5 ms·
Is there some reason to think Cuban has some useful thoughts here? He has done well for himself but he seems more than willing to make quips well outside of hi
by duxup 7y ago
Is there some reason to think Cuban has some useful thoughts here?
He has done well for himself but he seems more than willing to make quips well outside of his knowledge base. Specifically I'm thinking of some off the cuff tweets regarding personal healthcare that seemed to be pretty far off base.
Maybe that was a one off thing but I recall some others even regarding personal finance that seemed questionable.
- seppin 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect Same reason we ask Peter Thiel or Elon Musk their thoughts on AI or politics.
- mistermann 7y agoI generally have a positive opinion of Cuban, but it's not via that approach. Generally speaking, I've just liked most of what I've seen of him, and disliked very little. Plus, he seems willing to challenge the status quo, which I weight fairly heavily.
- nostromo 7y agoThiel and Musk have a track record of success though. Yes, they're lucky, but they also seem to be smart and capable. Cuban is a one-hit-wonder that sold a domain (and a dream) to Yahoo at the height of the dot com bubble. They don't seem particularly comparable. Edit: to respond to the comments below, no I'm not saying he's not successful, or that he's not smart. I'm only saying in tech and startup circles, he's no Thiel or Musk.
- holler 7y agoOn what basis is he a one-hit-wonder? Just because his endeavors didn’t progress to building rockets or big data ML for the gov, and instead to building a winning NBA team and one of most successful ongoing reality “startup” tv shows, he is somehow less-than?
- luckylion 7y agoI have no clue about the NBA, but yeah, I'd say being a part of a reality tv show isn't in the same league as building rockets to go to Mars. The Kardashians are in reality tv shows. They are not building rockets.
- groby_b 7y agoLet's just be clear that the reason SpaceX builds great rockets is... not exactly rooted in Musk. He was too busy sleeping on the Tesla production floor. If you want to look for the leaders there, Gwynne Shotwell & Tom Mueller is who should be on your radar.
- aaron-lebo 7y agoBoth of those guys have a track record of plowing more money into money, with their own failures. It's just sports, but winning a title isn't nothing, and if you've followed his sports career, he was big into advanced stats decently early and the Mavs are as good as anyone at finding diamonds in the rough. There's obviously Dirk and Doncic, but they were also really close on getting Giannis. That shows some kind of insight. Not to mention, small ball dominates the league today, but the Don Nelson Mavs were doing that in 2003. I know it is just sports, but sports are some of the most competitive domains in the world, with the ability to innovate, which he has done. I don't think HN's preference for tech should just ignore what he's accomplished. Don't forget, PG and YC are only what they are because Viaweb was purchased in the same wave as Broadcast. Neither of those companies matter today.
- seppin 7y ago> Thiel and Musk have a track record of success though. Yes, they're lucky, but they also seem to be smart and capable. Thinking someone has expertise in X therefore they are good source for analysis on Y is the logical fallacy I linked to above. Contrary to what silicon valley believes, there is no such thing as being "smart" in a general sense. You can be capable in certain things, maybe you are faster to learn in others. That doesn't mean any founder with a billion $ exit should be asked about public policy.
- vikramkr 7y agoAi sure, but I personally put as much stock into either of their opinions as I do Cubans, which is, about as much stock I'd give to the opinion of any other reasonably smart person. Nothing special, because it's out of their domain of expertise. Nobody is an expert on "politics" in general. Some people are experts in running campaigns. Some people are experts in Keynesian economic theory. Some people are experts in healthcare. Some are experts in getting legislation passed and in understanding the machinations of power in Congress. Some are good executives able to hold together a broad set of options and make good calls. Nobody is an expert in all aspects of "politics"
- crispyambulance 7y ago> Is there some reason to think Cuban has some useful thoughts here? He's wetting his feet, it seems, for some political aspirations. I mean, hit TV show + billionaire + massive ego + mis-informed? opinion on everything ==> presidential material, right? Kind of tired of seeing his face and hearing his voice, but somehow I suspect we'll see more and more of it.
- aaron-lebo 7y agoCubes has always been outspoken. He's been almost as publicly known for 20 years and certainly winning the title in 2011 gave him more prestige. He'd make a decent candidate though. He's a Democrat (I guess he could run as a Republican, too) from the South with a bigger built-in fanbase than anyone else mentioned in this comment thread. He's run his organization for a long time with advanced stats, so he's no dinosaur. He's Jewish (if that matters, but it's nice having more diversity). Seemingly very healthy and relatively young, and no existing political career so he can cast himself as a ... maverick. He's made a number of missteps, but he's also pretty good at turning those to his advantage. He's a minor god here in Dallas. If we're in an era where popularity/money is what wins elections, I feel like you could do much worse than him, and I'd trust him way way more than Trump and feel like he'd have the potential for lots more interesting change than Biden.
- nostromo 7y agoHoward Schultz and Mike Bloomberg fell for this trap too, and it didn't turn out well for them. It must be difficult to get honest advice as a billionaire, because these guys seem to be quite uninformed about how unpopular they actually turn out to be in the political arena.
- aaron-lebo 7y agoI'm certain it is hard to get that advice, because it's pretty hard to get out of your own way, success certainly ain't going to make it easier. You're completely correct about both of those guys, but Bloomberg showed an incredibly lack of charisma in his run and Schultz is known, but I really think yall are underrating how popular Cuban is for common people. The ESPN demographic is a lot bigger than the HN techie demographic.
