7 ms·
> because it's not easy to run your own software on an iPhone Then why do I need all this performance? Perhaps to run js on shitty websites. Well, maybe for ga
by fsflover 7y ago
> because it's not easy to run your own software on an iPhone
Then why do I need all this performance? Perhaps to run js on shitty websites. Well, maybe for gaming.
- godzillabrennus 7y agoNot that these Apple chips will run x86 or x64 code. Unless they bother with a Rosetta 2.0 then gaming is out of the question if Apple makes this jump.
- MrBuddyCasino 7y agoAren't apps already submitted as bitcode? They don't have to emulate, just recompile.
- nagisa 7y agoLLVM Bitcode is still architecture specific. That is, bitcode generated targetting x86 is not compatible with bitcode targetting ARM is not compatible with bitcode targetting aarch. The reason they are distributed as bitcode is to enable additional optimisations based on what exact chip will run the code (i.e. -march=native equivalent)
- pascoej 7y agohttps://www.highcaffeinecontent.com/blog/20190518-Translating-an-ARM-iOS-App-to-Intel-macOS-Using-Bitcode https://www.highcaffeinecontent.com/blog/20190518-Translatin... This article appears to successfully statically translate arm64 binary into an x86_64 binary using bitcode.
- imtringued 7y agoUsing LLVM IR merely solves the problem of being able to compile to a specific instruction. You still need a compatibility wrapper for all the platform specific APIs like wine or Windows on Windows. If Apple puts in the effort then it might work out.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoOn Mac? I don’t think so, no, because you can move App Store apps to different machines on USB keys. Also, a considerable number of Mac apps don’t use the App Store for distribution.
- ken 7y agoNo, the Mac compiler target has never supported bitcode. And LLVM bitcode doesn’t work like that anyway.
- rsynnott 7y agoThe Catalina move already killed off a lot of games where the developers didn't provide an updated (x86_64) binary. A move to ARM would kill more, of course, but it's not like there's not precedent. I'm half-convinced that Apple killed 32bit support so early precisely to see how developers coped; if it had been really bad they could have re-introduced it in a point release of Catalina. As it was, it wasn't very bad and most developers complied, which is an argument in favour of an ARM transition being feasible. The only other reason I can think of to so aggressively move to 64bit is security, but most of the apps that were stuck on 32bit were not that big a security concern.
- _ph_ 7y agoYes, I think the true reason, that Catalina is so incompatible with old programs, is, that they wanted to have the big compatibility breaking before the announce the ARM transition, which then would look as not so much a big step.
- leemailll 7y agoThis does not make sense. I can give an counter-example for this: the education market, especially the higher-education market. This market exists so long and aged so well that, in real life, enterprise-level deployment of Macs well-likely exist mostly in this market now. The down-side for this market: they are slow or reluctant to change. Those ones who make research-related or educational software never are quick enough to do the big jump for an architecture change. And they also might not be able hire more people to do this. And the customer also hate to do those type of changes, both the IT department and the researchers, nobody wants to find their code couldn’t run properly anymore on these new machines.
- _ph_ 7y agoBut that is already true. You cannot buy a mac any more which runs 32 bit software. So Apple is obviously willing to make things miserable for a considerably part of their user base. Me included. I will avoid anything with Catalina, because I still have a very few 32bit programs I want to run and can't upgrade. As long as macOS runs on x86 hardware, there is not much justification for such a break. Yes, they clean up the software stack, but at a very high price. The only good reason I can imagine is, that when Tim Cook announces macOS on ARM, he will claim "runs everything that runs on Catalina".
- yoz 7y agoHave you looked at the iOS App Store lately? There are tens of thousands of games there. Apple Arcade has a small (100+) but well-curated selection of good games that run on both iOS and MacOS. Oh, you meant PC games? Sure, the Mac only has a small percentage of (for example) Steam games, but that percentage is steadily rising - it's now over 25%. Switching architecture is unlikely to present a major problem for most developers, especially given that they're probably using Unity or Unreal Engine.
- DeathArrow 7y ago>Switching architecture is unlikely to present a major problem for most developers, especially given that they're probably using Unity or Unreal Engine. As a former game developer I can tell you that that is an issue. Apple is totally against using cross platform tools. They break compatibility as much as they can. Framework change, architecture change and so on. Instead of going with OpenGL ES, Vulkan, OpenCL they made Metal. If user base is large enough, as is the case with iOS, there's an incentive to go trough the pains of releasing for that platform. But that isn't the case with macOS. Maybe for Adobe is worth it to spend resources to build software for macOS, but for other companies that might not be the case. Anyway, you make much more money by targeting Play station and Xbox, and the resources needed are the same in money and man hours so it kame sense to target macOS last, if ever. And no, not everybody is using Unity and Unreal. That is true mostly for indies.
- TallGuyShort 7y agoA lot of people who don't need it already buy it for the image and social status. Apple doing this for workstation-type machines too just makes even more sense.
- rooam-dev 7y agoA more future proof too.
- rsynnott 7y agoThe extreme slowness of the modern web honestly is a reason. I do a lot of my personal web browsing on an elderly (nearly 6 year old) iPad Air 2. For everything but the web, and for old websites, it's fine. For the "100MB of react crap" type of website, it's getting pretty painful, tho.
- rvense 7y agoMy personal laptop is a Lenovo X200s from 2008 or 2009 with 8GB RAM. I use it to write words, read PDFs, do some software development (most often C and "vanilla" web stuff), design electronics in Kicad, and casually browse the web... and I'd be happy with it as my only computing device forever, except for some websites it's starting to be a little slow, especially a well-known site that's meant for exchanging messages under 500 characters. There's some irony there.
- KozmoNau7 7y agoMine is an X220s, so slightly newer than yours, but still a modest i3, upgraded to 8GB RAM, 128GB SSD and dual-band WLAN. With a new 9-cell battery, I get ~6 hours of battery life, and it's fine for general browsing with a decent number of open tabs, even a few games (Darkest Dungeon and some emulated SNES games). As long as it keeps ticking and I can get whichever spare parts I need on eBay or something, I'm not going to replace it anytime soon. The only reason I have a more powerful desktop PC (still ~2011 vintage) and don't just use the X220s in a dock, is that it it struggles with a 1440p external monitor (full HD is fine, though) and I sometimes like to play more graphically intense games.
- DeathArrow 7y ago>As long as it keeps ticking and I can get whichever spare parts I need on eBay or something, I'm not going to replace it anytime soon. Good luck with that as the Javascript crowd are in competition to slow the web as much as they can.
- KozmoNau7 7y ago
- mumblemumble 7y agoAlternatively, when you don't need to be running full throttle, you get better battery life. Which any consumer will appreciate. And is also perhaps an environmental win, if it allows them to get away with smaller batteries. That said, the experience of trying to browse a local newspaper's website with NoScript turned off on my 2015 MacBook Pro tells me that, yes, JS on shitty websites is a problem. And not one that most people would find to be particularly avoidable. Heck, even GMail is getting to be noticeably slow on that computer.
- papermachete 7y agoOr run virtual machines like Android users do.