7 ms·
I can only assume but culture makes things very different. I often said that French abstract algebra books stopped me from learning for 10 years (after many ser
by agumonkey 7y ago
I can only assume but culture makes things very different. I often said that French abstract algebra books stopped me from learning for 10 years (after many serious attempts). One book from Garreth Williams unlocked 80% of my issues. The shocking part was the approach. It was very operational, you calculate, you manipulate concrete data. In French books it's all theorems and concepts. Learning curve to make a Haskeller faint. And that book is not the only instance, Gilbert Strang lectures on youtube are also similar in style. It also correlates with the pragmatic engineering of US history (electricity comes to mind).
- ngold 7y agoThank's for the insight. I struggled with geography until I discovered history...again, after high school of course. I still struggle with algebra, so I look forward to checking your suggestions out. I think my problem as a kid was I was just hyper, all the time. I could cut wood outside for 10 hours but couldn't sit still for a moment.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoChild labour is an untapped resource. If it were somehow possible to let kids chop wood for 10hrs, as the need arose, or whatever, and then they could go / go back to school when they were ready. Certainly would have helped me a lot.
- zozbot234 7y agoAgreed. There is a severe lack of mindfulness and focus in modern education, and strenuous physical exercise like chopping wood can be a real mindfulness-workout.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> I struggled with geography until I discovered history Tangentially, a lot of fantasy authors seem to love maps for their own sake, and provide maps of their world as illustrations. I never saw the point of these; the map never really matters to the story. But history books provide almost the same number of maps -- usually one, before the discussion of whatever -- and it just isn't enough. Those maps really matter to understanding whatever was going on; in the real world, geography is a huge deal.
- ken 7y agoMy favorite sequence of maps in a book was “Black Hawk Down”. The first chapter begins with a world map, showing Somalia, and it lays the geopolitical setting for the events. The second chapter has a map of Somalia, showing where Mogadishu is, and sets the scene there. It keeps zooming in, until the final chapter shows a map so tight it has individual people (who you have since met) and which side of the street they were on.
- grawprog 7y ago>the map never really matters to the story. It's more about deepening the story I think and making it 'bigger' I guess or another type of story telling. You look at a fantasy map and there's typically places on the map not even mentioned in the actual story as you say, but that helps build the setting. Look at the map for the lord of the rings for example. A good number of the places in that map are barely mentioned in the actual trilogy. Yet that map's become one of the most iconic in fantasy in general. It's more about what the maps inspire in your imagination while you read. When some random fantasy city name gets mentioned, you can look at the map and get perspective about where it is in the world. It's also helpful I think to keep the world consistent for authors. It gives them a frame of reference for scale and distance in their stories and likely helps keep track of all the random names and cultures and such that they make up for their stories.
- readwind 7y agoImagine if the lord of the rings' world was like when we were still conquering and exploring all around, and then some dude, tolkien's lost brother, or something, twin, perhaps, with co-systemic minds, mapped out the unmentioned parts, and then you could just span the two things together. Fun times and theories co-bro. Anyways.
- chii 7y ago> It was very operational, you calculate, you manipulate concrete data it's interesting that some academic approaches focus on the theoretical framework and conceptual depth, with the underlying assumption that the student would "get" it once the fundamentals are understood. The other approach, mostly in the asian schools, teach rote and speed in mechanical/mental manipulation. For example, a student would do 1000 quadratic equations, mostly by rote using substitution into the formula. That constitutes "teaching" of the quadratic equation. But in the end, who learned more? Not sure. But i do believe that being able to manipulate numbers very quickly leads to a quality of its own, and can make understanding harder concepts easier.
- gruez 7y ago>But i do believe that being able to manipulate numbers very quickly leads to a quality of its own, and can make understanding harder concepts easier. Can you elaborate on this? Are you supposed to introspect while you're applying the quadratic formua 1000 times? How does being able to quickly add/subtract/multiply/divide help you better understand abstract concepts?
- Pxtl 7y agoIn my experience, those rote mental muscles mean that the basics are never slowing you down when tackling a harder problem. It's comparable to having a perfectly organized toolbox vs a mess of tools in your shed - you can do the same things, but you're free to focus on the core of the current task instead of distractions in the trivial parts.
- wutbrodo 7y agoThis is precisely it. I have a math-heavy job and play/write music, and the same phenomenon plays out in both situations: when reading sheet music or thinking in music theory is in your muscle memory, your entire conscious mind can focus on the actual, creative task at hand. This should be obvious from any number of examples, from driving a car to typing as a programmer. Reducing the friction between your brain and your tools simply makes you more effective.
- tathougies 7y agoI dunno, Rudin, the most popular abstract algebra textbook in English, is quite dense.
- google234123 7y ago"abstract algebra", are you sure you aren't talking about analysis? It's not usually used as an introduction anyway.
- tathougies 7y agosorry yes... wrote that comment way late at night.
- guerrilla 7y agoRudin's Principles of Mathematical Analysis is the top analysis book in the US too.
