32 ms·
Amazon asks workers sheltering at home to return or request leave
- replyguy912 7y agoThis seems reasonable and beyond what other major employers are offering, but as is the fashion I'm sure Amazon will be convicted in the court of public interwebs shortly...
- kevingadd 7y agoWhat's a few avoidable deaths between friends, after all? There are multiple active outbreaks in crowded factories and other facilities, just like an Amazon fulfillment warehouse. They do not have necessary safety equipment and procedures in place yet. Forcing people to show up to work under these conditions is murder. They could fix it, though. A starting point would be Amazon providing tests and ensuring that everyone has been tested before returning to work, along with ensuring everyone has masks and gloves and enough time to thoroughly wash their hands throughout their shift. Press reports up until this point and complaints from employees suggest none of that is consistently the case.
- newacct583 7y ago> What's a few avoidable deaths between friends, after all? Amazon is about as close to the ideal of an "essential employer" as anyone is, though. They're shipping a huge amount of food and other essentials. Objectively, a package delivered through a managed professional environment is less risky and involves fewer potential transmission events than one purchased at retail. Online sellers, where they have product to deliver, are the ones we want to prioritize keeping open. Now... there's lots to complain about with Amazon's response in other ways. It's very reasonable to argue that their workers need more PPE, employer-provided testing and notification, hazard pay, better safety practices, etc... But if you want to argue that Amazon should shut down... who do you want to be open instead?
- jcims 7y agoI'm glad I waited an extra minute to comment b/c you did all the work. Amazon has allowed me to limit my local travels to two physical environments for essentially the past six weeks. There's a value to that in reducing transmission.
- aaomidi 7y agoBy requiring others to do that for you and paying them pennies for what value they're providing. I'd agree with you if the company decided to not take profit during this time and paid the employees the same amount of value they produce.
- bhupy 7y ago> By requiring others to do that for you and paying them pennies for what value they're providing. The median wage of an Amazon Warehouse worker is about $60,000 / year, which is above the median wage in the US[1]. The 25th-percentile wage for the same worker is $53,000 — still higher than the median wage, and this is an entry level position that requires no college eduction. Amazon also provides 401(k) matching for their warehouse workers and provides them the same group health insurance as their software engineers and executives[2][3]. It is quite possibly the most generous set of benefits currently available to an entry-level low-skill worker with no college education. > I'd agree with you if the company decided to not take profit during this time and paid the employees the same amount of value they produce. Couple things: 1) I think you're overestimating how much profit Amazon makes on its retail business; the margins are razor thin. 2) profit is just the cost of labor for the managers, I.e. the people that are coordinating the labor and calling the high-level shots. This includes coming up with the policies and systems to ensure the company can continue to operate in the midst of a global pandemic. Finally, Amazon employed 798,000 people as of 2019, and added 100,000 new jobs in the last month alone, with 50,000 current openings outstanding. A lot of the margin goes into literally providing all of these wages and benefits for nearly 1 million people. This is more than many industrialized nations. [1] https://www.paysa.com/salaries/amazon--warehouse-worker https://www.paysa.com/salaries/amazon--warehouse-worker [2] https://www.aboutamazon.com/amazon-fulfillment/working-here/compensation-and-benefits https://www.aboutamazon.com/amazon-fulfillment/working-here/... [3] https://www.glassdoor.com/Benefits/Amazon-US-Benefits-EI_IE6036.0,6_IL.7,9_IN1.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Benefits/Amazon-US-Benefits-EI_IE6...
- mardifoufs 7y agoThey are not forcing them since they are allowed to take time off. You can't self quarantine forever anyways, standard procedure is 14 days of quarantine if you think you may have been exposed to the virus or if you have any symptoms.
- kevingadd 7y agoUnpaid time off. How are people supposed to eat and pay rent if their only available leave is unpaid? How will they afford their hospital bills after being exposed?
- sida 7y agoSame as the 20+ million Americans who are laid off and seeking unemployment?
