4 ms·
that is false. first of all, a lack of imagination does not mean we have a single tool to fight a coronavirus. shelter in place is perhaps the single tool in yo
by modzu 6y ago
that is false. first of all, a lack of imagination does not mean we have a single tool to fight a coronavirus. shelter in place is perhaps the single tool in your mind, not in the world. secondly, it is absolutely more complicated than that. economy vs health is a flase dichotomy. like the trolly problem one option seems obvious (save the crowd) but the implications for the other choice are, importantly, equally valid if less obvious : it means mudering a person. so maybe letting the trolly hit the crowd is the moral choice? in this case what are the effects of each choice? im not an american but dont americans pay for healthcare? so isnt a poor american worse off in terms of health outcomes? anyway even focusing on the health, here's an exercise that might get you to think deeply about it. coronavirus is a respiratory disease. it turns out that means if you're in good lung health you have much better odds of recovering. so one way to think about 'treatment' is treating lung health. many health problems are addressed this way -- holistically. where is our cure against lung cancer? its too hard to fight lung cancer qua cancer. but we are doing a fantastic job of eliminating it by eliminating smoking. you can stay inside your home and not catch any transmissable disease whatsoever. but the consequences of this are absolutely not merely economic!
- camgunz 6y ago> that is false. first of all, a lack of imagination does not mean we have a single tool to fight a coronavirus. The fact that we need to imagine more options means we only have the one.
- modzu 6y agowhile i dont follow the logic (what color is your shirt? if you need to imagine other options it means you only have the one?), if i interpret you charitably you might have thought i meant "imaginative" as in not realistic. but i simply meant there are other possibilities. the phrase "failure of imagination" has a somewhat technical definition: it means something obvious in retrospect that most people didnt think about until after a fact. like how it is obvious a plane could be hijacked. if i had to guess, id say the common conception (at least in NA) that there aren't other options to fight this virus is possibly because public knowledge of the pandemic is largely via news/entertainment media (compare for reference any other subject matter).