8 ms·
My god, this is amazing. They marketed their anti-litter campaign as a state-pride manly-man issue to great success. I love it. Very intelligent hack. This is
by renewiltord 7y ago
My god, this is amazing. They marketed their anti-litter campaign as a state-pride manly-man issue to great success. I love it. Very intelligent hack.
This is also a very interesting story about the importance of diversity on a team. While TXDOT wanted to go with "Please Keep Texas Beautiful", this guy knew the kind of guy he had to convince wouldn't listen to that stuff. Brilliant.
There's another one (less successful though still successful) which I remember just because it's so catchy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Click_It_or_Ticket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Click_It_or_Ticket . When I had family visiting from elsewhere you could just say "Click It or Ticket" and they'd get it. Sure the real reason I want them to wear the seatbelt isn't because of the ticket, but the slogan combined with the fact that I can outsource the argument to the state is great.
- m463 7y agoI had a friend who had been in the Army. She really identified with "Be all that you can be", but thought the later "An Army of One" campaign sent the wrong message. (Looks like it was short-lived [1]) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slogans_of_the_United_States_Army https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slogans_of_the_United_States_A...
- ghaff 7y agoAs I recall, the Army of One was sort of part of the zeitgeist of the moment and, yeah, it fell pretty flat in the context of suggesting military loners rather than teams.
- ken 7y agoI recall my friends in college praising it at the time. To them, the biggest downside of joining the military (besides, obviously, getting killed) was that your individuality would be beaten out of you. This marketing campaign tried to show that wasn’t necessarily the case.
- grawprog 7y agoI'm not American and i've always thought it odd how many 'join the army' ads you guys have on your channels, watching cartoons as a kid on the american vs the Canadian channels we got, the american ones always had at least one join the army ad per day, while I think I could count the amount of canadian ones I remember seeing. But i'll agree I remember even then thinking the army of one ones were pretty dumb and made no sense...I also remember the be all you can be ones...that's really how great your guys state propaganda is honestly. I remember these things, still. That says something.
- wolco 7y agoIn fairness the Canadian army doesn't really need you and to get combat you really need to put in your time and volunteer for the post. In the US army depending on the timeframe you could be through basic training and in a combat zone in less than a year.
- munk-a 7y agoI'm not certain how easy it is in the forces to get cushy stay at home jobs, but Canada actually contributes disproportionately highly to armed conflict when compared to the US, it has participated heavily in quite a few recent actions[1]. Both armed forces have logistical and bureaucratic arms along but only the US (AFAICT) has a dedicated stay-at-home path via the National Guard. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_history_of_Canada#Post%E2%80%93Cold_War_era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_history_of_Canada#Pos...
- pwaivers 7y agoWhat source do you have that Canada has disproportionate contributions, compared to the US? The Wikipedia page doesn't say that.
- wolco 7y agoCanada spends disproportionately low compared to the US. It's been a source of major compliants in NATO. 1.2526% vs 3+% Canada does join many more conflicts than it should. But sometimes doesn't have the equipment to get there/back to survive (wearing green camo instead of brown in the desert is a major disadvantage).
- jariel 7y agoThe 'Army of One' ads also had people with helmets with visors wherein you couldn't see they eyes of the person, they looked like storm troopers - it's the only military ad I've really taken umbrage with. There were 'pre-movie' recruiting ads in Texas movie theatres with knights fighting dragons that turned into Marines that I though was really hilarious and pathetic, but it wasn't 'bad' just tacky. There were some other ads something along the lines of 'They called me a loser High School, but now I'm doing this and this' or whatever - which is in some way ok (most people feel like 'outsiders' in HS and teens yearn for self improvement), but maybe a little sketchy. The Army is really serious stuff, it's ok to hint at adventure, self-improvement, fraternity but at the core it must appeal to 'duty' and or kind of communitarian obligation/commitment or it's the wrong message. The individual tactics used by some recruiters are kind of deplorable, I do think however recruiters should be allowed in schools legally, just like any other employer.