- kevingadd 7y agoI'm not sure why that makes it okay to add to that population? Amazon has the resources to temporarily cover paid leave until they can guarantee safe conditions in their warehouses for employees. Regions that have prematurely relaxed their virus controls have seen new outbreaks, the same could happen in warehouses. It's in everyone's best interest for Amazon to offer paid leave until their workplaces have been proven to be safe, which is going to take a bit even after all the appropriate measures are in place.
- bhupy 7y agoThe safety net is by far the better way to address this, it's a drop in the bucket relative to the total cost of the safety net. > It's in everyone's best interest for Amazon to offer paid leave until their workplaces have been proven to be safe, which is going to take a bit even after all the appropriate measures are in place. Amazon appears to think that your "until" condition is here now, per the safety measures they purport to be taking.
- xchaotic 7y agoYeah, I don’t see how few extra bucks is worth literally risking life. Total numbers look big but really it’s $120 more per each shift where you can be exposed or expose others to a deadly virus.
- throwaway744678 7y agoRemember that you are risking your life every day getting out of your bed, even without this virus.
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y ago>A starting point would be Amazon providing tests and ensuring that everyone has been tested before returning to work Amazon can't win. If they did that, the newspaper headlines would read "Bezos demands DNA samples of workers as a prerequisite to being paid."
- kevingadd 7y agoCOVID tests aren't DNA tests. It's a swab of the back of your throat (through the nose, oof) to test for a specific virus. It's not hard to find the specific stuff used to perform the tests, it's out there on the internet, the CDC published it. Are we really descending into paranoia about Amazon trying to genetically profile employees?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThere's a big population of people who just start from the premise that Amazon must be doing something wrong and search for facts to justify it. I lost my ability to assume good faith when people complained they should pay $15 an hour, they started paying $15 an hour, and then the controversy immediately restarted about how greedy they are to not pay more.
- bhupy 7y agoNever mind the fact that Amazon does 401(k) matching and provides its warehouse workers the same group health insurance plan as their software engineers, which might possibly be the most generous health insurance plan for an entry-level position that requires no college degree.
- jonknee 7y agoI'm pretty sure they could start paying a minimum wage of $30 an hour and people would be irate that they're making it impossible to hire anyone because Amazon is overpaying. When you're the biggest player there is nowhere to hide.
- 7y ago
- jonknee 7y agoFrom their post on the topic it sounds like you should be happy with their plan: https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/how-amazon-prioritizes-health-and-safety-while-fulfilling-customer-orders https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/how-amazon-priorit... > Millions of masks have been distributed across our network. They are available to all Amazon associates, delivery service partners, Amazon Flex participants, seasonal employees, and Whole Foods Market stores employees. We are encouraging everyone to take and use them. As for testing, they have been unable to do it through regular channels so they are building a lab to do it themselves: > An important safety step might be regular testing of all employees for COVID-19, including those without symptoms. We have begun assembling equipment we need to build our first lab to process tests and hope to start testing small numbers of our frontline employees soon. As for cleanliness: > We have increased the frequency and intensity of cleaning at all sites, including regular sanitization of door handles, handrails, touch screens, scanners, and other frequently touched areas. > Our enhanced cleaning has added almost 200 additional points of contact per site across our janitorial teams, and we’ve increased the size of our cleaning teams threefold to support our buildings. > We require everyone to wash their hands often with soap and water for at least 20 seconds, especially after using the bathroom and before eating, as well as after blowing their nose, coughing, or sneezing. If soap and water are not readily available, alcohol-based hand sanitizer stations are easily accessible throughout our buildings. > In addition to break times, employees can log out of their system to wash their hands whenever they choose, without worrying about impact on their performance goals.
- uoaei 7y agoContext matters. We are now over a month into the crisis, if you count it from the moment of lockdown. The fact that this wasn't a day one policy is inexcusable. Stop playing PR hype-man for Amazon, they don't need your help.
- duxup 7y agoThat person is not playing anything. They are noting what the facts are right now.
