9 ms·
This is how all news media operated before the internet created mouthpieces for non-professionals. In addition to suppressing some inconvenient truths they filt
by kevin_thibedeau 7y ago
This is how all news media operated before the internet created mouthpieces for non-professionals. In addition to suppressing some inconvenient truths they filtered out crackpot ideas that have become a plague in modern times.
- etangent 7y agoThis comment has so much elitism in it I can smell the grey poupon from across the wire.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoYou're right. We're so much better off when a significant segment of the population believes that the Secretary of State is pimping out children from a pizza restaurant.
- logicchains 7y agoYes, because the idea of rich, influential men pimping out children in modern America is simply unthinkable and certainly hasn't happened recently. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeffrey_Epstein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeffrey_Epstein
- labster 7y agoThe Secretary in question is a woman. Don’t just assume all secretaries are men, that’s sexist.
- pjc50 7y agoThe conspiracy theory stuff is seemingly always exactly wrong about this. Not only does it magnify unsubstantiated allegations, it often helps suppress the genuine ones; look at how badly the Weinstein accusers have been treated.
- raz32dust 7y agoThis is a well-known issue, but what is your solution? Ban internet and go back to the 90s? It's pointless to gripe about this without a good alternative.
- sintaxi 7y agoCorrect. That has has fewer downsides than truth being decided for the public.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- manigandham 7y agoWhat exactly qualifies someone to be a "professional" who is allowed to speak? The vast majority of content I watch on Youtube is produced by independent creators covering a variety of topics with much more detail, expertise, and truth than any mainstream program.
- cle 7y agoThere isn’t “qualified” and “unqualified”. It’s not that black-and-white, and I wish people would accept that more. Basically what we should be asking ourselves is “What’s the likelihood that what this person is telling me is correct?” which is much more useful, because it immediately puts the focus on what factors contribute to that. We aren’t going to conclude anything useful until we can agree that there are good and bad tradeoffs between central information control and decentralized, and that the optimum at any given point in time probably lies somewhere in between and depends on the context in which the communication takes place.
- chrstphrhrt 7y agoMakes total sense. The black and white thing always seemed so weird. It's a false dichotomy. Even if censorship is good in the particular context (which seems to be the case here), but bad in general and bad in principle, it seems that the real issue is that there should be one unaccountable entity who gets to make that decision. Why is Youtube big enough to have such an impact without being accountable in any way to the public?
- aantthony 7y agoIt's not just Youtube, it's also Twitter[1] and Facebook[2]. When they all act in concert with each other, it's much harder to hold them accountable. I think censorship can be dangerous in this context so I'm working on a decentralised fact-checker. I think it could be a more constructive solution to fake news that isn't subject to these problems: https://blog.verifact.io/2020/04/20/A-decentralised-fact-checker/ https://blog.verifact.io/2020/04/20/A-decentralised-fact-che... [1] https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/covid-19.html#definition https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/covid-19.... [2] https://nypost.com/2020/04/17/facebook-fact-checkers-foul-again-after-censoring-post-story/ https://nypost.com/2020/04/17/facebook-fact-checkers-foul-ag...
- maximente 7y agoyou mean like the NYT's Judith Miller, ostensibly a professional, who sabre rattled for the 2nd iraq war based on aluminum tubes which .gov leadership immediately cited after being published? because that was fairly crackpotty.
- Phanyxx 7y agoI'm not saying your example is wrong, but the fact that it's from nearly 20 years ago is very telling. Even the most credible of sources will get something very wrong on occasion.
- serf 7y ago>I'm not saying your example is wrong, but the fact that it's from nearly 20 years ago is very telling. telling in what way? This behavior hasn't really slowed down, and was persistent through the Obama administration, too. Many, including myself, feel as if that behavior is par for the course with regards to NYT. Chomsky refers to it as the NYT's special role of 'creating history'[0]. That's why they have some strange ability to be cited realistically by serious people, even when they're entirely wrong about something. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsiBl2CaDFg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsiBl2CaDFg
- toomanyrichies 7y agoI think what's needed is a measurement of how many times a source was later proven to be wrong, and then issued a correction to state as much. Or even better, a percentage comparing the # of times they got wrong with the percentage of times they admitted as much. A sort of "batting average" for admitting their mistakes. All sources will get it wrong from time to time. A reporter's primary loyalty should be to the truth, regardless of whether it aligns with their pre-conceived notions. Coming up with a way to quantify that loyalty would be a service to society.
- donw 7y agoWe also need to track exactly how loud those corrections are published. Calling out "hey, we totally got this one wrong, and here's why" even "louder" than original prediction is great. This is how you earn trust. Quietly publishing a correction on the metaphorical back page? Nope. Not even close. Silently changing the article after the fact? Oh hell no. Go directly to credibility jail, do not pass Go, do not collect $200.
- specialist 7y agoPreserving the status quo by functioning as both a high pass and low pass filter. For both better and worse.
- flukus 7y agoBefore the web was in every house we had professional media often pushing crackpot theories and news agents had a whole section of monthly crackpot magazines, one of mine had them right next to the comic section to get picked up by impressionable young people. Long before all this "5g causes corona virus" in the early 90's my local paper would often have stories about cell phones causing cancer. Long before "china to blame for coronavirus" we had "legitimate" media pushing the link between Iraq and 911. Long before any WHO was at the center of conspiracy theories the UN was. Let's not even go into things like current affairs shows and fox news. The internet may have made you more aware of the amount of crazy out there, but it was always there.
- smsm42 7y ago> crackpot ideas that have become a plague in modern times. It's especially fascinating to read this after we have literal viral pandemic, about which WHO told us it's not transmissible human to human, government told us go and enjoy restaurants and parades, CDC banned third-party tests and then completely bungled their own tests, same CDC advised people not to wear masks, and so on, and so on... yeah sure, "crackpot ideas" have become a plague. That's where the problem is. I am sitting a month in a quarantine while watching the economy slowly turning to dust - because some crackpot dude made a video about his ideas on Youtube, right?
- posterboy 7y agohahaha no, word of mouf always existed. It just found new channels
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago> In addition to suppressing some inconvenient truths they filtered out crackpot ideas that have become a plague in modern times. Every idea starts out as some fringe crackpot idea relative to the status quo. Government recognized marriage of a same sex couple comes to mind as a recent example. Some ideas (e.g. "the general public should wear a mask in public to reduce the spread of coronavirus") make it from crazy to accepted faster than others.