3 ms·
There are risk pools for lending because every business has a different cut off point below which a borrower is considered too risky and therefore gets rejected
by imtringued 7y ago
There are risk pools for lending because every business has a different cut off point below which a borrower is considered too risky and therefore gets rejected. Imagine you are a bank employee at Bank A with very low default rates and consequently low interest rates (say 2.5%) and a homeless man has an appointment with you because he wants a small loan of $5000 to find an apartment and a job. He has no assets or income and is only able to pay after getting his job so he will miss his first few payments. Therefore you decide to simply not give him a loan because it is incredibly obvious that he is going to default.
What are his options now? He can go to a Bank B that accepts more risky borrowers with a still acceptable but slightly higher interest rate of 5%. What happens is that all the reliable lenders go to Bank A because they get a great deal there and have no trouble getting a loan. They don't even bother with Bank B. Since Bank B fails to attract reliable lenders the only borrowers at Bank B are those who couldn't get a loan at Bank A. Bank B now has two choices. Either keep the risk profile or tighten it and only allow reliable lenders. If they keep it then they will notice a much higher than usual default rate. Bank B is losing money from all the defaulting loans and that money has to come from the borrowers of Bank B that didn't default.
Now imagine that there is a Bank C. What if it's risk profile is so lenient that it accepts anyone with no questions asked. Literally everyone who comes to you is defaulting. You're throwing money into a black hole with no chance of getting it back. You have to crank up the interest rate to absurd levels to cover the defaults.
You know what the problem is? It's not that Bank C is evil and exploiting the poor. Those people should have never gotten a loan at all. The act of giving them a loan is exploitation itself, not the interest rate or whatever conditions that Bank C needs to stay in business. It's as simple as that. Those individuals do not need a loan, they need support from the government in a way that doesn't require the money to be paid back. e.g. free housing, unemployment benefits or even straight up UBI.
Don't criticize Banks for not lending to those who need it most. For some reason people don't understand that Banks are businesses that have to at least cover their costs. They think a Bank is a charity that should take on responsibilities that really only belong to the government.
- gindely 7y agoBut now you have just portrayed situations in which banks provide affordable loans to people who don't need them, and unaffordable loans to people who need them. But this is what was criticised in the first place so we know it happens. So I'm not sure what the point of your first four paragraphs were. Your final paragraph is exactly what my earlier comment rejects. The general public has every right to criticise banks for acting in the banks' private interest. Banks are not charities, it is true. But they are groups of moral agents acting in a community, and the community has every right to hold the moral agents to whatever standards the community wishes to. The bank has the legal right to pursue its own private interests, so long as it acts legally, and has the legal right to not act as a charity. But that is not an argument against the view that the bank should act in conformance with community expectations, and if necessary the law should be changed to ensure that they do. The fact that banks make ridiculous profits - they're not just covering costs - is also relevant. If your business is making billion dollar profits, you're vulnerable to the claim that you should give greater weight to public opinion, and the notion that you're only acting to cover costs is a red herring.
- Spooky23 7y agoYour story makes sense for consumer loans and credit cards. For mortgages, not so much as the underwriting bank holds almost zero risk.