- Psyladine 7y ago>The Army is really serious stuff, it's ok to hint at adventure, self-improvement, fraternity but at the core it must appeal to 'duty' and or kind of communitarian obligation/commitment or it's the wrong message. https://i.imgur.com/tzG3VXq.jpg https://i.imgur.com/tzG3VXq.jpg
- munk-a 7y agoIf that is a real Ad I love it. I also think more mundane army portrayals like this helps to defuse US separatist extremist groups while visor down or active combat portrayals fuel that fire.
- RandomBacon 7y agoOnce I read the "because we say so" part, I was convinced it wasn't legitimate. Also, the paragraph below that is quintessential mumbo-jumbo.
- fearingreprisal 7y agoWhy exactly would 'US separatist extremist groups' ( how many of these can you name? ) and secessionist groups be interested in joining the federally run US army? Wouldn't mundane army portrayals just appeal to their sense of dissatisfaction with a society that many already see as far too passive? Or, as you so smugly put it, 'fuel that fire'. You forgot to mention Cheeto Hitler in your post. There's still time to edit though, so it's okay.
- freepor 7y agoI have no experience with the Army and even I knew that "Army of One" is a dumb as shit slogan. The entire military functions only because of chain of command and submitting to the organization rather than the individual. Otherwise how else would you get someone to risk their life for something as nebulous as a "mission"?
- dahfizz 7y ago> They marketed their anti-litter campaign as a state-pride manly-man issue to great success. I don't know why people don't do this with environmental issues at large. In my experience, conservatives care about the environment more than anyone. They live in the woods and hunt and fish and enjoy nature daily. But it's become a partisan issue so they don't listen. Surely someone can come up with a clever slogan to get convince conservatives to conserve nature.
- egberts1 7y agoNuclear: zero-carbon energy. #headduck
- archgoon 7y agoUnfortunately, despite prominent climate scientists like James Hansen advocating that Nuclear be considered a tool in the toolbox for combating Climate Change, it's been regularly dismissed by many activists it seems. Foolish, it would have been an excellent talking point to communicate that environmentalists were serious about this problem and weren't simply trying to leverage it to push their personal wish list of policy proposals. Missed opportunities.
- munk-a 7y agoUS Energy interests did a really bad thing in the 70s, 80s and 90s that's lead to this bull-headed knee-jerk response from a lot of otherwise environmentally minded people. At the same time... in Vermont the Vermont Yankee[1] plant destroyed anyone's ability to reasonably advocate for safe nuclear power by repeatedly violating the public trust to make a quick buck and saddling the state with a heavy burden, specifically: > In December 2014, Entergy submitted the Post Shutdown Decommissioning Report to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. This report estimated that the total cost for decommissioning the reactor would be $1.24 billion. The same document reported that only $665 million had been collected in the 42 years of operations of this plant for this purpose. Entergy hopes to raise some of the shortfall funds through "external financing". The sorta TL;DR here is that nuclear power, at the tech level we had in the 70s/80s/90s is incompatible with capitalism and the greed that goes with it. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermont_Yankee_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermont_Yankee_Nuclear_Power_P...
- leggomylibro 7y agoYeah, I noticed these signs along the highways in Texas when I was driving around the US. And I chuckled at how they used the "Don't mess with Texas" phrase despite having much lower littering fines than most other states. Like with everything else in this country, it's all about the marketing.
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y agoTexas seems on the heavier side of the fines/jail time, at least normal. https://www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resources/states-with-littering-penalties.aspx https://www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resour...
- leggomylibro 7y agoInteresting - you learn something new every day. I guess my trip was probably biased towards states with lots of parks and forests, who probably had more incentive to protect their local environments.
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y agoOut of curiosity which states did you visit? Texas has amazing (and clean!) state and national parks as well. Definitely worth a visit, especially Big Bend.
- leggomylibro 7y agoOh, mostly the forest-y and nature-y states - Arkansas, Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, Idaho, Tennessee, Kentucky, Arizona, Washington, Oregon, California...I would've liked to see more of Montana and Michigan, but it gets cold up there in the winters. Mostly I drove through Texas to avoid Oklahoma (one of my least favorite states), but the Guadalupe Mountains were very nice. I'm not sure I'd call it 'clean' though; the air seemed awfully smoggy and I saw almost as many flaring wells as I did in North Dakota. But there were lots of open spaces and the people were friendly. Washington, Arkansas, New Mexico, and Utah get my vote for the best places to do a parks/forests vacation, depending on your interests.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- goatherders 7y agoMy mother worked on the Keep Texas Beautiful campaign. It played a role as well in reducing the littering in Texas.
