3 ms·
I just don't understand the rhetoric here. The climate disaster scenario is > everything is expected to change: the air we breathe, the food we eat, the water
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I just don't understand the rhetoric here. The climate disaster scenario is
> everything is expected to change: the air we breathe, the food we eat, the water we drink, the landscapes we see, the oceans, the seasons, the daily routine, the quality of life. Our children will have to adapt or become extinct. They will have to dress differently, behave differently, live differently.
Sounds bad! I'm open to ideas on how to prevent such radical disruptions. But the author suggests that we need to end fossil fuel consumption, reconfigure our economic system, reconsider what it means to have a decent life, and eliminate our desire to consume lots of goods and services. Shouldn't we expect a comparable amount of disruption from these huge changes?
- yodsanklai 7y agoConsuming less goods and services doesn't sound as bad as drinking poisonous water and breathing toxic air. I think our children will experience both scenarios anyway (they already do in poorer countries).
- bhupy 7y agoEnding fossil fuel consumption is at least somewhat relevant to the stated problem...but reconfiguring economic systems? The Greeks couldn't construct a better horse than that.
- nickik 7y agoThe original New Deal was quite clearly designed for that as well. It was not about improving the economy, it was about chaining society and achieve political dominance.
- bhupy 7y agoRight, it is totally orthogonal to the climate, and is already the subject of a forever-long debate over how we ought to organize society. You're going to have a hard time fixing the climate if you also attach with it a completely unrelated laundry list of desired left-wing policy (not even trying to knock left-wing policy). It's functionally equivalent to adding a corporate-gender-diversity quota to the Coronavirus stimulus.
- Crye 7y agoWould you like to be driving the car when it veers off the road, or in the passenger seat. Passively waiting for the disruption of climate change to ravage normalcy, is probably going to be worst then trying to dealing with it aggressively. The equity of disruption will be extreme in the passive case.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI don't agree with the intuition. Even in the worst projections, climate change will be somewhat gradual; we won't wake up one day to find all the corn in Iowa is dead. The day we expropriate the factories, as the author insists we must, will be pretty extreme.
- augustt 7y agoIf only there were a current event that illustrates the danger of this line of thinking when it comes to things that can spiral out of control exponentially...
- bhupy 7y agoWhat? The two aren't related. You can't just take one event that demonstrably exhibits exponential-growth characteristics (via the R0) and another event that demonstrably doesn't, and then declare them to have the same growth characteristics just because they're vaguely similar in level-of-catastrophe.
- js8 7y ago> another event that demonstrably doesn't I would like to see a demonstration that ecological collapse cannot happen exponentially in response to a linear change in the environment. I am no ecologist, but I don't believe it.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoEven the worst case projections don't propose that the average temperature will change by more than current day-to-day variability. That doesn't mean it's okay, it'll cause a lot of problems if every day is 4 degrees hotter, but a spiral out of control won't happen.