9 ms·
People forget that there is no law which can put everyone under house arrest. This is all done voluntarily. Why is it ok for people to shop at Walmart and not
by walterbell 7y ago
People forget that there is no law which can put everyone under house arrest. This is all done voluntarily.
Why is it ok for people to shop at Walmart and not at their local small business that sells the same goods and is better equipped to enforce social distancing, with customers explicitly opting in to visit the smaller store?
If a small business can protect workers and customers, and a comparable large business is already open, the small business can consider opening and preparing to litigate all the way to the Supreme Court. With video cameras ready.
There may be a few hundred bored lawyers who remember the US constitution and would take their case pro bono. The federal government recently said it is willing to join lawsuits against states, on constitutional grounds.
Obviously, the business in question should be carefully chosen to maximize health, legal and business outcomes. But with many businesses shutdown, there's a large pool of candidates to be triaged.
- nradov 7y agoIf nothing else, at least we'll come out of this pandemic with some clear Supreme Court decisions to clarify what emergency powers state and local governments actually have. One nuance that people seem to miss is that timing matters. So a very short restriction on Constitutional rights may be acceptable, but the court places increasing scrutiny on those restrictions the longer they remain in place.
- walterbell 7y agoFrom https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/494892-barr-tells-prosecutors-to-watch-for-pandemic-restrictions-that https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/494892-barr-tell... > Attorney General William Barr on Monday directed federal prosecutors to “be on the lookout” for public health measures put in place amid the coronavirus pandemic that might be running afoul of constitutional rights. In a two-page memorandum to the 93 U.S. attorneys, Barr cautioned that some state and local directives could be infringing on protected religious, speech and economic rights. “If a state or local ordinance crosses the line from an appropriate exercise of authority to stop the spread of COVID-19 into an overbearing infringement of constitutional and statutory protections, the Department of Justice may have an obligation to address that overreach in federal court,” Barr wrote.
- rootusrootus 7y agoI'd love to believe that comes from a genuine appreciation of civil liberties and not from an election-year attempt to pander to the current executive's voting base.
- walterbell 7y agoOr that lockdowns are free of political calculus.
- rootusrootus 7y agoThere is already overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
- bobthepanda 7y agoI'm not aware of any lockdowns which are specifically targeted at small retailers while competing large retailers are allowed to be open. Where I am the small coffee shops are closed for walk-in business, but so are the Starbucks; the difference is that small coffee shops are not able to pivot to a centralized delivery platform en masse the way Starbucks is.
- oppositelock 7y agoI can speak to a few examples specifically. It's planting season now, and high business for nurseries. In Santa Clara County, they're closed by fiat. Lowe's, Home Depot, ACE hardware sell essential things (plumbing supplies, etc), so they get to remain open, in-store nurseries and all. So, if I want tomatoes, I have to brave the crowds at Lowe's instead of hopping out to my local nursery which is rarely densely populated even in good times.
- brucer 7y agoI believe nurseries are open again: https://summerwindsnursery.com/ca/promotions/curbside-pickup-delivery https://summerwindsnursery.com/ca/promotions/curbside-pickup...
- gwittel 7y agoSummerwinds got closed and has to do home delivery only per the site. After an outcry Yamagami's re-opened for customers with limited hours (rate limiting, etc) this past weekend. Not sure if Summerwinds is going to get the same reprieve. Neither is setup for online orders though. Summerwinds has a limited set of things online so you have to call. From what I've heard its very hard to get through on the phone because they're overwhelmed. I wish I could just e-mail a list and wait a week; but they're not doing that either.
- walterbell 7y agoOutcry from taxpayers to city officials or store management? Was that done by calling or emailing?
- Skunkleton 7y agoAlmost none of what you said is true. This is not voluntary, there are laws which give these powers, essential businesses can stay open regardless of their size, recording breaking the law while conducting non essential business won’t help you in the supreme court, the federal government is saying lots and doing very little.
- abfan1127 7y agoI read somewhere about a store who didn't sell "essential items", but they tried to begin selling those items and the local police prevented him from pivoting. iirc it was a small AZ town.
- Skunkleton 7y agoSo you maybe read about a small town in Arizona? Ok, well I buy my water refills from a small store in the Bay Area that isn’t closed down. Do our anecdotes cancel out?
- cabaalis 7y ago> there are laws which give these powers IANAL, but I know some of you are so I'm asking here. I've read that challenges to these orders will not succeed because of emergency declarations. The emergency declarations are supposedly backed by some law, correct? Don't we have a document in the national archives that guarantees things like peaceable assembly and not prohibiting exercise of religion? Yet we have people being arrested or cited for assembling, and pastors being put under arrest for holding church? Is it the temporary nature that allows this to be done? Regarding the law that allows this kind of stuff, how does that compare to a constitution which says "congress shall make no law ..."?
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoState's usually have laws to the tune of "if X happens then the emergency is extra super legit and the governor's orders carry the force of law" where X may or may not include a legislature vote and these laws have been exercised sparingly and in good enough taste (i.e. in actual emergencies) that they haven't been challenged much so they live in the same constitutional gray area that many obvious affronts to the text of the constitution live in.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- op00to 7y agoUh, there are plenty of laws to keep people in their houses. In my state, anyone outside w/o an excuse can be charged with disorderly persons offense at the very least.
- walterbell 7y agoWhich state, what are some acceptable excuses?
- the_watcher 7y agoState and local governments have far greater abilities to issue orders like this than the federal government. What, exactly, is unconstitutional about a city issuing an order that revokes the ability of a business to operate due to a health emergency?
- throwaway0a5e 7y agoOn the surface there's not much constitutional protection for engaging in business but there would be some serious schadenfreude if Wickard v. Filburn showed up to defend individuals from state prosecution for once. edit: To expand on this, for an individual's right to do something to be protected from the states that right must be protected under the 14th amendment. Over the years the court has found that the 1st, 2nd, 4th, etc, basically all the big stuff is protected from state infringement under the 14th. In addition to this, for the incorporation of a right to under the 14th to have any teeth to this the court must have ruled that state regulation must pass strict scrutiny to be constitutional, in layman's terms it needs to be limited in scope to the bare minimum and there as to be a damn good reason. Unless you're willing to play some serious mental gymnastics there isn't any real combination of constitutionally protected rights and court rulings that restrict infringement on those rights that result in the ability to run a nail salon or other "clearly not essential" type business. Basically, no the constitution doesn't protect you from this. That's where civil liberties advocates old nemesis comes in. In Wickard v. Filburn the court ruled that even non-business activity that is fully contained within a state is subject to federal regulation under the interstate commerce clause because it affects market conditions if everyone does it. If this sounds like an end run around the constitution it's because it is. Normally you see this ruling used (I'd love to say "abused" but is it really abuse when it's functioning as intended?) to micro manage how states regulate businesses or go over states' heads and regulate them directly. So it would be a more or less complete 180 to see the ruling used to justify the federal government not only prevent states from regulating but allow people to go about their business without being stopped by state regulation. I think this is highly unlikely but a) it's fun to speculate and b) if the rest of 2020 has been any indication, anything is possible. Also, it should go without saying but this analysis is not exhaustive, there would be more to the issue than this.
- danans 7y ago> Why is it ok for people to shop at Walmart and not at their local small business that sells the same goods and is better equipped to enforce social distancing, with customers explicitly opting in to visit the smaller store? Small local businesses in the Bay Area that sell similar items to Walmart are open right now, from hardware stores to produce markets. I imagine apparel stores are shut, though many around me are doing online and appointment apparel shopping. If Walmart is the only store open where you are, it's likely the only store that exists selling essentials where you are, and that is a different problem.