- mod 7y ago> Forcing people to show up to work under these conditions is murder. Nobody can be forced to show up, and no, that's not murder. > A starting point would be... Amazon has a page listing their pretty thorough adjustments for health & safety: https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/how-amazon-prioritizes-health-and-safety-while-fulfilling-customer-orders https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/how-amazon-priorit...
- kevingadd 7y agoUnpaid time off is forcing low-income workers to show up unless they want to starve.
- jshevek 7y agoBy starve do you mean "go hungry", or "eat less", or "starve to death"? Edit: I find "starve" to be a hyperbolic and emotionally manipulative choice of words, but I don't want to assume the worst. Maybe you have good reason to use this term?
- bl0b 7y agoNot having enough money to survive isn't a made up thing. However you want to define it, people need to make ends meet including right now.
- jshevek 7y ago>Not having enough money to survive isn't a made up thing. No one has suggested that anything here is a 'made up thing', are you creating strawmen? >However you want to define it, people need to make ends meet including right now. I'm interested in understanding what the GP's point was. I don't get to definitely choose arbitrary definitions and interpretations for them. The dictionary and accepted usage offers a range of interpretations.
- bl0b 7y ago
- macspoofing 7y ago>What's a few avoidable deaths between friends, after all? There is no vaccine coming for a year, maybe two, maybe never. "Flattening the curve" is ONLY a delaying strategy to not swamp the health-care system and hope that some treatments are developed (no guarantees there either). COVID is going to be part of our lives. Are you saying we should shelter in place forever? >A starting point would be Amazon providing tests What tests? Are you expecting every employer to test their workers every day? >along with ensuring everyone has masks and gloves and enough time to thoroughly wash their hands throughout their shift. That's reasonable. Masks + social distancing + gloves, and policies for hand washing and disinfecting of commonly used surfaces. I suspect Amazon isn't too far from that, and if they are it's only because of the global PPE shortage.
- kevingadd 7y agoIMO a starting point is: Single test for all employees before return to work, 100% guarantee that everyone has a mask for their shifts, the facility has ventilation, and they have gloves. 100% guarantee that facilities have soap and running water. In the past all of what I mention has been a problem in warehouses, and it's why employees are protesting. Amazon can fix this, but it's been a problem very recently. It's super reasonable if they can't gather up a bunch of N95s and medical grade gloves, but paper surgical masks or cloth masks should be feasible by now. It sounds like they're working on their own testing infrastructure, which is great.
- CuriouslyC 7y agoThe death rate with proper medical care is very low. The avoidable deaths are a direct result of a swamped medical system.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- greendude29 7y agoDisagree. Amazon is doing pretty well due to the quarantine (as they deserve to given the services they provide). Them having to reduce their share of the profits from these extraordinary times is not particularly noble, but rather just average. The United States hasn't even passed the first stage of Corona yet (in SF, daily number of deaths is still rising). It is too early to mandate come backs. Here in SF, multiple employees at 3 Whole Foods locations have already contracted Covid. Amazon has not done nearly enough thus far. The fact that they are now providing masks and cleaning up door handles is again, a bare minimum. They should let exigent time off policies rein for at least 2 more months, before going back to business as normal policies. Please realize, that even despite all of the above, their profits will keep rising through this period; there is no reason to think of them as victims, when they very much so are winners in this situation. Foregoing just a little bit of your extra profits to ensure your workers stay healthy in unprecedented times of a pandemic is not asking for too much.
- cco 7y ago> The United States hasn't even passed the first stage of Corona yet (in SF, daily number of deaths is still rising). It is too early to mandate come backs. That isn't true according to the numbers from https://coronavirus.1point3acres.com/en https://coronavirus.1point3acres.com/en. Do you have a citation for that? Numbers for new deaths have been hovering between 0 and 5 for the last month in SF, SF has had a total of 22 people dead, due to successful lockdown measures it basically never hit SF.
- auiya 7y agoCDC says it's still rising. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/cases-in-us.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/case...
