6 ms·
Isn't it interesting that there isn't much of interest for the most successful major European-Asian country out there? I am talking about Turkey, where death r
by mrtksn 7y ago
Isn't it interesting that there isn't much of interest for the most successful major European-Asian country out there?
I am talking about Turkey, where death rates are even lower than Germany and the curfews are partial. There's an abundance of IC units despite the 100K cases and the spread curve is already going down and the country is in a position to offer substantial help to other major countries.
There have been some CNN[0] and BBC reporting on this but with the numbers THAT good, I would have expected much higher interest. I know about the democracy and free speech situation but the country is not North Korea, Turkey is actually doing that good in managing the situation.
Just switch Turkey on in this website and you'll see how much better Turkey is doing.
I am beginning to suspect that the Eurocentric mindset is literally killing Europeans at this time. There's a hugely successful country that is integrated with Europe, has some of its territory in Europe, it has a population of a large European country and yet nobody seems to think about looking at Turkey for an example.
As a quick note, Turkey manages to do this through aggressive contact tracing through thousands of tracking teams around the country. It was revealed that in Istanbul alone there are 1200 contact tracing teams consisting of doctors, nurses and etc. that track down every infection. It's not as cool as having Tech giants make an app but it works. According to the health ministry, these teams use purpose built apps to coordinate and the entire health system is well integrated and they monitor every single patients status - be it at home or in the hospital and have very good picture of the situation.
Turkey has many problems but the health system is not one of them and maybe it's worth taking a look at.
[0]: https://edition.cnn.com/videos/world/2020/04/21/inside-turkey-icu-coronavirus-arwa-damon-pkg-cnni-vpx.cnn/video/playlists/coronavirus-intl/ https://edition.cnn.com/videos/world/2020/04/21/inside-turke...
- renox 7y agoHow about Czech Republic? I think that's an even better example.
- mrtksn 7y agoSure, why not, they are doing great too. However, Turkey has a population of 82 million(and more than 5 million refugees) which is in par with the UK, France, Germany. You don't have the excuse of "It's a small country" when it comes to Turkey. Thousands of citizens were repatriated, large PPE deliveries to the UK, Spain, Italy and so on, the death rate is at 2.5, the hospital bed occupancy rate was at about %50, ICU occupancy rate at about 60% last time I checked. The country is doing something right and is doing it right at scale.
- Jemm 7y agoThat all depends on if you can trust the numbers coming out of Turkey.
- mrtksn 7y agoI know but Turkey is not North Korea or Iran, there are many western journalists based in Turkey and they are indeed reporting that the situation is fine and the hospitals have plenty of capacity to go. There are some concerns on reporting methodology but these concerns are not different than those in the UK. Nothing that will change the picture substentially.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lm28469 7y agoTurkey is essentially a dictatorship, if you want to believe in their numbers feel free to do so but I'm very skeptical about the accuracy of their reports.
- mrtksn 7y agoYou are right to be sceptical, it is indeed a dictatorship but it's not the kind of dictatorship that makes doctors disappear. There is no indication about any major cover-ups, the country is not insulated from the west, has visa-free travel with many Western countries, is part of many western institutions and has many wester journalists based in Turkey. "I don't like Erdogan and his policies" is not good enough to dismiss Turkey as a closed society, the country is NOT like DPRK or Iran. Turkey is financially and institutionally integrated with Europe and the USA. This(dismissing the country solely on its current political situation or lack of awareness beyond the stereotype and prejudice) is exactly the mentality that I am talking about and I suspect that it is killing many people in the west.
- chvid 7y agoThe whole thing is about to be so political that everything is buried in noise. China's numbers cannot be trusted. Turkey's numbers cannot be trusted. WHO cannot be trusted. Even Germany cannot be trusted; I saw a statement from an Italien doctor saying that reason for the difference between Germany and Italy was that Germany was systematically undercounting deaths (for political reasons).
- jmkerr 7y ago'I saw a statement from an...', therefore 'Even Germany cannot be trusted'. Can't argue with that.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI agree it's unrealistic to propose they're hiding bodies. But the death count could be suppressed by merely implementing unreasonable standards for what's reported as a coronavirus death. Articles I've read suggest that Turkey isn't doing particularly well when measured by excess deaths over the historical baseline. (I agree with the obvious followup, that we should check to see if other countries we believe are doing well look good in the same metric.)
- febeling 7y agoAs someone with German perspective, I'm sure you have a point about Europe having a blind spot there. Still, it looks like Turkey also are earlier in the curve, which would explain at least some of the better fatality numbers.
- mrtksn 7y agoWhy do you think Turkey is early in the curve, the new infections are falling and Turkey is doing more tests per capita than France or the UK. That's probably an example of the blind eye.
- febeling 7y agoI'm looking at data in the JHU dashboard. I see the first cases in the Daily Cases chart in late February for Germany, and around March 17 for Turkey. It looks like an about three-week time lag.
- kingofpandora 7y agoHave spoken to a doctor you know in Turkey about the situation (I'm assuming you are Turkish)? The ones on the ground don't have such a rosy view.
- mrtksn 7y agoI have relatives in the business(doctors and nurses) who work in some of the largest hospitals that deal with the pandemic. Obviously it's not a rosy situation when a hunders people are dying every day but I am yet to see a credible report of a cover-up. My doctor relative told me that she had to buy some of her PPE and that they are getting paranoid about catching the bug but she doesn't think that the situation is worse than the reported. She complained about some management issues like asking people to get a test but not providing them with a safe place to queue and so on but no, people are not dying en mass here in Istanbul.
- abdulmuhaimin 7y agosadly, many people refuse to set their prejudice aside and admit when someone(or country) is doing the right thing