5 ms·
If this study is accurate, and is not just working on garbage data, and if these antibodies actually mean long-term immunity, this means one of two things: 1.
by vkou 7y ago
If this study is accurate, and is not just working on garbage data, and if these antibodies actually mean long-term immunity, this means one of two things:
1. If the lockdown is lifted, we will see another ~60,000 to 100,000 deaths in NYC, before it will hit herd immunity.
2. Or, the lockdown will continue.
The accuracy of antibody studies has been called into doubt, and as far as I know, nobody has ever followed up on whether or not people with study-detected antibodies can catch the virus. The data for the latter is unlikely to be available until the second wave hits.
- grey-area 7y agoThat would be a very useful follow up study with this same population.
- CubsFan1060 7y agoThere is no reason why an all or none approach is necessary here, is there? By my count, 10,120/15,740 of deaths have been folks over 70. If you kept people over 70 locked down (including their caretakers), you could significantly reduce the number of deaths while increasing the percentage that have had it. In fact, only 9% of New York's population is over 70. So theoretically (though clearly not practically), you could get over the percentage required for herd immunity while reducing the deaths by 66%
- joe_maley 7y ago> if these antibodies actually mean long-term immunity This is the big unknown that seems to be largely ignored, thank you for bringing it up. I am frequently seeing "herd immunity" thrown around without any qualification on the durability of the associated antibodies.
- DeonPenny 7y agoWe'd also need to make the decsision to continue a lockdown over a virus with a 99.5% survival rate or not. Seeing at the flu has a 99.9% survival rate does it make sense to destroy the economy over that.
- tunesmith 7y agoHospitalization rates per infection are greater for covid than for flu. What matters is hospital capacity, to protect against greater non-covid death rates.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI agree, but this is not universally believed. Many people argue that hospital capacity is not what matters, and we must continue lockdowns even if hospitals won't be overloaded to eradicate the disease.
- tunesmith 7y agoAh, yeah. If hospitals are fine, I think lockdowns can be swapped for a contact tracing system, assuming enough people use it and assuming easy test access and 24-hour test turnarounds. (And even then... use masks.) But, in the absence of that, if a hospital is at 50% capacity, I don't agree with opening up a lockdown until a hospital gets to 95% capacity. (The game changes entirely if we get a good anti-viral.)
- DeonPenny 7y agoBut if that held then we'd eradicate flu and the common cold two. Quarantines don't eradicate disease they slow the spread but the area under the curve is constant. I doubt will change the number of infected is a constant regardless of the rate.
- tunesmith 7y agoThat's only true if medical and technological advancements don't happen. A vaccine a year from now means less death if we've locked down in the meantime, compared to if we haven't locked down. Similarly, if we scale up testing and contact tracing to the point we can eventually eradicate the disease through targeted quarantines, a preceding lockdown means less death. If instead we don't experience any advancements, then right, it just means the same number of infections are spread out over a longer period of time.
- djrogers 7y agoThe purpose of the lockdown isn't to hide until the virus magically disappears, it's to flatten the curve and allow the virus to spread slowly enough that it doesn't overwhelm the healthcare system in any given place. Maintaining a lockdown will not lower the number of people who get the virus, it will merely extend how long it takes to get there.
- lbeltrame 7y agoAt least if you heard the statements of my government (Italy) from a couple weeks ago, they were hoping (or so the press said) to "reduce infections to zero". Since then, quite obviously, they backtracked from those statements.
- legulere 7y agoFlattening the curve until there is a vaccine might be the right plan for a influenza pandemic. For COVID-19 we can go further: we can bring down infection rates so much that contact tracing becomes feasible again.
- usaar333 7y agoMatters where you are. The Bay Area is keeping their lockdown up so they can contact trace and crush any infection spike. Otherwise, we're going to be locked down until a vaccine at the current new case rates.