- dmoy 7y agoSorry I'm not seeing anything in there that's saying number of deaths per day is rising. Can you help me navigate to where that is shown?
- hlmencken 7y agoThere is but one interweb.
- NeutronStar 7y agoGonna have to check with Russia and China if this holds true..
- wilde 7y agoI doubt Amazon would provide what it has here without public pressure.
- morningcovfefe 7y agoI tend to agree.. It's not on employers to support their employees - it's on governments to support their citizens. Amazon will get lambasted in the press, but this isn't an issue to be fixed employer by employer but rather by the government, which needs to provide safety nets like universal healthcare or living wage
- HarryHirsch 7y agoIn other countries employers have a duty of care towards their employees, they just can't use them up until they aren't good any longer. I note there are continuous reports about dozens of people falling sick with coronavirus at Amazon warehouses, and in the past there reports of were ambulances parked outside Amazon facilities because it's cheaper to cart someone off to the hospital with heatstroke than to provide proper air conditioning.
- _understood_ 7y ago*paywall
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y agoJust disable javascript if you're seeing a bloomberg paywall, the article should still read fine.
- qorrect 7y agoWell hey!
- onei 7y agoDisable JavaScript and reload. Whoever made the paywall was smart enough to detect incognito mode, but disabling JS apparently didn't occur to them. It works for most paywalls surprisingly.
- jonknee 7y agoDirect from the source, here is what Amazon is doing: https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/how-amazon-prioritizes-health-and-safety-while-fulfilling-customer-orders https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/how-amazon-priorit... > We’ve extended the increased hourly pay outlined below through May 16. We are also extending double overtime pay in the U.S. and Canada. These extensions increase our total investment in pay during COVID-19 to nearly $700 million for our hourly employees and partners. In addition, we are providing flexibility with leave of absence options, including expanding the policy to cover COVID-19 circumstances, such as high-risk individuals or school closures. We continue to see heavy demand during this difficult time and the team is doing incredible work for our customers and the community.
- falcolas 7y agoNone of this really disagrees with the article; it's an issue because people typically on a leave of absence don't get paid (notice the lack of "paid leave").
- jonknee 7y agoI never said it did? The article is behind a paywall and is based off this blog post which is not behind a paywall.
- Jaepa 7y agoNo, but saying look at all they're doing without addressing kind of the key part of the article does kind of miss the point, and makes your response seem more like a response from PR then a comment on the text.
- bhupy 7y agoI genuinely would like to make sure I'm not missing something: what's the "key part of the article" that's missing from the Amazon press release?
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y agoHow long until Amazon's warehouses are 100% fully robotic? Or 99% fully robotic? (With a small team of managers to check in on the robots)
- travbrack 7y agoI'm curious what the percentage is right now.
- mcqueenjordan 7y agoYou can go tour one. The robotics are pretty impressive. It reminded me of the scenes in Beauty and the Beast where the teapots and brooms and candlesticks were all orchestrated together to clean up/set the table/etc.
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y agoI wasn't aware amazon warehouse tours were an option... I think I'll plan one for when we're out of lockdown in my area. Thanks for the outing idea!
- j88439h84 7y agoI don't understand what this question means. Clearly none of the current employees' jobs have been automated, since otherwise the job wouldn't exist.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mportela 7y agoWithout the paywall: https://outline.com/YnuzdH https://outline.com/YnuzdH
- claudeganon 7y agoThere’s no greater demonstration of their internal class divide than what would happen if they asked HQ employees to stop working from home and do the same.
- looping__lui 7y ago... force people whose job can be done from home to go to the office for the sake of “solidarity” !?
- uoaei 7y agoThe point is that the way the system is currently set up, it sustains itself by using poor and working class bodies as consumable parts which are replaced when they inevitably crack under the pressure. Yes if you get a good education and get a desk job you can work from home. That's obvious. What is less obvious is who, on average, has the means and access to get to that position.
