4 ms·
One solution could be some form of mandatory rent holiday, although it might already be too late. The sensible landlords should not be charging rent to their s
by amluto 7y ago
One solution could be some form of mandatory rent holiday, although it might already be too late.
The sensible landlords should not be charging rent to their small business tenants right now. If the lose them all, then their properties will be worth considerably less when the dust settles.
- nickff 7y agoThe property values are not going to be affected by any individual landlord, but keeping a reliable tenant may be extremely valuable during the recovery. Getting a good tenant is often difficult, and getting any tenant at all can be near-impossible in a recession.
- capdeck 7y agoSome landlords have mortgages to pay too - so in that case "rent holiday" is basically "landlord pays for tenant". But commercial real estate seems to be a different beast. I've witnessed a large amount of commercial property being empty for years at a time (5+) in a fairly expensive area of NY. Commercial landlords in this case probably owned the buildings outright and were in agreement to keep rents high even if it made it longer to find the next tenant. It probably is not like that everywhere, but I was really surprised that half of the building would just sit unoccupied for so long.
- ryoshu 7y agoMy naive understanding is that the empty storefronts offset as a tax loss from a more lucrative line of business from the matrixed holding company that owns the property. The empty storefront on 5th Ave. doesn't matter to the owners because the numbers work out on a spreadsheet.
- WalterBright 7y agoLosses reduce the taxable income, they are not tax credits. If you're paying a 20% tax rate, you still lose 80% of those losses.
- seganddr 7y agoSuspending mortgage payments should be looked at also
- exclusiv 7y agoThey have forebearance of 180 days and you can extend another 180. But this will unwind very badly because it's still due yet the renters and homeowners won't be in a position to pay lump sums. From a Planet Money episode, essentially the mortgage servicers will go bankrupt as they are the only ones that can't defer payments in the flow. You have renters, landlords, banks, mortgage servicers, investors and the federal government guarantees a lot of mortgages. It seems most plausible that homeowners who don't pay will end up with longer mortgages versus a balloon payment they won't be able to handle.
- matwood 7y agoDo you also default on all of the bonds that are backed by mortgages?
- nightski 7y agoThe current proposal in Congress reimburses landlords and mortgage holders with taxpayer money subject to stipulations. This proposal is actually much cheaper than the UBI esque one.
- concerned_user 7y agoI have heard that with commercial space you can take building depreciation costs and write that off as an expense so it might be not as expensive for a landlord to keep the property vacant as you would imagine. Also sometimes as I understand it is new tenant who has to clean up and bring the building up to code to open, and if there is plenty of other properties to lend they might find something with less upfront costs. Location is everything in cities like NY, especially for businesses that rely on people traffic so few hundred feet closed to rail station might be a lot more expensive so they just wait for tenant that can utilize that.
- manigandham 7y agoThe landlords have bills of their own. Very few of them own their properties completely (which doesn't make sense anyway with low interest rates). If you stop rent payments then you must also help landlords and property owners with their mortgage.
- Pfhreak 7y agoThat's a false equivalence. Landlords have huge equity advantages that the renters do not. That said, I agree, we should be deferring mortgages and canceling rents.
- EGreg 7y agoHere’s what I don’t get Everyone is paying downstream until you hit the lenders. What are the lenders’ costs? What if they pause repayment for 3 months and tack it on to the end of their loans? Presumably if all the lenders downstream did this, we could really hit pause.
- matwood 7y agoYou think the lenders don't have anyone to pay? Many mortgages are packaged up into bonds [1]. Those bond coupon payments are often times what retired people are using for their fixed income to pay their bills. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortgage-backed_security#Market_size_and_liquidity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortgage-backed_security#Marke...
- EGreg 7y agoAlright, but didn’t we send those retired people checks? By the way this is another reason why UBI is good in a crisis. It creates a floor for people to buy food etc. while we suspend rent payments and mortgages for a few months. And with no disincentive to work like we have now. Anyway... so who do the retired people need to pay when everything is on pause? Social Security and Medicare cover a lot of the basics. If they have investments yielding enough for them to live on, then they have savings that they can use 0.5% of in three months. Not to mention, the stock market is down, we can pause bond yields for the retirees for a few months also. The only thing I wouldn’t pause is sovereign debt, since we can print money to service it and confidence in that is paramount. (Another reason why McConnell’s stance on letting states go bankrupt is dangerous. I would have liked to see states and cities have the ability to issue their own complementary currencies.)