19 ms·
'Insect apocalypse' more complicated than thought
- fiblye 7y agoThis article says freshwater insects are increasing, but doesn't really specify which ones aside from mayflies. I'm assuming one of them, if not the main group, is mosquitoes.
- dao- 7y ago> The scientists say there is no smoking gun on insect declines but they find the destruction of natural habitats due to urbanisation, to be key. Urbanization, i.e. people moving to larger cities? This doesn't seem to make sense and is inconsistent with every other report I read on this topic pointing out habitat loss and pollution from farming. I guess modern intensive farming methods correlate with small farmers moving away in favor of big industrial farmers, but concluding that urbanization kills natural habitats seems like a gross misrepresentation. Industrial farming can and should be reformed to weigh less heavily on nature without reversing urbanization.
- fvdessen 7y agoI think part of it is also the upper middle class moving out of larger cities, and buying a house with a big garden in the countryside, and then turning the garden into a sterile architectural monument.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoSure, but when you say upper middle class I think - that must be a small portion of the population and thus not likely to be significant to causing a problem of this magnitude.
- fvdessen 7y agoIt is a small proportion of the population (5-10%) but it has a disproportionate effect because they take up the space that previously remained wild because too impractical to farm, and there was not that much of it.
- hutzlibu 7y agoWhat I increasingly observe in europe, is the opposite: diverse gardens with different flowers, bushes and trees. The sterile garden type still exists, but has gotten very uncommon. And I have seen lots of europe in the last years. So it is really cheap, to target garden owning people, when you have large areas with monoculture and insect poison everywhere.
- fvdessen 7y agoThose gardens with pretty flowers and bushes are not the natural habitat of the insects. They look diverse but are in fact as sterile as a monoculture field. Insects thrive in the unkempt parcels between fields where man never goes, and those are disappearing, replaced by well kept gardens.
- hutzlibu 7y agoIt depends. There exist the diverse looking, but sterile garden type (who do use pesticides and insectizides of all sorts to keep it sterile). But this is increasingly changing. All the garden magazines are full of it, how to make your garden more insect friendly, insect hotels, leave patches of grass uncut, flowers that have nectar for insects and not just pretty flowers. And people follow it, since years, as far as I experienced. But even the most sterile looking garden with bushes and trees is far more insect friendly, than a dead field. Because tons of insects are living in the bushes and trees alone. A big tree can feed colonies of bees, when blooming, etc. But I am of course also with you, that the fields need to get more small, with bushes between them and if possible, organic.
- 11235813213455 7y agoThere are both kinds, some are obsessed with over-pruning/mutilating trees and mowing the garden like a golf green (another heresy), some let the nature develop. For example, France has many extended private areas, with forests
- hutzlibu 7y agoBtw. insects love deadwood. But yeah, most gardeners do not .. which is alright with me to remove, if it is a hazard in a tree, but deadwood lying in a bush could be tolerable.
- erpellan 7y agoMeanwhile the pesticide manufacturers are following the cigarette company playbook and busily funding bullshit research and top notch PR to deflect blame. This is what happens. We blanket our fields and their surroundings with chemicals specifically designed to highly efficiently kill insects and are surprised when insects die in droves. But sure, blame people living in cities.
- mikorym 7y agoBut keep in mind that pesticides (in the correct quantities) are crucial for high yields, whereas I am not sure whether tobacco is crucial for anything.
- bad_user 7y agoIndeed, I see plenty of criticism of industrial farming practices, but it's what's feeding the world population and without alternatives that are as efficient as current practices, the suggestion to give up pesticides is akin to saying that it's OK for people to die of hunger, as long as it ain't you. On the other hand denying a problem delays working on a solution.
- erpellan 7y agoSomething like 70% of farming is growing crops to feed animals which we then eat. Meat is an incredibly inefficient way to turn sunlight and water into calories. If we all switched away from meat and ate mostly plants instead we’d have more than enough without needing such intensive farming methods. More seriously than that though, current methods are actively destructive to the soil - the longer we farm so intensively the less viable farmland we will have. Does that sound sustainable?
