5 ms·
Which constitutional requirements do you think are being violated? And if you're going to say first amendment, be sure to explain precisely why they wouldn't su
by jcranmer 7y ago
Which constitutional requirements do you think are being violated? And if you're going to say first amendment, be sure to explain precisely why they wouldn't survive strict scrutiny. (And if you're not aware of the legal meaning of "strict scrutiny," then you are probably ignorant of what the Constitution has actually been held to mean by the authority that has the power to interpret it.)
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoControlling a pandemic is certainly a compelling interest, but as far as I know no government has attempted to show that a general closure of businesses and churches is the least restrictive means that will achieve it. Many acknowledge that there are less restrictive means, and have a medium-term plan to move to those lesser restrictions, but say we shouldn't explore them right now because it's too dangerous.
- tptacek 7y agoThe authority of the state to impose broad quarantines has a history in our jurisprudence going all the way back to John Marshall. See, for instance, Gibbons v Ogden.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y ago"Quarantine" historically refers to segregation of people or populations who've been exposed to a disease from the general public. The idea of a general quarantine, where everyone is segregated from everyone else, was as far as I can tell invented out of whole cloth a few months ago.
- tptacek 7y agoSince there are literally laws on the books in many states that explicitly delegate this power, for this precise purpose, "invented out of whole cloth a few months ago" seems an extraordinary claim. Find a credible source? When you do so, remember that the "lockdown" we're experiencing falls far short of a "general quarantine". You can in fact leave your house, and travel between states, free from pretty much any tracking or extra surveillance. Most of the police power being exercised falls under business regulation; where you're feeling the lockdown the most is likely in the fact that you have so few places to go right now. Because it's easy to find sources discussing the legal controversy of general quarantines. But you'll notice they're mostly talking about the due process concerns of doing the equivalent of imprisoning people without trials, not closing the bars.
- leereeves 7y agoClosing the bars, and the churches, gun stores, courthouses... This lockdown is infringing on pretty much all our Constitutional rights, across the board.
- tptacek 7y agoIt is if you assume your Constitutional rights are that that any citizen intuits from a casual reading of the Bill of Rights. It suffices in this context to point out that, if you're an American, you don't live in a country that operates on that principle; we've had centuries of jurisprudence that put the Bill of Rights into actual practice, and many of the principles routinely assumed to be violating the plain meaning of the amendments were established by the framers of those amendments. (Courts, for what it's worth, continue to function).
- leereeves 7y agoJury trials have been postponed all over the country. And we can't go 2 years without jury trials while waiting for a vaccine. We'll have to find less restrictive ways to coexist with this virus.
- tptacek 7y agoTrials are postponed when they can be. Hearings are being conducted remotely. Courts are open where they have to be. Habeas has not been suspended. Churches are an especially unpersuasive example of overreach, since several churches have been implicated in super-spreader events.
- leereeves 7y ago"When they can be" is a strange way to refer to a universal shutdown of all jury trials in many jurisdictions, such as: https://www.ktvu.com/news/justice-delayed-california-courts-cancel-postpone-hearings https://www.ktvu.com/news/justice-delayed-california-courts-... What was perhaps acceptable as a temporary emergency measure is not acceptable as the new normal. The current measures are overly restrictive and cannot continue for two years. And while I don't care about religion myself, I understand that religious people feel the same way about closing all churches for years. We'll also have to find less restrictive ways to control the virus while allowing the churches to reopen.
- leereeves 7y agoControlling a pandemic is a compelling state interest, but it would be hard to argue that current lockdown restrictions are narrowly tailored and use the least restrictive means possible, when other states and other nations have controlled the outbreak without lockdowns.