Large Telescope Project" (april 1st) https://arxiv.org/abs/1204.0526 https://arxiv.org/abs/1204.0526
- j-james 7y agoThis astronomical naming scheme doesn't seem to be limited to telescopes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_Large_Array https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_Large_Array
- torpfactory 7y agohttps://xkcd.com/1294/ https://xkcd.com/1294/
- martythemaniak 7y agoThe Hubble has a launch mass of 10000kg and has a mirror with a 2.4m diameter and 4.525 m^2 collecting area. The ELT has a diameter of 39.3m area of 978 m^2, that is 216 Hubbles. The target cost of getting stuff to LEO using Starship/SuperHeavy is $2m per 100000kg, or $200k per Hubble. It would only cost $43 million to launch the light-gathering equivalent to the ELT. Now, $20/kg to LEO is very optimistic, but even at 5-10x that rate, a more believable $100-200/kg, that would still make the launch possible for 200-400m, which is roughly the cost of a Delta Heavy launch. Scaling this up, a 100m telescope (The OWL) would be 1,735.69 Hubbles and cost $350m to launch at the optimistic price, but still less than $3.5B at the believable price. Basically, if Starship is successful it could have a dramatic effect on astronomy. 216 Hubbles may sound a bit insane, but mass producing them would drive the cost for each down considerably. Without the atmosphere, you don't need the fancy laser-actuator correction mechanism, and you certainly don't need to fight local activists for one of very few locations worldwide where you can plausibly put these things (AFAIK, there are only 3 such locations worldwide - Canary Islands, Cerro Amazones and Hawaii). Not only that, but if you had a constellation of Hubbles, they could be spread out and use interferometry to construct a telescope larger than the Earth (this is the technique that Event Horizon Telescope used). So the question is, is it possible to design a standardized, flatpack hubble-sized mirror+cam sattelite and pull it off for the price of a regular telescope? At ~1.2Eur for the ELT, that would imply $45m per "hubble". Seems doable.
- __tg__ 7y agoNot sure about the Starship numbers but if its is $2m per Hubble mass, then launching 200 hubbles would be $800m, not $43m. This however is not about sending bricks into orbit. The ELT mirrors are segmented and need precise alignment with each other to micron precision. Deploying a segmented mirror in orbit has still not been done (the James Webb Telescope launches in 2021); the engineering involved adds orders of magnitudes of complexity over a single-piece primary mirror such as Hubble has. Add to this maintenance costs: a mirror the size of ELT in orbit needs a huge maintenance program behind it to work at all. The lifetime cost for such a mirror would be in tens of billions, if not hundreds. This is why such large telescopes keep getting built on Earth.
- bouvin 7y agoThe excellent Omega Tau science podcast recently did an in-depth episode on the not inconsiderable complications of the ELT’s five mirror lightpath and its control: http://omegataupodcast.net/150-5-controlling-the-elt/ http://omegataupodcast.net/150-5-controlling-the-elt/
- SeanFerree 7y agoVery nice!!
- tigershark 7y agoI wonder why they decided to make it so dark... f/17.48 is really really dark. Actually reading Wikipedia numbers it seems even darker at f/18.91. The focal length is impressive at 3/4 km, so probably they wanted to privilege the angular resolution going toward the diffraction limit.
- adamtj 7y agoHow close will this be to being able to resolve starspots on something other than our sun?
- tigershark 7y agoI didn’t run the numbers but I would say very very far.
- bawana 7y agoWhy bother with Leo? Jus build one on the moon (along w a moon base) The interferometry would be awesome when coordinated w a telescope in the atacama. And no worries about maintaining a spacecraft, no shuttle missions, no astronaut exposure to radiation. Compare the rate limiting factors of working on the ISS versus doing the same thing in the Atacama. Having a safe, protected environment with gravity allows a much more human friendly working situation. Space is for transiting, not living in. We need to be on planets.
- BurningFrog 7y ago"Just build a moon base" might be overly optimistic :)
- rbanffy 7y agoTo say nothing about radiation shielding on the Lunar surface.
- nordsieck 7y ago> To say nothing about radiation shielding on the Lunar surface. Compared to space, radiation shielding on the moon is trivial - humans belong underground except for short stints on the surface.
- gameshot911 7y agoSpeaking of a moon telescope....[1] [1] https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2020_Phase_I_Phase_II/lunar_crater_radio_telescope/ https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2020_Phase_...
- blackrock 7y agoI would think, that we would first need to land on the moon again.
- bawana 7y agoWe should take turns. US, China, Japan, Russia, India, EU, even North Korea. Did I leave anyone out who has launch capability? How about those nations who dont have launch capability- They can buy a seat on SpaceX, BlueOrigin, or Virgin Space (or whatever that guy's company is called). And I'm sure there are a few private companies I've forgotten. I bet those astronauts who make it through training, make the journey, and survive the rigors of life on the moon will have a lot of camraderie, respect for each other and human decency. Why? Because evil is not tolerated in an environment where your actions can lead to the loss of your nation's citizens and its investment as well. When you have skin in a game where everyone is watching, you play fair. or else.
- rbanffy 7y agoEvery article like this should have a simulated photo of a small object in the solar system compared to other telescopes.
- autokad 7y agopersonally, hearing this makes me happy, can't wait till it's built. Has anyone heard of terrascopes? (telescopes using celestial bodies) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgOTZe07eHA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgOTZe07eHA if it is workable, it sounds fantastical but probably not something I'd see in my lifetime either way
- google234123 7y agoIt seems to me that the ESA is getting better value for money than NASA. They seem to have more projects completed or on the way than NASA. Is it just the fact that NASA is focused on a maned space missions that takes away from more general science projects?
- fsh 7y agoThe ELT is built by the ESO (European Southern Observatory), not ESA.
- blackrock 7y agoInstead of building it on the ground, testing it, then launching it, where you are limited by maximum payload size. I wonder if it is now easier to launch the raw components, and manufacture it in space. There are some engineering challenges of course, but it might be a worthy industrial exercise.
- peter_d_sherman 7y ago"It will be able to correct for image distortions caused by the turbulence in the Earth atmosphere, providing diffraction-limited images that are 16 times sharper than those from the Hubble Space Telescope." I would love to learn about this technology, in depth, because my own knowledge in this area is close to zero. Can anyone point me to any web pages, books, articles, courses, explainer videos, anything in this field... Also, what is the correct terminology around this subject area? This technology seems to exist at some confluence of the science of optics and the computer discipline of image correction... but maybe there's a better name, a better set of terminology for it... well, any and all comments about this area would be welcome!