7 ms·
You mean this is not the norm? The cases I've read seemed quite reasonable. They happened in the 90s and early 2000s though.
by matheusmoreira 7y ago
You mean this is not the norm? The cases I've read seemed quite reasonable. They happened in the 90s and early 2000s though.
- huffmsa 7y agoThere are definitely more than a few partisan court cases, but most of them are very very logical. Even when it's a partisan, ideological split.
- LiquidSky 7y agoHa. The trick is that what's "logical" and what's "partisan" depend entirely on who is speaking, like how cries of "judicial activism" only ever arise when it's a ruling against a conservative position. If it's a ruling FOR the conservative position, it's obviously logical and sound, and possibly correcting previous evil irrational liberal decisions.
- huffmsa 7y agoNo, I rarely read an opinion from the high court that I can't at least understand the logic and reasoning behind, regardless of if I agree with the conclusion
- tyre 7y agoThis is an easy take if you don't follow the court. The cases that tend to get a lot of press tend to be ones with clear ideological lines. But not every case is divided 5–4 along the line of which party nominated the justice. There are a lot of ideological currents that don't fit cleanly into political parties
- CWuestefeld 7y agocries of "judicial activism" only ever arise when it's a ruling against a conservative position I saw a counterexample just this morning. An editorial was arguing that the Court's "interference" in the Michigan election threatens democracy, and the only solution is to pack the court.
- ISL 7y agoIt is the norm for the Court. It's just quite contrary to much of what we see in the news daily. This ruling split the judges in an uncommon way, which was even more welcome.
- tyre 7y agoI read a few case opinions per year. There are ones that are partisan but on the whole are incredibly well thought through, argued, and written. There are some disasters, but even then you get beautiful rebuttals (e.g. Kagan's dissent in Rucho v. Common Cause)
- golemotron 7y agoIt's even more impressive when you realize that in many cases the opinions are largely researched and written by clerks.
- MiroF 7y agoI would say less impressive? Many great things can be produced by teams of what are essentially grad students. A single person churning out brilliant opinions over decades would be more impressive to me.
- ulkesh 7y agoIt may be the norm, but they also get some completely wrong: Citizens United, for example.
- Redoubts 7y agoWhat if it's right, but the constitution is wrong?
- huffmsa 7y agoThen you follow the procedure outlined in article 5 to amend the Constitution.
- DaiPlusPlus 7y agoThat is much easier said than done. It’s 2020 and we still don’t have a gender equality amendment even though the majority of states want one. ...let alone amendments for healthcare as a right, abortion rights, and proportional representation.
- gowld 7y agoAre gender equality laws prohibited by the Constitution? Title IX shows no.
- DaiPlusPlus 7y agoThe issue isn’t that there’s a difficulty in creating gender-equality laws, but that the opposite is true: it’s just as straightforward for a legislature somewhere to enact misogynistic laws. A constitutional amendment to recognise gender equality would mean US laws like these could be struck-down or never get enacted in the first place: https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/sexist-laws-in-the-us-in-2017/ https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/sexist-laws-in-the-...
- huffmsa 7y agoIt's supposed to be hard. That's the point. You have to get an absolutely overwhelming majority before you can change a the source code.