- chestervonwinch 7y ago"popular"
- julianeon 7y agoI feel like it's worth pointing out here, for Americans who don't know better (no blame implied), that the French have one of the best mathematical pipelines in the world. They have almost as many Nobels (13 vs. 11) despite having 1/5 the population. Guardian article about them here: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/may/31/europa-french-maths-ecoles-normales-superieures https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/may/31/europa-french-... So please don't think France is a backwater that just doesn't know how to do math - on the contrary, it may be the best country in the world to be born into, if you want to be a mathematician. For what it's worth, I'm an American who honestly is pretty bad at math, but I try to keep learning, though I'm past an age where it will matter in college or higher education.
- lainga 7y agoDo you mean the Fields Medal?
- julianeon 7y agoHa! Yes I do. In fact you can tell my amateur-ness from this, that this misstatement didn't immediately jump out as wrong (though I do know there is no Nobel for math, when I stop and think about it). I should have said the Fields Medal, as indicated in the article.
- realbarack 7y agoA paraphrased anecdote I heard about French math education: "In America, they start by teaching you how to add two numbers, then once you've mastered that you learn to subtract, then once you've got that down you learn to multiply and divide and so forth. In France they tell you: this is an arithmetic object. The operations on it are add, subtract, multiply, and divide. It's simple! It's a good way of cranking out a bunch of Fields medalists, while everyone else has no idea what's going on."
- Koshkin 7y agoTo the question "what is 2 + 3" a French primary school pupil replied: "3 + 2, since addition is commutative". He did not know what the sum was equal to and could not even understand what he was asked about! https://www.uni-muenster.de/Physik.TP/~munsteg/arnold.html https://www.uni-muenster.de/Physik.TP/~munsteg/arnold.html
- zozbot234 7y ago> It was very operational, you calculate, you manipulate concrete data. In French books it's all theorems and concepts. "¿Por qué no los dos?" as they say? One can also detail how to "calculate" and "manipulate concrete data" in a rigorously correct way, involving precise concepts and perhaps some theorems. (Though an overemphasis on theorems is not necessarily good, either. Sometimes it can even signal a lack of attention to the actual "rules of the game" one is ultimately supposed to be studying, while a focus on direct manipulation would perhaps tend to avoid this. A good balance of the two styles is perhaps best.)
- jimmaswell 7y agoMy experience was the opposite. School in America tried to make me just memorize a bunch of stuff and it didn't work at all, but using resources like Khan Academy to build understanding and working through proofs of everything was all I needed. Lots of shallow exercises did nothing for me compared to a few deep exercises/proofs and reading.
- ssivark 7y agoIn my experience with Russian style mathematical thinking, it often involves hardcore theory in pursuit of some hard-nosed applications (where every assumption and approximation in the theory is well-motivated). When the two come together, there’s an ineffable magic and wholesomeness that I’ve seldom seen elsewhere. Some of the Russian Olympiad problems are absolute beauty.
- wutbrodo 7y ago> It also correlates with the pragmatic engineering of US history (electricity comes to mind). I got my math degree in California (at Cal) and the approach was a lot closer to what you describe French books as. Many of my courses were just a semester-long discussion of proof after proof, with breaks for exams that were more proofs.
- agumonkey 7y agoAh well my views were too biased then :)
- hgchrre 7y agoYou’re right. I’m a French student myself and our education system has always been very "Cartesian". This is also partly due to the fact that we have a special competitive exam system for entering higher education (top business and engineering schools) where you spend 2-3 years absorbing unfathomable quantities of math, economics and history/geography. The emphasis on mathematical abstraction and especially proof here is insane.
- mbeex 7y agoBourbaki school of thought. Read Dieudonné - not a single( I think to remember) illustration. Kindergarten starts math education with set theory. This was the imaginated ideal.
- rq1 7y ago> Kindergarten starts math education with set theory. Well what’s wrong with that?
- mbeex 7y agoEmphasis on 'theory', not 'set'.
- laichzeit0 7y agoNot a bad idea at all. You can have a separate class called “Arithmetic” and that can be used to learn arguably the most boring application of mathematics: operations on numbers. Maybe distinguishing mathematics from arithmetic will make people hate the subject less. Set theory alone you can get to continuum hypothesis. I’m sure children would find the idea that some infinite sets are bigger than other infinite sets quite fascinating.
- mbeex 7y ago> Set theory alone you can get to continuum hypothesis. Ironically, her independence from ZF would make the classical Bourbaki group shiver. The same way the earlier, better known, work of Goedel did. I don't know, if you are aware of Bourbakis spirit. There is something much more important in this context as the content-wise difference between sets and numbers. I never would argue against applying naive set definitions in a suiting way. But Bourbaki had an agenda, and this agenda is not for everyone (certainly not for me).
- rjsw 7y agoI'm the right age to have done New Math [1] in my first years at school, my memory of it is that it seemed fine but at age five I wasn't really thinking about comparing different educational styles. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Math https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Math
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]