- looping__lui 7y agoHey, I am German. Assembly line worker generally earn similar to university graduates. It does not matter whether you are employed or not: your kids will get the same quality of schooling (almost no private schools), you get the same healthcare treatment everybody else gets, your kids will go to university for free - if they can’t afford living expenses the government will give them a free loan for that, you get 6 weeks of vacation and unlimited sick days. THIS has nothing to do with Amazon, BMW, Google, Facebook or the holy church. There is a divide - bit it’s not the “working classes” like Marx liked to predict but social/political systems.
- chadlavi 7y ago> it’s not the “working classes” like Marx liked to predict but social/political systems What's the difference, exactly? the social/political systems create the group of under-paid, under-served people. Call them working class or not, the problem is still there. In the US, employers pay drastically less for physical labor than knowledge work, government does not offer a social safety net, and social services are offered almost exclusively as paid services. People get trapped in a multi-generational cycle of lower wages, which means less desirable housing, worse schools, worse health care, which means their children have less opportunity for better-paying jobs. This creates, effectively, a low-wage-jobs-only group of people.
- speedgoose 7y ago> The company has said criticisms of its safety measures are unfounded. Well, the French justice forced them to improve their safety measures. They had to close down for 5 days to do so. I don't remember reading about them doing that worldwide. However, I do remember them complaining in emails sent to their French customers that they are forced to improve the safety measures and that the French justice is not nice. It was a bit ridiculous and not well received.
- strictnein 7y agoThat's not what happened at all. The French imposed very arbitrary guidelines on only delivering "essential" goods and they had to stop all deliveries to address them All these "essential" good definitions are complete nonsense anyways. What one person deems unnecessary can be very, very necessary to someone else.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- speedgoose 7y agoI do really disagree. This is a source from today : https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2020/04/24/coronavirus-la-justice-confirme-en-appel-le-rappel-a-l-ordre-d-amazon_6037670_3234.html https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2020/04/24/coronavir...
- strictnein 7y agoWhich says what I said. They shut down because they needed to figure out what was meant by the "essential" order. The fine was too large to do anything but pause operations. > On April 15, the online store preferred to close its six large French warehouses, ensuring that it had no other choice, given the amount of the penalty. "How to precisely define food, hygiene or medical products?" " Asked the business.
- speedgoose 7y ago
- uoaei 7y ago> These extensions increase our total investment in pay during COVID-19 to nearly $700 million for our hourly employees and partners. This is a drop in the bucket for Amazon. They are able to pay much better but do not. If the savings were being passed onto the customers, that's one thing, but with all the recent news about Amazon's practices, it's easy and convenient to take the cynical route.
- rriepe 7y agoPay and benefits were the conversation before, and Amazon was a villain. Now it's having a job vs. not having a job, and Amazon is a hero.
- jonknee 7y agoWhat dollar figure would make you happy?
- uoaei 7y agoNot talking about it in absolute terms. How about talking about it in terms of median wage per job title? Putting big numbers in glitzy blog posts only serves to dazzle and obfuscates how easy it would be for Amazon to double or triple that number with basically no dent in the wallet from doing so.
- ck2 7y agoThis is going to be like the 9/11 first responders where they had to beg for health care and health insurance for the rest of their lives. We have no idea what the lifetime implications are for someone getting sick. Put lifetime healthcare coverage with no cap in their contract. What are they going to somehow be "too healthy" ?
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/rY2I6 https://archive.md/rY2I6
- dchyrdvh 7y agoBezos is willing to sacrifice health of his slaves, I mean warehouse workers. It's a tough decision he had to make, but given the potential profits at stake, he decided it was worth it.
- crazygringo 7y ago> Amazon said earlier this month it had hired an additional 100,000 employees Not the main point of the article, but can I just say that's huge. That's... the same size as Google's entire full-time workforce. Granted they're low-skill warehouse positions, not highly paid engineering jobs, but still. The ability of a company to hire one hundred thousand people in a month is absolutely insane.
- jonknee 7y agoEven crazier, they have already announced an additional 75,000 openings. Just nuts.
