7 ms·
The SE is Apple’s way of cutting off the oxygen supply to competing me-too mid and high end Android smartphones, for the many people that really don’t care abou
by simonh 7y ago
The SE is Apple’s way of cutting off the oxygen supply to competing me-too mid and high end Android smartphones, for the many people that really don’t care about the brand. It’s a no-compromises smartphone with the fastest internals you can get, plenty of longevity and competitive screen and camera at a midrange price. If we hadn’t already got XRs for my teenage kids, this SE would have been the obvious choice.
- megablast 7y ago> with the fastest internals you can get, plenty of longevity and competitive screen and camera at a midrange price So improved CPU which most people do not car about, old design and not great camera.
- gherkinnn 7y agoPeople don’t care about the CPU, they care about the fact that the phone will remain fast and snappy for many years to come. And many of the same people who don’t give a shit about the CPU don’t care about the design and not-great camera either.
- fulafel 7y agoThe reason phones become badly janky as the years pass is very rately the CPU. You can tell by how the lag ebbs, there are small hangs and the the device gets going again. It's some combination of flash perf degeneration, ram squeeze, and the many ways the OS install degenerates between wipes. And OS upgrades that have left old hw performance regressions unfixed.
- sq_ 7y agoMost compelling thing versus similarly priced Android offerings from my point of view is the guarantee of software support far into the future. Hardware is roughly the same as the 11, so, based on Apple's past behavior, one can expect that this will be supported for roughly as long as the 11 will. I'm definitely not aware of many Android phones at this price point that one can expect to get security updates, much less feature updates, 4-5 years into the future.
- GeekyBear 7y agoThe iPhone 5s got six years of OS and security updates. Since the iPhone 4s, every major iPhone has received at least five years of support. The sole exception was the first attempt at a budget iPhone, the 2013 iPhone 5c, which only got four years of updates.
- scarface74 7y agoThe 4s from 2011 got a bug fix/security update June of last year....
- saagarjha 7y agoThat was for GPS positioning; there were no security fixes in that update.
- hocuspocus 7y agoOn Android, a much bigger part of the OS gets updated through the Play store and Play services, you certainly do get access to new features 5 years into the future.
- ViViDboarder 7y agoBut you’re on your own if there is a kernel exploit!
- simonh 7y agoThat’s true, Play Services has proved a great way to get useful feature updates out without being beholden to the carriers and manufacturers, but it doesn’t really help much on the security side.
- hocuspocus 7y agoIt's not perfect and Google should definitely figure out a way to push low-level security fixes, but it does help on the security side as well. A lot of the attack surface (the Play store itself, messaging apps, browser, system webview, ...) keeps getting updates for many years after the end of system upgrades delivered by the OEM.
- tambourine_man 7y ago>…and not great camera The camera is best in class. It's a single less system, but a remarkable one.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe amount of people who make use of the camera features in the 11 pro versus the camera in the SE is probably in the low single digits, if that.
- 1123581321 7y agoGiven that 11 Pro features are accessed as soon as you touch the prominent zoom UI, and that Night Mode is automatic, that seems unlikely, but I would like to learn more. It doesn’t seem like public data is readily available after some searching.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI don’t have data of course, but the way most people take photos, it really doesn’t seem like they know or care how to utilize those functions. The zoom is nice, but is it $500 nice? In my circle, they’re taking the pics, and then sharing super compressed versions of it in WhatsApp. No one is spending their time organizing huge photo and video files for posterity. Maybe I am wrong and people will opt for better camera functions. I certainly like that they’re hitting multiple price points now, so if you want a fancy camera you can get it and if you don’t, you can get SE.
- unethical_ban 7y agoThe camera is outright fantastic in terms of performance, responsiveness, etc. and people do care about the CPU - they care about their phone being responsive, and being usable for more than 24 months before it starts feeling like an Amiga. The A13 is an incredible processor.
- code_duck 7y agoWhat do you mean by 'feeling like an Amiga'? I don't think that is a great example of an unresponsive interface.
- bgorman 7y agoIf you put a LCD display next to a OLED display, the difference is striking. Pretty much every Android phone has a better display, and is easier on the eyes.
- dogma1138 7y agoWhich $400 android phones (with warranty and service and guaranteed updates for 4-5 years) come with an OLED these days?
- bgorman 7y agoThe Pixel 3a has an OLED display, and probably the best update guarantees you can get on Android. Why are you expecting Android phones to come with a 4-5 year warranty? The iPhone comes with a 1 year warranty
- scarface74 7y agoHe said “guaranteed updates” not warranties.
- kalleboo 7y agoDidn't the Pixel 1 only get updates for 3 years?
- morsch 7y agoAnd that's pretty much as good as it gets. With the notable exception of community maintainance, eg. Lineage OS.
- hocuspocus 7y agoIn practice nobody cares about the Android version or upgrades. People just want to install the latest apps, which you can do for a very long time even on an outdated entry-level Android phone.
- 7y ago
- CoolGuySteve 7y agoI switched to Android when I realized a few years back I could buy a whole phone that did everything I need for the price of an iPhone screen replacement. My $150 Moto G7 is much slower but I don't really notice. It has a taller screen that's better for reading websites, emails, books, etc, a headphone jack, and SD storage for my music/videos. So as far as "commoditized pocket computers" go, welcome to the party, I guess.
- scarface74 7y agoI definitely notice the difference in performance between a 2018 Moto G and a 2015 iPhone 6s. The iPhone 6s was much faster.
- CoolGuySteve 7y ago"notice" is a bad word for it, I should say I don't care. The browser scrolls, the apps launch, the keyboard types, all that happens at a reasonable pace. I don't notice frustration with the performance.
- __blockcipher__ 7y agoIt sounds like those tradeoffs make sense for your use case. Personally I find any slowness whatsoever in a phone to be unacceptable because it’s such a fundamental computing device (for me) and because I’m not a highly price sensitive consumer if I’m getting a level of performance that makes it worth it to me. In other words, the market is working as intended, allowing consumers to optimize for the factors that matter to them :)
- yodsanklai 7y agoI'd like to have an iphone for better integration with my mac and for the smaller size, but overall, the iphone SE is still more expensive than comparable android phones (e.g. xiaomi). There are also various features that I like on my android phone, such as the usb-c charger and a jack port.
- ViViDboarder 7y agoWhich Xiaomi? Comparable how? I haven’t seen the latest releases, but I remember the fastest Xiaomi phones being more expensive than this. The SE has a flagship chipset.
- ornornor 7y agoTry a used 6S. You can get very good condition ones with a good battery for less than 200$ and it’s still very fast on the latest iOS.
- paul7986 7y agoIf they make an expensive iPhone SE (size) I'd buy that too! I bought the XS and immediately returned it due to the size (too big for one hand only texting) and no Touch ID (now Face ID while wearing a mask seems an even worse UX). I've kept and been happy with my iPhone 8 Since September 2017. Previously I bought a new iPhone each year! Though finally replacing it with the new SE in a week or two.