7 ms·
Oh, that's a hardline position. It's a good argument for taxing advertising. In a society that's spent out, with a low savings rate, advertising just moves dema
by Animats 7y ago
Oh, that's a hardline position. It's a good argument for taxing advertising. In a society that's spent out, with a low savings rate, advertising just moves demand around. It doesn't generate it.
(One could write an article about the Web titled "The obsolescence of information in the advertising age." Cover the decline of actual info provided on web sites, vs. the giant sucking sound of the onboarding funnel. You know, the sites which have nothing but stock photos and a form for entering in your email address.)
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> advertising just moves demand around. It doesn't generate it I’ve seen ads for products I would have never bought, because I never knew they existed, and wound up better for it.
- IgorPartola 7y agoThe point they are trying to make is that if you have very little money to spend, advertising product A to you so you buy it instead of product B is moving demand around. It’s only generating demand if you have money to spend on both A and B.
- Zarath 7y agoRight, but it redistributes demand around. Ever been to a busy boardwalk with people hired to call out and give samples out to get people to come in? It's an arms race like that, it redistributes the demand of eating on the boardwalk, and those that don't pay for the advertising don't survive, so everyone does it, but ultimately the boardwalk would be more or less the same without it
- corysama 7y agoThat assumes all products are of equal value to all people. Which is clearly not true. What makes this situation hard is that there are two problems: 1) Even if you make a good product, it is not reasonable to demand the world to just inform everyone about it on your behalf. Getting the word out takes effort. Money is the potential energy of human effort. 2) There is so much money to be made from various products that trillions of dollars are being spent getting the word out about various products. That makes it hard to rise above the baseline noise if you don't happen to start with large amounts of money. As a result, I've seen many investment deals based entirely around "You have a good product. We have money. We'll put money into advertising your product in return for owning part of it."
- hannasanarion 7y agoThat is a tiny fragment of advertising we see though. Of all the ads I see in a month, I feel like maybe one or two informs me of a new product, and usually not one I'll buy (and usually those ads are in non-traditional media, like YouTube sponsors). All the rest are big brands everybody already knows.
- achillesheels 7y agoIn theory, isn’t that what digital marketing is supposed to promise? It seems as though the marketing bandwidth is optimized for economies of scale purchasing in both analog and digital domains.
- jotm 7y agoThe direction of online advertising was super precise targeting, but that was abandoned long before privacy became important, for some reason. Even related ads on Amazon by Amazon are 99% trash, which is incredible.
- achillesheels 7y agoThis is the promise of the Facebook API...and this is perhaps why I find Instagram to be incredibly potent (and reasonably expensive) - it has sufficiently advanced targeting as well as a “catalog” feel, ie engaged purchasing. Still, I thought we’d be much further along by now with finding things I didn’t know I needed. Maybe it’s the ROMI which doesn’t work with small firms? Maybe marketing requires a minimum buy for efficacy? Likewise incredible is the fact I have to see spanx ads on YouTube.
- lamnk 7y agorecently when I want to buy something, I will find some pages on FB that sell the products, then refresh my newsfeed a few times to see FB ads suggestions :)
- sandworm101 7y agoAnd I bet you also bought products to solve problems that, without advertising, you may have thought had no solution. There are certainly evils surrounding medical advertising, but many people suffer very embarrassing or painful conditions until they learn, via an ad, that there is a product that can help. If an ad for a new drug means that someone suffering with disease reaches out and finds help, that isn't evil.
- Razengan 7y ago> I’ve seen ads for products I would have never bought, because I never knew they existed, and wound up better for it. Such as? I can't recall myself purchasing anything [just] because of an ad, or knowing anyone else who did, or even seeing an ad for something I was interested in. Everything that I've spent money on, has been discovered through manual search, word of mouth (on online forums), voluntarily subscribed newsletters/feeds (like a favorite developer announcing a new game or app) or random recommendations algorithms (like these clips of Mortal Engines and Ultimate Chicken Horse that I just saw on YouTube, or featured spots on the App Store, Steam, iTunes etc.) which I guess may count as a form of advertisement but they show me what a product is actually like.
- ericzawo 7y agoOh really? How much of your time has been spent on what brand of salt is in your pantry right now? What informs your type of shampoo in your bathroom? How much weight would you say your friends or colleagues experience with a car brand has influenced the decision you made to purchase one auto manufacturer's model over another? Advertising works and if it didn't it wouldn't exist. While I do understand and am with you on your philosophy of making an informed decision, so much of our impulses as we purchase the things required to live daily are influenced by ads whether we're aware of them or not.
- Razengan 7y ago> How much of your time has been spent on what brand of salt is in your pantry right now? What informs your type of shampoo in your bathroom? I pick these up from store aisles more or less at random. > How much weight would you say your friends or colleagues experience with a car brand has influenced the decision you made to purchase one auto manufacturer's model over another? None, I don't own a car, but I can see the point you're trying to make with that one. > Advertising works and if it didn't it wouldn't exist. There is a possibility that it actually doesn't and is a case of the emperor with no clothes, an unnecessary industry perpetuated by those in the industry.
- 7y ago
- FiatLuxDave 7y agoTo me this makes an excellent argument for taxation rather than banning. People do occasionally find advertising useful. The problem is not the existence of advertising, it is the amount of it. In medicine, it is the dose that makes the difference between a useful medicine and a poison. If we had about 95% less advertising volume in our lives, people wouldn't be so upset about it. And the remaining 5% of ads would need to be better (more useful, more entertaining, more pertinent) to compete in a reduced ecological niche.
- anthonypasq 7y agoyour demand for that product was already there, otherwise the advertisement would have had no effect on you. Marketing does not create demand.
- craftinator 7y agoI generally search for the things I need, and find them if they exist. And I actively boycott advertised companies because I hate the state of our ad industry.
- mcswell 7y agoI'm confused. You wound up better for discovering they existed and not buying them, or for discovering they existed and buying them?
- JSavageOne 7y agoIn my entire life I can't recall a single instance of buying something because an advertisement introduced me to something or convinced me to.
- handedness 7y agoFar be it from me to defend advertising, but that assumes a zero-sum economy with fixed productivity and fixed wealth. It also assumes a number of other things, including no economies of scale, no innovation to meet increased demand, etc. Consumer goods are in some ways about as inexpensive as they've ever been. Turnover can create a landscape conducive to innovation. And all that aside, ads for fractional lending, for example, would theoretically generate capital, and not merely move it around.