- whitebread 7y agoDallasite here. While the marketing campaign was very catchy, it has fallen on hard times. Take a walk or drive through Dallas, and you’ll quickly become crestfallen with the amount of litter constantly flowing with the breeze. It’s a disgrace.
- Kikawala 7y agoH-E-B also uses state-pride in their marketing campaigns and store branded products. https://www.eater.com/2018/12/11/18133776/heb-texas-origin-cult-following https://www.eater.com/2018/12/11/18133776/heb-texas-origin-c...
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Click It or Ticket I've always hated this one because there is a significant contingent of people who disagree with seatbelt laws -- even if they themselves always wear their seatbelts -- because it's a central example of a law that shouldn't exist when the role of criminal law is to save innocent people from bad people and not idiots from themselves. And then the campaign feels like a direct attack on the people who don't agree with the law, which encourages defiance, which is the exact opposite of the intended effect. With the further effect of making people angry while they're driving a car, which dangerous in itself. The cynic may also notice that such laws are commonly passed in order to generate revenue, in which case stimulating defiance could be fully intentional because more defiance generates more revenue.
- Spare_account 7y agoThere are external costs when someone doesn't wear their seatbelt. First responders are kept busy tending to their needs when they are injured. Ambulances and hospital resources are kept busy when they otherwise wouldn't need to be. Rear seat passengers not wearing seatbelts can directly injure front seat passengers who did not consent to the risk. To argue that the seatbelt law impacts on personal freedom seems shortsighted to me.
- renewiltord 7y agoThis was an interesting hypothesis. I enjoyed the idea so I wanted to see what probability I should assign the idea that the defiance-effect overrules the compliance-effect. Interestingly, there is one state which does not have a mandatory front seat adult passenger seat-belt law which gives us the ability to test what effect that has. New Hampshire: No adult front-seat passenger seat-belt law. Beltedness: 67.6% Lowest beltedness (any law): Massachusetts (73.7%), secondary enforcement (i.e. if you violated another driving law then you can be cited for the seatbelt thing too) Lowest beltedness (primary enforcement): Mississippi (78.8%) Regardless of the paternalism angle (which I'm sympathetic to because I would like drug use to be permitted, etc.) this would appear as evidence that the defiance-effect is overruled by the compliance-effect. Certainly, it is sufficient enough for me to not look further into the subject. Standard HN disclaimer so we don't get into some Internet war: Not attempting to refute anything you're saying. Just sharing my conclusions. Your priors and your weights to evidence may yield different posteriors. I do not require you to convince me and I am not aiming to convince you. The hypothesis I wanted to test may slightly vary from yours due to my interests being different and to aim for easier falsification. The existence of this disclaimer is not intended to be evidence that I believe you will engage in an Internet argument.
- npunt 7y ago[I was wrong, ignore]
- mardifoufs 7y agoIt says on the linked wiki page: "The campaign is credited with reducing litter on Texas highways roughly 72% between 1987 and 1990" So it seems to have worked very well!
- npunt 7y agoApologies I stand corrected! No idea how I missed that. Thanks!
- conductr 7y ago1980s kid & have lived in Texas my whole life. The slogan had a instant impact on behavior. Litter was a pretty bad problem. I remember it was common behavior to just toss stuff out the window while driving. Drink can/bottle, wrappers, cigarette butts, pretty much anything; some people would even dump trash on the side of the highway. It got a lot better and fairly quick so I believe the 70%+ stat mentioned. While I'm on this train of thought. Most/many trucks in Texas had a gun rack with a rifle or two hanging across the rear window. Nobody wore seat belts until kids my age were taught to go home and nag their parents through PSA/Sex Ed/DARE style school lessons. It ended up being pretty effective.