- itronitron 7y agoHe was an executive producer for the movie 'The Road' (a 2009 American post-apocalyptic survival film) so he at least has a passing interest in the topic.
- duxup 7y agoI'm not sure what that ... should mean.
- bhupy 7y ago> Is there some reason to think Cuban has some useful thoughts here? It seems to me that the most effective trait in a politician is strategic decision-making, capability of applying abstract thinking to different situations (which comes particularly handy during crises), and figuring out how to get the right people together and get them to cooperate. All of these also strike me as traits in executives and effective managers, which is likely why we tend to organically gravitate towards them in politics. Whether Cuban can be regarded as an effective executive is debatable, I have no opinion on that.
- vkou 7y agoThe problem is that it is hard to differentiate between lucky idiots who failed upwards, and actually capable executives, who know when to defer to expertise. Executives are judged on results - which are heavily influenced by circumstances that can be entirely outside the executive's control.
- bhupy 7y ago> Executives are judged on results - which are heavily influenced by circumstances that can be entirely outside the executive's control. The exact same can be said for most politicians as well.
- adventured 7y ago> Is there some reason to think Cuban has some useful thoughts here? Sure. He has invested into hundreds of businesses of every size spanning two decades. He has intimate experience with the operations of small and large size businesses of most every type, along with their operating requirements in all regards. A huge part of the recovery is getting small, medium, large businesses all back to functioning properly. From his perch, he sees a lot of what's going on at multiple levels. He is one of the couple hundred prominent business persons selected for Trump's recovery advisory council. He knows his stuff and he keeps close tabs on all of his investments (and the broader economic environment), which is remarkable given the expanded scope of his activities. I've done business with Mark in the past and can vouch for all of this personally. People often have wide-ranging responses to him based on his outsized personality, however he is very sharp, he's a smart guy and understands business at a high level of competency. People that dig on him by saying he's just a lucky dotcom billionaire, don't actually know him. edit: so let's hear your retort, downvote brigade. I'm probably one of the only people in this thread qualified to speak to the actual question the parent posed, as I have years of experience being in business with Cuban. I know how he operates and how he deals with businesses. Everybody else here is talking out of their ass.
- qaq 7y agoafter SV can't take him seriously at all just see Russ Hanneman
- thephyber 7y agoI've been reading his posts on LinkedIn. He seems to be advocating for businesses to treat their employees loyally now or fear the social backlash (reputation hit) when we come out of crisis. I have no idea about his previous tweets and I'm not sure I care.
- duxup 7y agoI'm always wary of "treat your employees well" talk from big names as I think that is as much about self promotion as it is anything else. Much like the lifestyle type 'careers section' on a lot of company sites ;)
- muh_gradle 7y agoCuban is an ok guy, but the healthcare comments are a good example of him being plain wrong. https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/tv/2019/11/04/shark-tank-doctor-virus-fighting-pack-isnt-immune-criticism/4151858002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/tv/2019/11/04/s... This is an example of him arguing with a MD. Cuban takes an issue with the doctor stating that consumer driven health care from non medical professionals is responsible for overuse of antibiotics. Cuban gets heated and dismisses the doctor as a quack when the doctor makes a completely legitimate point. Mark Cuban, like all successful people in life, is great at providing a loud opinion on everything and especially with areas that aren't his expertise.
- duxup 7y agoI don't even think that was the health related comment by Cuban I was thinking of... but man what a cluster of a scene that sounds like.
- leereeves 7y ago> consumer driven health care from non medical professionals is responsible for overuse of antibiotics That sounds like there are no medical professionals involved, but aren't medical professionals prescribing the antibiotics?
- untog 7y agoI'm not an expert here but I believe the argument is that because it's consumer driven if a patient wants antibiotics then they can just shop around doctors until they find one willing to prescribe. Plus of course, drug manufacturers aggressively pitching their product to doctors.
- tboyd47 7y agoHe always does this on Shark Tank too. Guy has some kind of issue with doctors.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThe "MD" was a guy on Shark Tank asking for an investment in his vitamin supplement company.
- creaghpatr 7y agoUseful is debatable, but his comments are relevant since he's on the federal task force for reopening the economy.
- groby_b 7y agoIsn't everybody and the kitchen sink on that task force? Ah, yes,here we go, 200+ people: https://www.axios.com/white-house-reopen-america-task-fore-868d9192-ce91-4aae-8794-ec52b9d11fda.html https://www.axios.com/white-house-reopen-america-task-fore-8... (Which means it's a no-op. No group of 200 people is able to move at any kind of speed)
- busymom0 7y agoHow is that "kitchen sink"? The list consists of CEOs of many companies from different states and senators. Since each state is impacted differently and some are in better/worse situation than others, every company's opinion matters. There are also CEOs/business people from different venues like restaurants, NBA, NFL, UFC, Disney and other parks, bars etc. I think 200 might be too low. 200 divided by 50 states is around 4 per state.
- woobity 7y agoIs there some reason to think that Altman has any useful insight here? Really. And people are calling out Cuban as being a one hit wonder. Altman doesn't even have that, Path was an abject failure. He's just been appointed to his roost by the SV overlords.
- darepublic 7y agoThe presence of Cuban helps me to feel more at ease with the state of the world.. if celebrities I recognize seem to be okay with what is happening what do I have to fear?
- busymom0 7y agoNot sure about usefulness but it's worth mentioning that he has been hinting at running for President in a lot of his recent TV appearances.
- sixQuarks 7y agoHe'd be better than someone with Dementia. So at least he's got that going for him.