- bhupy 7y agoAs of 2019, Amazon employed 798,000 employees, so we're looking at almost 1 million people, earning $15/hour at a minimum, with 401(k), health, vision, and dental benefits. Absolutely nuts.
- vadym909 7y agoI'd be really surprised if these were real- '401(k), health, vision, and dental benefits'. Anyone can offer 401k without matching, medical without contributing to the premium.
- kevindong 7y agoAmazon publishes this page detailing the benefits + their per-paycheck costs [0]. The prices for the coverage received seem very reasonable. [0]: https://www.amazon.jobs/en/landing_pages/benefitsoverview-us https://www.amazon.jobs/en/landing_pages/benefitsoverview-us
- vadym909 7y agoAh ok- I stand corrected - the medical is pretty reasonable. The 401k match takes 3 years to vest.
- disambiguation 7y agoI'm curious what Amazon warehouse worker is going to take this deal when there's free state and federal government checks being dished out.
- TomMckenny 7y agoHave you quit your job to collect these allegedly easy to obtain checks? Or is this character flaw exclusive to warehouse workers?
- wutbrodo 7y agoObviously you wouldn't quit your job if it pays a lot higher than the new unemployment payouts, and/or if you can easily work from home...and nobody but you is claiming that it's a character flaw to choose not to risk your life working if you have the safety net to avoid doing so. This is a really bizarre, immature reaction to a discussion of the incentives trade-off at play here.
- TomMckenny 7y agoI'm not addressing the extremely wise decision that a government make it financially possible for people not to spread disease. Nor disputing that the vast majority of people are willing to do this under these extreme circumstance. I'm addressing the assumption, wrapped in theories about incentives, that everyone (strangely except any persons expounding the theory) is eager to quit work for "welfare" at the first opportunity. And, by extension, that this is why there must never be a social safety net that can keep anyone alive. Because, according to this demonstrably false theory, society would collapse. People do not quit their jobs to receive handouts exactly because of their principles and because they are not the cynical robots that theoreticians make them out to be. Corporations may maximize wealth regardless of harm to society or others but the vast majority of natural persons don't.
- wutbrodo 7y ago> I'm addressing the assumption, wrapped in theories about incentives, that everyone (strangely except any persons expounding the theory) is eager to quit work for "welfare" at the first opportunity Again, the GP comment didn't say or imply anything like this. You're just accusing random commenters of irrelevant thoughtcrime based on trying to fit into every square peg into the round hole of the same vacuous political gamesmanship that dominates most conversations that touch on the economy. Paying attention to incentives doesn't at all imply that you think it's a moral failing for someone to follow incentives. In fact, I'd imagine that it's quite the opposite: people who get hysterical at the sight of rational, apolitical discussion are infinitely more likely to weight descriptions of incentives with moral dimensions that they don't have or need. This is what it looks like when people are actually interested in trying to understand the economic situation, without immediately having to snap into us-vs-them political gamesmanship. HN isn't perfect, but it's at least better than that; Go to /r/politics or something if that's what you're interested in.
- ggm 7y agoRapid surges in hiring are often accompanied by harder negotiation stances in pay and condtions since new hires have not had time to socialise or organise and hence unionise. Bezos is notoriously opposed to organised labour. I think this surge implies a fight, and a long one.
- wasdfff 7y agoNo one getting hired to work in an amazon warehouse is negotiating anything beyond what shifts they will be picking up.
- ggm 7y agoOnce you have an established contract and term of employment, organising for better working conditions is the next step. Or perhaps your preference is a perpetual marginalised and casual workforce?
- ineedasername 7y agoAre you eligible for unemployment on such a leave? Also, I don't fault Amazon for limiting paid-leave if the worker isn't sick, but it's only reasonable to ask people to come in if they are given decent PPE. Temperature checks are insufficient for a virus that may have a large # of asymptomatic carriers and a lengthy pre-symptomatic period for many that get sick.
- say_it_as_it_is 7y agoCannot trust Bloomberg Media to report facts.