3 ms·
Lets not get too excited about this. Whatever the numbers, that's interesting and worth recording for planning. But whatever they are, they result in "way too m
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Lets not get too excited about this. Whatever the numbers, that's interesting and worth recording for planning. But whatever they are, they result in "way too many deaths". This is still a very dangerous and rapidly-spreading virus.
- partiallypro 7y agoI think the hope is that we could be closer to herd immunity than we think.
- the8472 7y agoAny herd immunity scenario is conditionnal on immunity is long-lasting, which is far from certain considering related viruses are recurring seasonally or in single-digit year intervals. Don't bet the farm on it.
- k2enemy 7y agoWhere is the cutoff between "way too many deaths" and not too many deaths? I don't mean to be glib, but it is an important question that needs to be weighed against destroying all of our economic institutions.
- pgsbathhouse2 7y ago> that needs to be weighed against destroying all of our economic institutions. No it doesn't. Like the statement alone doesn't even have any credence, let alone following through with it. Incredibly daft.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoEconomic institutions sustain people's lives. Declining productivity translates to loss in life expectancy.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoIf everything else remains unchanged. Which it isn't. Changes are happening every day. And nobody plans to stay in this mode forever. Medicine is making tremendous progress at an astonishing rate. They just need time. Stay patient.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoThere are viral infections for which vaccines were never successfully developed, despite over a decade of research and trials. There is no guarantee a vaccine will be developed for SARS-CoV-2 in anything approaching a timely manner. People need to weigh the costs and risks of a near total freeze on economic activity against those of letting the virus run its course until herd immunity develops.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThere are 115 trials underway. There are 100,000 very smart investigators working day and night. There has already been tremendous progress. My niece works at a lab developing a cheap test. Two of their researchers have already died of this virus (they went to work despite the risks). Don't make fools of them, by falling into despair and negativity.
- CryptoPunk 7y ago
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoStrawman. Weigh it against suspension of economic institutions, new rules to mitigate the damage, and new institutions that operate on more rational basis.
- tempestn 7y agoYeah, one leap I often see made is, say a study shows "only" a 0.5% case fatality rate, about 5x as bad as an average flu. It's natural from there to then think letting it run unchecked would only be about 5x as bad as a flu. Very bad, certainly, but perhaps manageable. But that ignores the fact that there is a flu vaccine, and even without one the natural rate of spread of the flu is lower than this virus. So without measures, many more people would be infected and so it would be much worse than 5x an average flu, even if the CFR is indeed 0.5% (for example). Of course, that doesn't mean these numbers aren't useful for planning and determining what degree of intervention is warranted, as you say. Edit: could one of those down-voting explain? If I'm making a mistake here I'd like to understand it.