7 ms·
I had a friend who had been in the Army. She really identified with "Be all that you can be", but thought the later "An Army of One" campaign sent the wrong me
by m463 7y ago
I had a friend who had been in the Army. She really identified with "Be all that you can be", but thought the later "An Army of One" campaign sent the wrong message.
(Looks like it was short-lived [1])
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slogans_of_the_United_States_Army https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slogans_of_the_United_States_A...
- ghaff 7y agoAs I recall, the Army of One was sort of part of the zeitgeist of the moment and, yeah, it fell pretty flat in the context of suggesting military loners rather than teams.
- ken 7y agoI recall my friends in college praising it at the time. To them, the biggest downside of joining the military (besides, obviously, getting killed) was that your individuality would be beaten out of you. This marketing campaign tried to show that wasn’t necessarily the case.
- grawprog 7y agoI'm not American and i've always thought it odd how many 'join the army' ads you guys have on your channels, watching cartoons as a kid on the american vs the Canadian channels we got, the american ones always had at least one join the army ad per day, while I think I could count the amount of canadian ones I remember seeing. But i'll agree I remember even then thinking the army of one ones were pretty dumb and made no sense...I also remember the be all you can be ones...that's really how great your guys state propaganda is honestly. I remember these things, still. That says something.
- wolco 7y agoIn fairness the Canadian army doesn't really need you and to get combat you really need to put in your time and volunteer for the post. In the US army depending on the timeframe you could be through basic training and in a combat zone in less than a year.
- munk-a 7y agoI'm not certain how easy it is in the forces to get cushy stay at home jobs, but Canada actually contributes disproportionately highly to armed conflict when compared to the US, it has participated heavily in quite a few recent actions[1]. Both armed forces have logistical and bureaucratic arms along but only the US (AFAICT) has a dedicated stay-at-home path via the National Guard. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_history_of_Canada#Post%E2%80%93Cold_War_era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_history_of_Canada#Pos...
- pwaivers 7y agoWhat source do you have that Canada has disproportionate contributions, compared to the US? The Wikipedia page doesn't say that.
- wolco 7y agoCanada spends disproportionately low compared to the US. It's been a source of major compliants in NATO. 1.2526% vs 3+% Canada does join many more conflicts than it should. But sometimes doesn't have the equipment to get there/back to survive (wearing green camo instead of brown in the desert is a major disadvantage).
- amanaplanacanal 7y ago> dedicated stay-at-home path via the National Guard I thought last decade that dedicated stay-at-home path meant you ended up in Iraq or Afghanistan. In other words not so stay-at-home.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoIndeed -- many National Guard units have done 4+ deployments to Afghanistan or Iraq. There was an article a while back about how the Guard used to be fat-ass weekend warriors with gear that was EOL or falling apart. After damn near 20 years of Afghanistan and Iraq most of those Guard units have been multiple times and are equipped and trained to something that resembles actually full-time line units. The Active Duty troopers still get better gear and training, but the Reserves & Guard are a completely different creature than a few decades ago.
- squarefoot 7y agoThe war business needs lots of dedicated people, therefore fueling nationalism and military pride becomes necessary to have a constant influx of applicants. This happens pretty much everywhere, although to different degrees.
- npo9 7y agoThe US army spends about $700 million on recruitment [0]. While that number has been higher recently since becoming an all volunteer army recruitment has been an expensive challenge. [0]https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2018/11/07/to-draw-more-soldiers-the-army-wants-more-recruiters-bigger-budgets-and-a-better-slogan/ https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2018/11/07/to-draw-...
- munk-a 7y agoJust to clarify - Canada doesn't have forced conscription, it also has an entirely voluntary armed forces.
- ericmay 7y agoWhat are you clarifying here?
- kennywinker 7y agoI think the supposition is that Canada also has a volunteer army, but does not spend as much on recruitment. I am not sure if that is true or not, but anecdotally it feels like there is at least 10x the amount of military recruitment ads in the US as there are in Canada.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoWell I would think the Army as the road out of poverty thing is not as big in Canada as in the U.S
- blaser-waffle 7y agoBingo. There was a awful lot of screening at MEPS -- where you go to process for the US Military, regardless of Marines/Army/Navy/Airforce -- for medical stuff. Lots of implied "do you secretly have a medical issue?" questions, as the military is responsible for paying for your healthcare. I served with a dude who entered to be a diesel mechanic (even though he had no background/interest in it) because he got his GF pregnant and didn't have a way to take care of a kid at 19. These are less of an issue in Canada, the UK, etc. where they have universal healthcare and better safety nets.
- dylan604 7y agoThe US has pretty much been at war with someone somewhere since WWII. President Eisenhower's military war complex warnings shows it was already apparent at that time. Stockpiling weapons is only so effective at keeping the complex running. It's much better to constantly be depleting the stockpiles requiring them to constantly being replenished while also needing new toys to be created. I don't know/think/research that the neighbors to the north have been involved in nearly as many conflicts. Edit: corrected the actual president. thanks ethbro
- dehrmann 7y agoYvan eht nioj.
- jariel 7y agoThe 'Army of One' ads also had people with helmets with visors wherein you couldn't see they eyes of the person, they looked like storm troopers - it's the only military ad I've really taken umbrage with. There were 'pre-movie' recruiting ads in Texas movie theatres with knights fighting dragons that turned into Marines that I though was really hilarious and pathetic, but it wasn't 'bad' just tacky. There were some other ads something along the lines of 'They called me a loser High School, but now I'm doing this and this' or whatever - which is in some way ok (most people feel like 'outsiders' in HS and teens yearn for self improvement), but maybe a little sketchy. The Army is really serious stuff, it's ok to hint at adventure, self-improvement, fraternity but at the core it must appeal to 'duty' and or kind of communitarian obligation/commitment or it's the wrong message. The individual tactics used by some recruiters are kind of deplorable, I do think however recruiters should be allowed in schools legally, just like any other employer.
- Psyladine 7y ago>The Army is really serious stuff, it's ok to hint at adventure, self-improvement, fraternity but at the core it must appeal to 'duty' and or kind of communitarian obligation/commitment or it's the wrong message. https://i.imgur.com/tzG3VXq.jpg https://i.imgur.com/tzG3VXq.jpg
- munk-a 7y agoIf that is a real Ad I love it. I also think more mundane army portrayals like this helps to defuse US separatist extremist groups while visor down or active combat portrayals fuel that fire.
- RandomBacon 7y agoOnce I read the "because we say so" part, I was convinced it wasn't legitimate. Also, the paragraph below that is quintessential mumbo-jumbo.
- fearingreprisal 7y agoWhy exactly would 'US separatist extremist groups' ( how many of these can you name? ) and secessionist groups be interested in joining the federally run US army? Wouldn't mundane army portrayals just appeal to their sense of dissatisfaction with a society that many already see as far too passive? Or, as you so smugly put it, 'fuel that fire'. You forgot to mention Cheeto Hitler in your post. There's still time to edit though, so it's okay.
- freepor 7y agoI have no experience with the Army and even I knew that "Army of One" is a dumb as shit slogan. The entire military functions only because of chain of command and submitting to the organization rather than the individual. Otherwise how else would you get someone to risk their life for something as nebulous as a "mission"?