- sleepygardener 7y agoIf this is all true, I wonder why a kg of pepper/cucumber (or any other vegetable for that matter) costs very close to a kg of chicken/pork etc. Shouldn't the additional complexity/resource intensiveness of meat production be reflected in the consumer price?
- 29athrowaway 7y agoEvery 61 years, world population doubles. That rate will slow down but population will still keep increasing. More humans = more habitat loss for other species.
- sgt101 7y agoI don't think that this is going to be true. I think it is pretty clear that population is going to fall from mid century on. It may fall very fast at the tail end of this century the current crop of young adults die. It looks like real fertility rates (the actual incidence of people having babies has fallen and continues to fall).
- drclau 7y agoCan you provide some data to support this? I’m genuinely interested.
- rb808 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_dependencies_by_total_fertility_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_d... Still many countries are >2 but they're falling rapidly too. Its surprising to me to see Bangladesh at 2.1 and India at 2.2. Places like S Korea 1.1, Italy 1.3, Japan 1.4 you can do the math yourself. (1.3/2)^N means without immigration their populations nearly disappear in 100 years. Russia 1.6, China 1.6, Thailand 1.5 takes maybe 12 generations to do the same.
- nfc 7y agoI think if what we are discussing is population growth we should talk about the global data not that of individual countries. Whether some countries population is increasing or not is a different question. I looked at this source https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate which seems to imply that globally the number of children per woman is 2.5 so still much higher than the replacement rate (of course we'd have to talk about more than fertility rate to have a real discussion). As far as I understand the projections about population stabilization are based on predictions of a reduction of children per woman in countries where this is still very high. It's possible that these predictions are right but they are just that, predictions. As an aside, I think we should dedicate a bit more effort to try to understand the implications of both possibilities and a bit less to try to assert as certain what is just a prediction. This is not obviously not only a reply to the parent's point, I just found myself writing a longer reply than expected ;)
- MrJagil 7y agoInsect hotels are becoming quite the thing here in Denmark, to the point that my local grocery store carries smaller versions. I think it's a very sweet and compassionate idea that kids can learn from and have fun with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insect_hotel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insect_hotel
- 11235813213455 7y agoI've seen insects coming back on my shirt while cycling since a few weeks, thanks to lockdown, and an amazing blossoming along roads, where it's usually dead-polluted. We need periodical lockdowns. The activity, traffic and pollution is way too intense in cities otherwise, not just for insects. We need to rethink air-traffic too (mainly as individual choices, because I don't see politics going against it), as someone living near an international airport, it's a massive change currently. Almost all if not all flights are unnecessary
- fit2rule 7y agoI am fortunate enough to live in an area where insects are still pretty common. Every summer and spring we are visited in our garden house by bees and wasps and butterflies, praying mantis and hovering moths - all variety of other things, beetles and bugs galore. Our kids have learned to keep bees safe and how to safely shepherd a wasp out the window. We delight in the butterflies visiting our noses, and even in the last week witnessed our pear and cherry trees turn from flower to fruit bud with a little help from our friends. Then there was a time I witnessed a mantis defending my outdoor shoe from my foot, only to discover its egg sac deeply embedded in the shoes depths, which I of course left alone until a thousand critters made their way into our garden. It's hard to imagine there are places in the world were such delights are not so easily experienced. I believe the modern world has done us all a disservice by breeding squeamish generations incapable of holding such critters in their hand, in wonder. If you're a parent, teach yer kids to love bugs - with respect of course, we have not much use for ticks - and encourage experiments which show the world of insects and their life cycles to future generations.
- raarts 7y agoSeems wind turbines contribute significantly to this. Germany also happens to be one of the most active countries in investing in them. https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/06/26/why-wind-turbines-threaten-endangered-species-with-extinction/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/06/26...